‘first time gay sex’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
first time gay sex 

Category

Dad's Friend Gave Me a Hot Massage

Dad's friends agrees to help relieve my pain with his cock.

H
4.67
34.6k
90
12
136
0

Straight Roommate needs a blowjob

My straight roommate politely asked me for a blowjob.

H
4.74
24.3k
41
9
88
0

Beach Bum Pick Up

They meet on a beach and spend a hot, sweaty afternoon.

H
4.62
12.4k
10
8
21
0

Rummates Pt. 08

Know how to peel a pink banana?

4.43
2.6k
4
3
6

Get Out! Ch. 03

More about Thomas & Ashley.

H
4.89
2.9k
4
5
7

David Agrees to Gay Sex

Straight guy David agrees to be filmed with gay guys.

4.38
20.8k
17
3
28
0

No Longer a Show Ch. 02

Straight cam dude meets IRL for first gay anal sex.

4.32
12.6k
21
3
24

Escape Room for Jocks Pt. 08

The 4 jocks discover some other people involved in the game.

H
4.54
13.8k
35
8
42

Escape Room for Jocks Pt. 07

A puzzle needs to be solved before the jocks can advance.

H
4.6
12.5k
17
4
22

David and Donny Ch. 01

An inexperienced young man gets more than he bargained for.

4.43
24.3k
22
5
30
0

My Roommate Mark Pt. 02

Mark wants to try something new.

4.47
34.3k
30
3
40

First Tape

Old man's tapes give young man a boner.

4.37
47.7k
44
10
49
0

Mountain Man

College grad finds gay sex in the Rockies with a hot Daddy.

H
4.65
70k
77
11
100
0

My First Time Sex with Uncle Pt. 01

A story of bisexual young guy trying gay sex first time.

3.98
87.1k
17
5
23

Two Days with Ulrike Ch. 03

Adam is forced into gay sex.

4.34
38.8k
28
2
31

Redhead's First time on Friday

A true story about a young man's first gay encounters.

4.41
65.4k
23
10
26
0

Dominated By and Older Couple

Bicurious guy is dominated by couple and has gay sex.

4.25
150.6k
58
7
76
0

High and Low Ch. 05

Sliding over the edge and falling into temptation.

4.18
23.5k
6
3
7

Caught in the Act

Jeremy gets caught, and now he must accept the punishment.

4.21
84.6k
22
7
27
0

My Best Friend's Dad

18-year-old boy's fantasies realized with older stud.

4.12
179.6k
35
8
43
0
Active tags
Active tags
first time gay sex
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ