Try the free LITEROTICA WEBCAMS!

‘gay first time’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
gay first time 

Category

Sort by:
ViewsRatingFavoriteNewest
7 Days30 DaysAll Time

Very Best Friends

Jon and Tony explore their budding friendship.

by posingstrap1 in Gay Male 04/19/2024
H
4.86
11.7k
27
11
47
0

Senior Gala Pt. 01

Will straight boyfriend attend bi orgy?

by LoveScribe62 in NonConsent/Reluctance 05/09/2024
NEW
4.41
7.3k
11
1
28

Good Cop Bad Cop

Two dominant daddy cops pull over an unsuspecting twink.

by Subotter4beardaddy in Gay Male 05/10/2024
NEWH
4.77
7.2k
27
4
45
0

Senior Gala Pt. 02

Straight boyfriend's journey to bisexuality concludes.

by LoveScribe62 in NonConsent/Reluctance 05/10/2024
NEWH
4.74
4.8k
8
0
20

Roofer Calling

Does your roof leak? No, but this roofer fixed it anyway!

by LaTourEiffel in Gay Male 04/17/2024
4.44
4.3k
12
1
15
0

MWM Bisexual Musings Ch. 04

Short exchange leads to forced anal.

by fitfidelityfifty64 in Gay Male 04/19/2024
4.32
3.7k
4
0
6

MWM Bisexual Musings Ch. 03c

Gabbie's "Only Friends" ensnares Donnie and Mel.

by fitfidelityfifty64 in Mature 04/23/2024
4.45
3.1k
2
0
4

New Apartment/Roommate(s) Ch. 05

Liam and Dave confess their secrets about Harlan.

by ilike2watchu5one in Gay Male 04/26/2024
H
4.82
1.8k
3
1
10
Active tags
Active tags
gay first time
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ