‘first time anal sex’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
first time anal sex 

Category

Joy Ride on I-55

Couple’s road trip escalates into a wild night.

4.38
10.7k
6
2
13
0

Spring Breaking Pt. 02

Sarah goes from a quiet girl to a partying anal lover.

H
4.67
19.5k
13
0
27

Trust Me...

Maybe you shouldn't...heh, heh, heh...

H
4.58
8.7k
8
3
14
0

In Praise of Older Women

Surprise Seduction - Bachelorette Party - Happy Reunion.

4.38
33.8k
29
9
38
0

Be Careful What You Wish For Pt. 02

The "rape" fantasy continues in the back of a van

H
4.54
46.5k
27
2
43

What Goes Around, Comes Around

A young Asian female golfer repays a random act of kindness.

H
4.52
16k
16
3
21
0

Shall We Play?

A sex game goes all the way.

4.21
46.4k
13
0
17
0

Rewards of Random Kindness

A lonely girl and a freely given umbrella.

4.43
15.7k
10
2
10
0

Edna, My Asian Seductress

Lost my virginity and innocence– gained an Asian mistress.

4.48
43.6k
49
3
66
0

Getting What You Need

Finding that missing piece of your life.

H
4.61
27.7k
16
4
27

Technically You are Still a Virgin...

How Shari kept her vow of chastity...sort of...

H
4.52
23.4k
19
2
31
0

DDlg: A Little Lesson

Little Bunny learns to take your cock in her ass hole.

4.29
73.8k
29
4
37
0

Mike

I finally have him.

4.02
24.4k
1
1
4
0

College Judo Ch. 01

Shane gives too much info, and Matt capitalizes on it.

4.48
67.2k
53
1
72

It's About Time Ch. 02

More fantasies get fulfilled.

4.43
16.9k
1
1
1

First Times are the Best Ch. 02

First time having gay sex.

4.29
44.8k
11
11
12

Ashleigh's Carnal Friends Ch. 01

John fulfills Ashleigh's sexual needs.

H
4.56
45.6k
36
1
45

First Time Anal Fuck

Alice has her very first anal experience.

4.39
143.8k
39
3
54
0

Rolling in Pine Needles

A 50+ kayaker gets lucky with a horny 24 year old.

H
4.56
149.7k
11
9
15
0
Active tags
Active tags
first time anal sex
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ