‘gay first time’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
gay first time 

Category

Dominated By Football Rival Pt. 03

Senior Quarterback Submits to the Cocky Freshman.

4.36
50.5k
73
15
105

Bachelor Party Gone Wrong Pt. 04

The bachelor gets unexpectedly dominated by his groomsmen.

4.45
59.2k
143
30
175

The Photo Shop Ch. 15

A painful day at the beauty parlor and a photoshoot.

H
4.56
7k
3
0
5

Bachelor Party Gone Wrong Pt. 02

A crazy Vegas naked party gets humiliating for the groom.

4
49k
31
2
60

Do Not Judge a Book By its Cover

The captain of the football team vs. the small slender boy.

4.23
30.2k
33
14
62

Bachelor Party Gone Wrong Pt. 01

The groom is out-gunned by his groomsmen.

3.84
74k
59
5
164

Dominated By Football Rival Pt. 01

New Quarterback Is Cocky in More Ways than One.

4.11
51.9k
64
5
129

Nile Trains Me

A tale from my past...about my first tail!

3.74
7.7k
1
0
6
0

Brandon's Boots Ch. 01

A former teacher is victimized by his younger bully boss.

3.6
19.6k
19
2
36

Dominated By Wrestling Rival Pt. 02

Losing wrestler pays the price.

H
4.6
60.6k
102
15
139

Spring Break with Cocky Bros Pt. 05

Best friend and horse-hung bros cement their dominance.

4.32
38k
52
10
76

Cocky Med Students Pt. 03

Big-dicked med student completely dominates my life.

4.48
44k
49
10
79

Trapped

Two straight guys trapped in the snow do what they must.

H
4.56
172k
385
54
555
0

Edging Games Turn Not Gay Pt. 03

Best friends continue exploring.

H
4.53
14.3k
14
3
22

College Hitchhiker's First Time

A story of my first encounter with a man.

3.96
28k
7
4
11
0

No Longer a Show Ch. 01

Straight live cam guy tries first gay blowjob to make cash.

3.93
15.9k
22
3
36

Tales of a Cock Slave #74

Fun with hot, hung, aggressive Afghan bodybuilders.

4.57
3.7k
000

First Date Glory Ch. 01

Wild date ends at a glory hole.

H
4.84
98.7k
367
57
464
0

Field of Blooms: The Beginning Ch. 07

Vengeance is a dish best served ice cold.

4.43
3.9k
6
12
7
0

Midnight Workout

Late night gay encounter.

4.12
19.7k
6
2
15
0

Jogging Quickie

A neighborhood jog leads to first time magic.

H
4.7
154.3k
366
46
501

When My Teen Cousins Came

Teen twin cousins play with me and my trans wife.

H
4.57
62.4k
106
5
182
0

Hot Tub Hookup

Two straight friends have anal sex.

4.42
68.1k
69
5
114
0

Secret Santa

Played a secret Santa

4.39
16.6k
9
8
15
0

Pelican Point Pt. 02

Continuing the story of Darren and Mark, now introducing Bao.

H
4.77
4.4k
4
0
7

Prequel to Threesome

Young men experimenting.

4.34
14.7k
4
3
9
0

The Dicksucker Pt. 02

A young guy newly addicted to BBC.

4.19
30.6k
17
0
27

Horny Nephew's Summer with Uncle

Nephew lies awake, thinking about his uncle, one room over.

4.28
76.9k
55
11
94
0

Our Kinky New Neighbors Pt. 07

Kelly tricks the brothers into gay incest.

4.41
22.6k
15
0
25

Our Kinky New Neighbors Pt. 06

Paul's first real blow-job and anal sex.

H
4.69
27.9k
25
4
33

Follow the Rules

They learn the hard way to follow the rules.

3.48
11.9k
5
0
11
0

Hippie Hollow Cowboy

Straight cowboy needs a man.

H
4.54
26.8k
28
6
41

Meeting My College Roommate

The hot guy from school is my new college roommate...

H
4.67
41k
79
12
105
0

Bent

A story about two straight guys, who didn't see it coming...

H
4.66
112.8k
183
33
290

Mr. Right Now Ch. 08: Brad

Gay teenager's first time.

H
4.68
15k
12
2
18

After the End Ch. 01

Avery confesses attraction to daunting male colleague.

H
4.77
22.7k
42
7
94

Blackmailed and Seduced by Peter

Steve is caught and tricked in pleasing an older man.

H
4.74
51.7k
103
19
145
0

Try It You'll Like It

Chad's first time gay and beyond.

4.31
34.9k
15
4
27
0

Perfectly Clear

A man, who is definitely not gay, gives a speech.

4.35
4.2k
4
1
5
0

Insatiable Ch. 01

Kevin exploring gay lifestyle from straight.

4.09
19.7k
8
3
19

Romping on Winter Break - Day 04

The gang recovers, and tell stories about their first times.

H
4.71
13.9k
15
0
22

Nevermore Ch. 02

Damian's inevitable return to Nevermore.

H
4.75
7.8k
11
2
23

Mr. Right Now Ch. 07: Mustang

The Mustang man really has something . . .

H
4.52
3.8k
5
1
10

Darcy's Doubts - Day 01

Darcy moves in with an old friend after a long time away.

4.49
12.2k
16
6
27

Breaking and Entering

An intruder breaks into Bill's home and seduces him.

H
4.54
50.4k
82
3
135
0

The Cruise to Heaven and Hell

Drew and Autry meet on a cruise destined for disaster.

4.41
7.5k
4
4
7
0

Business Trip

Nelson shows his coworker big things come in small packages.

H
4.63
43k
65
15
94
0

Felix's First Time

Felix finally feels ready for his first time.

4.34
25.8k
6
0
16
0

Michael's First Time

Is he prepared to have his deepest desire fulfilled?

4.36
36k
16
6
25
0

Ryan Jackson's Great Stretch Pt. 02

Ryan Jackson wakes up to more changes to his life.

4.3
21.9k
19
1
23

Ryan Jackson's Great Stretch

Straight College Boy gets fucked and his world view changes.

4.37
46.3k
52
8
82

A Wife's Pleasure

Jack's wife is excited to hear about his first time.

4.39
36.1k
29
10
43
0

Who was he?!

A stranger sneaks into my room. Do I want him to leave?

4.15
14.7k
13
2
22
0

Order Gets Delivered

After having a mmf encounter she forgets to pick up the order.

4.24
19.6k
7
2
18
0

Business Escape Pt. 03

Morgan quickly returns to wrap up this unexpected adventure.

H
4.72
13.3k
15
3
24

Finally Fulfilled My Fantasy

My first time getting filled up after years of fantasizing.

H
4.5
52.7k
35
13
62
0

Learning from Older Men Pt. 02

My history teacher takes me home and I taste my first cock.

H
4.71
45.3k
67
14
90

Packing in Tight Places

I was the tight space that needed packing.

4.48
35k
59
5
94

That Time I Lost My Virginity

Losing my anal virginity.

3.92
34.9k
5
1
9
0

A Cruising Life Ch. 02

Finally sucking my first cock.

H
4.6
23.4k
24
4
26

Nude Modeling w Hung Roommate Pt. 02

Horse-hung roommate dominates me in private and public.

H
4.71
128.2k
189
24
245

Nude Modeling w Hung Roommate Pt. 01

Naked modeling session shifts power dynamics in our dormroom.

4.19
117.7k
143
11
249

To Know the Touch of a Man

My first sexual experience with a man. But not my last...

4.33
17.5k
3
4
6
0

Mark and Mark

Straight Mark and gay Mark meet at a software course.

H
4.53
24k
20
3
31
0

Spring Break with Cocky Bros Pt. 03

Best friend unexpectedly dominates me and my girlfriend.

4.39
72.1k
72
11
97

Giving Myself to You

Mature guy describes his first experience with another man.

4.49
21.6k
16
4
22
0

The Cocky Coxswain Pt. 05

There can only be one king of the locker room.

H
4.7
24.3k
36
5
39

The Cocky Coxswain Pt. 04

Sexy Italian teammate gets pounded in the sauna.

H
4.7
29.1k
42
4
54

I'm Just Not Into Asian Guys

A young "straight" man has a new experience.

H
4.53
23k
25
4
38
0

Jack's First Male Experience

Jack's much needed release came from an unexpected source.

4.37
35.3k
13
9
29
0

Boys Bonding Upgraded

A group of friends take their bond to the next level.

4.32
33.6k
18
6
41
0

Learning from Older Men Pt. 01

My first time playing with an older guy on webcam.

4.42
28.6k
32
5
48

The Cocky Coxswain Pt. 03

Rower studs bet on who has the biggest dick.

H
4.64
27.4k
25
10
34

The Cocky Coxswain Pt. 02

The horse-hung stud dominates two teammates in the shower.

4.46
36.2k
27
7
42

Afternoon Delight

Straight, married man, experiences his first taste of cock.

4.48
41.3k
15
15
28
0

The Cocky Coxswain Pt. 01

The shortest lad in rowing dominates his sexy teammates.

4.09
41.3k
55
10
113

Teammates' Trial

Nathan get close to his new teammate.

4.27
12.3k
8
4
15
0

I Thought I was Straight

Twice married and finds out he is gay.

4
42.4k
19
4
32

Gas Station Guy

Gay virgin mistakes her for a man.

H
4.6
47.1k
23
22
63
0

Doctor's First Prostate Massage

Colleague takes advantage of intimate procedure.

H
4.72
108.9k
200
28
287
0

Mr. Right Now Ch. 03: Dave

Dominating a hot cop.

H
4.69
11.6k
11
5
21

Yes, His Solely

Conniving plans derailed when a hot ass gets drenched.

3.69
9k
4
0
5
0

A Good Learner

Mick learns about sex from an upperclassman.

4.48
36k
25
6
38
0

Brock's First Cock

Straight boy can't stop thinking about cock, gets surprise.

H
4.5
121.2k
126
18
207

Cumming of Age Pt. 04

Matt begins to explore his sexuality more.

4.37
17.7k
15
0
17

Mountain Men Ch. 02: Schooled

His first anal with a wild mountain man.

H
4.6
28.5k
18
5
32

My First Time with Conor Pt. 01

I was nervous, but Conor showed me the joys of sucking dick.

4.47
18.9k
8
3
18
0

My First Time

First Time: Jim was 33 years old and I was 18.

4.26
65.2k
16
11
23
0

Long Weekends Pt. 01

Holidays are better with family especially for Landon.

H
4.7
29.7k
33
5
58

Winning the Blonde Goddess Ch. 08

Scott's life changes as he develops a new infatuation.

H
4.64
12.7k
11
2
15

Mountain Men Ch. 01: Rescued

Lost and found in the wilderness.

4.47
36.8k
34
7
65

Roommates Get Drunk And Horny

Straight roommates get horny after St. Paddy Day barhopping.

H
4.7
249.5k
508
41
693
0

Declin's Awakening

Evan pushes Declin a little too far.

4.36
19.2k
10
1
20

The Dog Bowl Ch. 01

A straight boy's fantasy is fulfilled, for a small price.

H
4.74
19k
25
5
41
0

Blow, Blow, Thou Winter Wind

Brotherly warmth heats up on a cold night.

4.35
32.5k
11
2
20
0

About a Minute or an Hour

Two inexperienced young men secret away to share touch. [version 2]

H
4.62
21.2k
5
3
15
0

First Time Seeing the Doctor Alone

18 year old, worried about his penis, goes to urgent care.

4.46
67.6k
31
4
48
0

Best Friends Camping

A story about a gay first time between friends.

4.26
106.9k
24
6
38
0
Active tags
Active tags
gay first time
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ