Try the free LITEROTICA WEBCAMS!

‘gay reluctant’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
gay reluctant 

Category

Sort by:
ViewsRatingFavoriteNewest
All Time

Owen Takes Control Pt. 02

Second gay experience with a dominant soccer buddy.

by Decare in Gay Male 12/06/2023
H
4.65
6.9k
6
1
11
0

My Penile Romance

My new alpha roommate wants to romance me with his big penis.

by azburglar in Gay Male 11/29/2023
4.48
19.7k
56
10
106
0

Thai Boy Ch. 01

Employing a handsome Thai boy for the evening in Patpong.

by tattoo_dragon in Gay Male 03/02/2020
4.33
34.4k
33
4
56

Sister Turns Brother into Pet

Brother gets humiliated and degraded by sister.

by Gtuny in NonConsent/Reluctance 10/19/2019
3.33
74.7k
27
10
51
0

QJ Productions

Judy uses her fiancé's ass to negotiate porno deals.

by azburglar in Gay Male 07/28/2015
H
4.6
117.3k
261
30
360
0

Sexy Swimsuit

Straight guy with girl's ass gives dirty lapdance at the pool.

by azburglar in Gay Male 06/28/2013
H
4.58
1.05M
1.6k
180
2k
0

Tough Nuts to Crack

After sex story, reluctant straight guy is pressured to suck.

by azburglar in Gay Male 03/07/2013
4.44
276.5k
257
31
350
0

Thugs Break In

Black student suffers attempted robbery and more.

by exodus_69xXx in Gay Male 01/14/2011
4.43
163.1k
61
7
87
0

March Madness Ch. 01

Straight guy experiences a little madness of his own.

by watchdwag in Gay Male 07/04/2009
4.47
230.6k
229
15
304

Just My Luck

Guy with bad luck has to hold on to his job.

by Gck2702 in Gay Male 09/13/2008
3.86
69.6k
15
1
24
0

How You Seduced Me Ch. 02

You bend me over a kitchen countertop & fuck my virgin ass.

by married_but_curious in Gay Male 03/17/2008
H
4.65
215.7k
180
51
198

How You Seduced Me Ch. 01

Straight married man gets talked into sucking cock - and more.

by married_but_curious in Gay Male 02/17/2008
4.34
303k
107
31
146

Surprised and Used

Reluctant, first time gay experience.

by Ryter in Gay Male 12/07/2007
4.33
252.9k
117
2
151

A Cold Reading Turned Hot

A m/m fantasy of how Michael Biehn might've got that role.

by Larabees Lady in Celebrities & Fan Fiction 12/14/2001
0
42.8k
2
0
2
0
Active tags
Active tags
gay reluctant
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ