‘birthday surprise’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
birthday surprise 

Category

Wife's new friend

Yet another lucky husband gets birthday surprise.

4.01
24.2k
21
11
58
0

New Neighbor Birthday Surprise

My relationship with our new neighbor continues to develop.

4.4
18.5k
14
6
19

My Brother's Best Friend Ch. 02

The birthday girl gets an amazing birthday present.

H
4.77
21.4k
21
9
28

Harleys Surprise

Identical twins surprise Harley for her birthday.

4.46
15.7k
14
0
29
0

Holy Frijoles: A PapaToad Flash Story

It was a birthday surprise, for everyone.

0
61.7k
79
0
98
0

She Shoots, He Scores

High school senior gets girl of his dreams on 18th birthday.

H
4.55
48.7k
39
4
59
0

DJ Pt. 11

DJ's Surprise BD Party almost kills him, makes out like bandit.

H
4.67
4.4k
1
3
2

DJ Pt. 10

DJ's surprise 20th BD Party, Jamie & DJ virgins no more.

H
4.53
5.5k
5
2
6

DJ Pt. 09

DJ & Jamie experiment with anal sex.

H
4.56
7.3k
6
3
6

Kelsey's World Ch. 31

Wendy's Birthday.

H
4.82
30.5k
12
0
19

Mid-Life Crisis

Health scare leads to lifestyle change.

4.17
66.6k
35
47
47
0

Weird Fantasies 16: Birthday

i get flogged as a birthday present.

3.98
28.3k
4
0
8

Birthday Strap-On Surprise

Public sex and pegging.

4.49
73.6k
72
5
91
0

Plus One

He gets a threesome for his birthday.

4.44
41.5k
15
1
22
0

Best For Who Ch. 02

Some stability returns to his life.

H
4.59
24.4k
5
2
10

Matty Meets Kimmy

Coeds meet via mutual friends and fall hard for each other.

H
4.56
62.6k
56
10
85

Between Friends

A disatisfied wife makes an extraordinary request.

4.03
73.1k
12
8
19
0

Vanilla with Cream

Women explore new bi-sides while pleasuring their man.

H
4.65
102.6k
47
7
65

Thirty-Six Photographs

One man's dark and disturbing fetish.

3.73
49.6k
5
0
11
0

A Birthday Surprise

He is visited by a beautiful stranger on his birthday.

4.44
42.7k
2
2
5
0

A Pagan Birthday

A family plans a party for Adam and Eve

4.19
88.6k
20
2
22
0

Birthday Surprise

An erotic birthday adventure.

4.17
35.1k
5
0
11
0

A Cock and Cum Birthday

Wife gives me a 43rd birthday surprise.

4.06
245.9k
43
16
55
0

Birthday Surprise

Danielle gives hubby a present he won't forget.

4.39
61.9k
6
1
8
0

Home Office Seduction

A birthday he will never forget.

4.39
47.2k
6
1
9
0

Encounters with Mia: Sixth

He finds a birthday surprise beneath his desk.

4.3
26.4k
00
4

The Surprise Ch. 1

Lee prepares birthday surprise with a twist.

4.27
16.7k
00
3
0

Sally's Birthday Surprise

Sally gets gangbanged on her birthday.

4.04
174.5k
14
0
28
0

My Birthday Surprise

From the restaurant to unexpected penetration.

3.36
48.3k
2
0
4
0

Arizona Delight

She makes lover's fantasy threesome come true.

3.98
55.2k
2
0
2
0

The Birthday Present

What a surprise husband receives!

3.22
95.5k
17
0
24
0

Birthday Surprise

Wife acts out fantasy for husband on his birthday.

3.74
128.9k
14
0
18
0

Anal Birthday Surprise

Guy gets quite a present from sister's girlfriends.

3.52
73.9k
7
0
11
0

Virgin Teen

Brother's caught with present when sis comes home early.

3.69
1.03M
25
0
28
0
Active tags
Active tags
birthday surprise
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ