‘first time gay’ stories

My first experience as a Bottom.

Sam visits his grandfather at his retirement home.

A college freshman discovers his bisexuality.

Painful straight breakup leads me to explore hidden desires.

Sexy Irish lacrosse stud submits to horse-hung freshmen.

Straight married man attemps redemption after forced blowjob.

Timothy encounters 2 strangers at the gym.

A young, straight married man gives his first blowjob.

He wanted to see if I inherited his dick.

My best friend's boyfriend and I discover our fetishes.

Innocent shower peeping escalates into much more.

A walk in the park turned my straight life upside down.

Married Man in Desperate Need.

A mother in law comes up with a devious plan.

Stationed in a war zone, a soldier has to escape.

Being fucked for a first time... by two big cocks.

Peter takes me to bed.

A young man and his older neighbour.

Motorcop meets equestrian couple.

Caught my boss jerking off and he makes me finish it.

Small town soccer players submit to the enemy team.

Finally going to a gay bathhouse.

The Jocks are getting intimate with two more teammates.

An older man from work seduced me when I was 18.

With Maggie's turn complete, Taisha puts Sam in his place.

Blake goes to sleep with Vinh & wakes with Linc.

I give all of myself to him for the first time.

Blake submits to Linc, Vinh, Park, Jae, Jung and Lee at once.

An unusual adventure when I was a young man.

A game of truth or dare in the spa.

BFFs (1F, 3 "straight" M) explore first gay sex experiences.

An innocent birthday gift turns into a new F/F experience

BFFs (1F 2M) give Cole (M) his first gay sexual experience.

Four BFFs (3M, 1F) explore beyond their previous sexualities.

A young college student wants to lose his V card... but not.

With the lockdown in full swing, two housemates make do.

Adrian finds love in a small town after living in London.

Colin is my first. He will not be my last!

Billy comes over to another house party at Jess' and Dylan's.

First bisexual orgy with my insatiable wife.

Alpha bull finally takes all of me.

Sex starved husband ends up pleasing man from Craigslist.

Seduced at my apartment gym.

A young widower needs a release and Phil can't say no.

I agree to be one of her test subjects.

BFFs to lovers - 1st gay sex experience of 2 "straight" men.

My BFF finally gives me to a real man.

I do a little more exploring of this newfound curiosity...

Turns out I'm a little more curious than I thought...

How far can Sara make the boys go?

Damian explores his control over Nevermore.

Jake and his straight teammate chat in the showers post-game.

Time away with my best friend.

One new game, two more team mates, one winner.

Two straight guys trapped in the snow do what they must.

Landon, Gabe and the brothers go camping.

An alpha bull turns a straight man into a submissive slut.

Preston goes deeper with his new Daddy.

First time gay in filthy service station.

Straight cam dude meets IRL for first gay anal sex.

Straight live cam guy tries first gay blowjob to make cash.

Wild date ends at a glory hole.

Femboy and his drunk older brother are left alone.

Jake satisfies his star player after the team's first win.

Scared boy learns a painful truth about himself.

A Christmas wish come true, or is it...

Two straight buddies experience more of eachother.

Fantasy Football Punishment Takes a Turn.

A neighborhood jog leads to first time magic.

John and President May form a father/son bond.

A girlfriend widens her boyfriend's horizons and his hole.

My seduction by my university's president begins...

The jocks their weaknesses are again tested.

Straight for 22 years, until I see his cock.

My journey from fingers, to dildos, and finally to cocks.

The race continues.

The race is on between the 4 jocks.

The jocks play another game and meet eachother.

Adventures of four close friends.

A story of a first time blow job in Vegas.

Housemates can't sleep - follow up on "Desperate Times..."

Unexpected seduction during quarantine desperation.

Shy guy sets out to solve an XXL college dorm mystery.

A desire to experiment with gay sex is fulfilled by a BBC.

Laura talks Tommy into trying it with a man.

Aunt introduces me to her lifestyle.

They continue their sexual bucket list in Palm Springs.

Married coworker and I have first male sex experience.

Finding myself surrounded by bicurious thoughts.

A Buck's Party at a Virtual Reality club.

My first time getting filled up after years of fantasizing.

Alisha sets me up for a date with a gay man.

Aaron's father figure forces him to learn a new life lesson.

A story of how Malcolm lost his virginity.

Two housemates are stuck in quarantine together.

The weekend fun continues for the cousins and a friend.

First time with a man, started at the Adult Movie House.

Sex. Drugs. Burning Man.

My ex girlfriend gets revenge.

Str8 boy gets best head of his life from virgin cocksucker.