‘first time’ stories

Who's up for drinking games with six beautiful Futas?

Friends suck & fuck for the first time in his dorm.

Things heat up with Gary's sister, +1 unexpected relative.

The title says it all.

All good things must come at the end.

Play fight with little sister leads to curiosity and fun.

Siblings love watching TV, but they love each other more.

Parker has a birthday to remember.

He pushed his daughter into the arms of his friend.

Innocent Lola gets a night she will never forget.

Two troubled men find each other at an airport gate.

Sexy co-ed seduces not one, but two MILF flight attendants.

Redefining the boundaries of The Rule.

Danielle get trapped in a Glory hole, with one way out.

Game of Edward 40 Hands turns me into my true slutty self

Aaron's new black boyfriend teaches him his place.

A sister saves her brother from a horrible life at home.

Ralphie wants just one thing for Christmas.

Miracles come in different kinds of packages.

A Rocky boat ride, and a meeting with Mom.

Miracles can happen on Christmas Eve...

Elliot learns to handle Libby's cock...semi-consensually.

An average guy gains the confidence to seduce women.

Sara wants older brother Ben to entertain her.

BBW Mom and her virgin son discover love.

Young woman is deflowered by her boyfriend's bully.

Falling helplessly in love with my straight best friend.

Catherine is hired to appear nude for an upscale party.

Teen’s first family breeding day is a bit too successful.

Husband and wife meet a stranger on a business trip.

Straight man's interview includes taking cock in both holes.

Virgin student's summer job search lands her in a porn film.

The secret's out.

18-year-old guy saves his mother from an intruder.

Straight shy guy walks into an adult theatre in late 1980's.

Emily ends up in a misunderstanding with the popular girl.

When Sam's mom leaves, her stepfather takes what's his.

Is my sister encouraging our cousin to flirt with me?

Ryan can't find a date, but his mom has the solution.

Shaun gets blackmailed.

Wife is seduced by a serial seducer.

Virgin with Huge Cock finally gets laid.

A young man discovers a ring with special powers.

Jeannie and Charlene get rear-ended.

English teacher becomes my high school sweetheart.

Nerd is sexually assaulted and dominated by two cheerleaders.

Daddy and my uncles play poker for my virginity.

Dad helps his daughter out before the annual daughter swap.

Brother and sister, virgins, discover that sex can be fun.

Janet confesses to her friend that she isn't what she seems.

"You've got a crush on me. You've got a crush on me."

Be very careful with what you tell your son.

Kyle and Myra lose their virginity. And someone wants in.

I (straight) bet on a blowjob and swallow more than pride.

A high school geek is surprised by one of the cool girls.

Hubby finally gets wife to play with clever trap.

The girls go clubbing and Amy takes Scarlet's virginity.

Brother and sister end vacation with steamy anal action.

Slave breeding in the antebellum south.

This one time while camping...

Frigid MILF turned by one of her husband's young employees.

A sperm donor was needed.

Teenage boy and his experienced older sister.

18 year old virgin falls in love with her military dad.

Damon explores the daughter of his favorite fucktoy.

Curvy Maddy meets Daddy for the first time.

Young woman faces a choice in accepting herself.

Night of discovery leads to a wife sharing experience.

Two high-achievers discover each other, and themselves.

Two sisters discover each other during family movie night.

Beautiful hunted Elf seeks protection from an Orc General.

Young virgin undresses for her older neighbour.

A first for family movie night.

A husband brings a coworker home for dinner.

A not-so-straight guy gets turned out at the gym.

Ethan's mom has uncommon ideas to solve his problem.

Straight guy discovers the joy of cock in gym shower.

Finding love in the midst of a pandemic.

Two days, the most important ones between brother and sister.

Daddy breaks my mind then makes me take my birthday present.

Maddie had the perfect suburban life, but changes are coming.

A brother gets a surprise roommate for a few weeks.

What happens in New York stays in New York.

Mike visits a hypnotist and gets more than he bargained for.

His mother makes all his sexual fantasies come true.

A daughter bumps into her parents at a swingers club.

After their erotic shower, siblings take it to the bedroom.

Siblings with unusual relationship take things further.

Daddy teaches his little girl a lesson or two.

Jennifer goes kitten hunting and captures young Ashley.

A mother teases her son, it gets steamy, all the way.

A black man breeds a young white girl.

A cliche romance between a nerd and her football player.

Daddy gets his first taste of the harem lifestyle.

Shannon and friends help her cousin recover from a breakup.

Straight guy discovers the pleasures of being a sissy.

Coed learns about sex and love.

A mother's lessons is all a son needs, especially sexually.

Gavin seeks revenge.

Sister helps brother through a rough patch in his marriage.