Try the free LITEROTICA WEBCAMS!

‘gay first time anal’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
gay first time anal 

Category

Sort by:
ViewsRatingFavoriteNewest
All Time

Hippie Hollow Cowboy

Straight cowboy needs a man.

by KenJames in Gay Male 10/28/2020
H
4.54
26.9k
28
6
41

My Entry into Anal

Senior man gets fucked and likes it.

by LittleTommyTudor in Gay Male 03/08/2013
4.38
89.3k
20
23
22
0

Virgin Daddy

Sperm donor finally meets his child.

by afureteru in Incest/Taboo 02/16/2013
4.4
210.4k
177
17
285
0

The Past Pt. 03: A Possible Future

Terry gets an unexpected visitor in the night.

by Forerunner in Gay Male 12/28/2012
3.73
22.1k
0
1
0

A Bear Cub Takes My Virginity

My first time; a 25 year old bear cub fucks me.

by Bundy5 in Gay Male 12/27/2012
4.29
143.8k
80
11
96
0
Active tags
Active tags
gay first time anal
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ

Category filter