‘butt plug’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
butt plug 

Category

Librarian

Challenged to spend a day naked.

4.35
12.9k
10
5
37

It Started Innocently Enough

Shoe fetish turns into an exploration of gender & D/s roles.

4.43
4.1k
4
1
12
0

Princess of Everdale Ch. 06

Talia learns the truth about Alec's past.

H
4.69
1.8k
1
0
3

Achievement Unlocked

Anal-curious man gets a new toy and reaches a longtime goal.

4.16
10.3k
6
1
21
0

Taylor Begins her New Job

Taylor starts work at Andrea's club and much more.

H
4.62
5.9k
5
0
13
0

Trust Me Ch. 04

Rugby and a stimulating dinner and car ride.

4
1.4k
00
1

Teasing Daddy Pt. 03

Teasing Daddy so he punishes me in the night ;)

4.42
6.8k
5
0
10

Jessica's Awakening Ch. 03

The party continues...

H
4.74
8.1k
11
2
19

Jessica's Awakening Ch. 02

Stacy and Jessica return to the party...

H
4.76
8.1k
12
3
21

Return to the Lake Ch. 04

The couples change it up.

H
4.8
8.4k
5
0
10

A Birthday to Remember

A follow up to "A night of firsts".

0
17.9k
14
8
25
0

Good Girl Ch. 02: New Beginnings

Sissy takes a big leap toward her new life.

H
4.65
14.1k
15
2
22

Watching You Cum and Cum Again

You are my horny cumslut to use for my enjoyment, and yours.

4.45
10.9k
7
0
19
0

Average High School Life Ch. 11

Alternate Title: Having Twins.

H
4.87
8.4k
17
1
32

Sleeping with My Boss Ch. 02

Robin and Elizabeth invite Hazel into their bed.

H
4.85
22.7k
41
18
70

The Club - A New Member

Erik's young life suddenly gets more interesting.

4.38
6.7k
4
0
12
0

Anal Sex In Kev’s Car

Anal sex in Kev's Car.

4.41
19.8k
10
5
18

Jenna Improvement Program Ch. 08

Maria humiliates Jenna to orgasm in the food court.

H
4.76
13.7k
10
7
15

Sharing my Wife Michelle

Wife's fantasy of being shared is finally fulfilled.

4.12
49.1k
35
18
79
0

An Unexpected Turn of Events

After leaking her sex tape, Brie tries to make a break.

H
4.8
5.1k
5
0
11

Young Couples Awakening Ch. 02

The couple expand their sexual horizon.

4.38
3.9k
4
1
11

Susan's First Challenge

Susan is given a challenge by Mistress.

H
4.65
7.2k
17
3
30
0

Rehead's Hike to Pleasure

Redhead get's BBC on a Hike.

4.18
15.2k
17
1
33
0

Liberty Summer Ch. 03

A mother daughter dance off and meeting the neighbors.

H
4.62
9.6k
16
4
29

Little Bo Peep - The Third Outing

Jan and Tiger make their way towards Japan.

H
4.57
1.8k
1
1
3

Losing my Anal Virginity to Nichole

How buttplugs and dildos lead me to lose my anal virginity.

H
4.57
23.9k
32
3
63

A Public Handjob and Anal Creampie

A hand job in a cinema becomes a plugged, anal creampie.

H
4.54
25.7k
23
1
46
0

My Exhibitionist Nudist Daughter Ch. 09

Our night of fun with friends continues and Sam gets bolder.

4.44
14.3k
24
5
39

Mid-day, Midnight, and Morning

A loving wife welcomes her husband home from a long absence.

3.77
13.7k
24
4
43
0

The Boyfriend Pt. 55

Tasha surprises Liam and hangs out while he has a plug in.

H
4.68
5.3k
4
8
8

Gaming vs. Femboy Ch. 05

Extreme cum sharing and experiencing orc and demon dick.

H
4.81
11.5k
54
20
79

Gaming vs. Femboy Ch. 04

Clothes shopping, questing, and tentacle attacks.

H
4.77
12.2k
39
8
62

Gaming vs. Femboy Ch. 03

Time with Adora, the Church of Femboy, and a new magic item.

H
4.81
9.6k
43
4
71

A Weekend at the Lake Ch. 12

A New Experience for Michael and Stephanie.

H
4.61
5.9k
8
5
12
0

Miss Pamela Six

Miss Pamela and Desiree torment Tommy.

4.49
7.3k
2
2
6

Only Consenting Adults Ch. 05

Quinn serves Mistress Candice in an entirely unexpected way.

H
4.59
3.4k
2
4
9

Daddy's Little Gymnast Ch. 06

Audra and Misty see a solution to the Natalia 'problem'.

H
4.75
15.6k
34
6
61

Office Encounters Pt. 03

Diaries of a secret slut. Does she finally seduce daddy?

4.38
5.6k
3
1
6

Pam's Shemale Experience Ch. 18

The shemales and the sluts get together.

H
4.75
4.2k
8
3
13

Solo Flashing at the Mall

I spend the day flashing and masturbating at the mall.

H
4.69
14k
24
4
49
0

Kate Returns Home Ch. 35

Nicole and Cynthia face complaints, discipline, get revenge.

4.5
2.1k
0
1
2

Jenna Improvement Program Ch. 06-07

Maria takes advantage of Jenna at the mall.

H
4.7
13.6k
19
6
25

Shared Against my Will Ch. 02

Still tied, still shared, still pleasured.

H
4.51
49.5k
56
5
97

Sith Lost Ch. 11

Miley gets on her knees for her Mistress.

4.67
2.4k
1
0
4

Shared Against my Will

Husband binds me, helps his friends rape me.

4.45
111.5k
145
14
270
0

Anniversary Fling Pt. 04

Sandy continues Jill's slut-wife training with Reed's help.

H
4.79
6.1k
12
8
27

A Different Kind of Sex Toy Ch. 20

Allie and Katrina livestream a sex show.

0
6.5k
9
6
21

My Mom is a Slut Ch. 08

The two new slaves begin to learn what is expected of them...

4.44
18.1k
23
29
47

Mickie and Laurie Pt. 05

Laurie discovers she can enjoy sex in chastity.

H
4.54
15.1k
11
1
19

The Boyfriend Pt. 16

Lexi tells Marie to finger herself in a changing room.

H
4.58
7.3k
2
0
4

The Boyfriend Pt. 15

Marie asks Lexi for a picture. Lexi makes her earn it.

H
4.56
4.1k
1
0
2

Mickie and Laurie Pt. 04

Our narrator gets acquainted with a dildo, and starts HRT.

H
4.68
13.2k
17
8
26

Korrupting Kayla Pt. 07

Kayla attends another toy party with Tiffany.

H
4.76
15.7k
9
3
17

The Female Lead

The DILF from Sabrina's younger days comes for her.

H
4.63
7.5k
15
2
27
0

Unravel Me Ch. 01

Could Layla be Ben's new voluptuous sub?

H
4.52
2.8k
5
1
9
0

Rita's Coming Out Party

Courtney's swonong party.

4.16
5.6k
8
0
19
0

Jill's Story - Sex, Sex & More sex Pt. 09

More cock for Jill & James goes "Bi".

H
4.89
4.8k
7
0
13

Come Get What You Deserve Pt. 02 [F4F]

Please, Let Me Express My Gratitude.

0
6.5k
2
4
9

Nate and Kaya Ch. 03

Kaya starts playing with toys and Nate notices.

H
4.66
15.7k
32
13
47

The Surrogate Pt. 05

Gina and Cassy get used to their piercings.

4.16
6.8k
4
1
9

Safeword: Rosso Corsa

Like Classic Cars, Classy Cunts need to be warmed before use

4.43
4.6k
1
2
5
0

Sissy Slave to my Ex Pt. 04

I was now being used in public by my new Mistress.

4.44
23.8k
14
2
21

Side Slut Ch. 01

Young wife offers her sister for her big-dicked spouse’s use.

4.24
110.8k
196
24
452

Somewhere Between Love and Lust Ch. 03

Tammy, Veronica and I take acid together.

4.38
3k
3
0
6

Sith Lost Ch. 08

Miley and Orllah attend a party.

4
1.1k
00
2

Assimilated

Veteran in a jungle war is captured and turned by his enemy.

4.29
10.6k
9
4
27
0

The Perfect Fuck Buddy Ch. 07

Ariel wants to try something new.

H
4.58
11.3k
22
1
28

Jenna Improvement Program Ch. 04-05

Dr. Truce gives Jenna a slutty outfit to wear at the mall.

H
4.7
14.2k
20
9
31

Chapter 02 - Getting Ready

Getting ready for a busy weekend.

4.49
8.9k
5
0
10

The Surrogate Pt. 04

Gina submits to Mike and Cassy.

4.41
8.5k
9
0
14

The Room

A sexual smorgasbord.

3.89
7.1k
2
0
8
0

The Outer Veil, Ch. 01

A cute boy's journey to sacred and forbidden realms.

4.38
4.7k
2
0
10
0

Chapter 01 - Red & Black

While her master is away he monitors her every move.

4.39
15k
17
1
73

A Businessman's Sissy Pt. 02

David and Samantha’s relationship grows. Samantha is taken.

H
4.7
14.2k
17
10
28

Skybound Desires Ch. 08

Kitten submits to her "funishment".

H
4.6
4.2k
2
0
5

Breaking News - Ch. 01

A ball slapping, ass banging, raunchy D/s fuck ...

H
4.53
9k
14
10
33

A Businessman's Sissy Pt. 01

A sissy is discovered and taken by a local businessman.

H
4.71
25.5k
41
17
63

Crumbling Memories Ch. 01

A bus ride sparks Lisa and Vicky's unique bond.

H
4.65
9.9k
5
4
18

Babygirl Watches

Babygirl fulfills fantasy of watching Daddy fuck a girl.

4.11
15.7k
8
1
25
0

#1 MILF - Teenage Nut November

Nicci runs into Matt's mom on her way to a holiday stuffing.

4.38
21.1k
17
1
27

Controlling My Personal Assistant Ch. 02

Marie buys and inserts toys, we meet her flatmate.

H
4.5
19.5k
10
3
21

Curt and the Charity Auction Ch. 01

Tina sells Curt at an auction and promises “services”.

4.47
9.1k
16
1
37

Nichole's Circle Party

Nichole and 4 of her shemale friends give me a lot of cum.

H
4.72
17.7k
24
7
57

Too Good To Be True Ch. 16

More sexy shenanigans with Cindy.

H
4.79
9k
19
2
29

Seduction of the Older Woman

Day takes a turn when her daughter's friend comes over.

4.38
36.9k
39
10
65
0

Crafting Submission

Submissive Tanya discovers a way to subjugate her Mistress.

H
4.76
5.2k
6
3
20
0

Employee Discipline Ch. 03

Delilah has dinner with Ms. Verity.

H
4.74
7.6k
9
3
15

The Thrill of Submission

Power dynamics and humiliation Mei experiences in her role.

4.4
9k
2
0
16

Nora - Embracing an Erotic Life Ch. 13

A New Guest for Dinner--and for After Dinner!

4.47
4.1k
7
5
12

Feeding Kitten Their Leftovers

Kitten gets their leftovers from mistress and husband.

H
4.63
19.1k
24
5
55
0

#1 MILF - Teen Nut November

Nicci runs into Matt's mom on the way to a holiday stuffing.

4.41
8.1k
11
0
24
Active tags
Active tags
butt plug
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ