‘turned gay’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
turned gay 

Category

Frat Boy Turned - Virgin No More

Riley’s first party & first sissygasm.

H
4.88
24.5k
31
8
71

An Extremely Unlikely Story

I'm turned and then turn out daughter's ex boyfriend.

H
4.71
6.2k
5
0
15
0

MMM Autumn Night Camping

Gay guy unexpectedly taken by two straight best friend jocks.

H
4.66
47.6k
111
8
188

Forced Gay Virgin Ass, Summer Camp

Forced proximity and a forceful man turn me gay and begging.

H
4.68
47.4k
87
6
151
0

Festival Transformation

Elizabeth turns Dan into Dani while at a music festival.

H
4.71
34.8k
88
20
150
0

Straight to Gay Ch. 04

Nick loses all control for bbc.

H
4.73
35.6k
37
11
65

Straight to Gay Ch. 03

Nick pushes his sexuality further. No going back now!

H
4.6
32.1k
44
25
72

Straight to Gay Ch. 02

Nick dives deeper into his new sexuality.

H
4.69
40.1k
59
5
86

Straight to Gay

Good looking college boy goes gay for a stud daddy.

H
4.66
87.7k
140
15
234

Two Black Workmen Turn Straight Boy

18 year old gets turned by two black men in his house.

H
4.73
102.3k
261
27
420
0

Turned Out: Bitch's Boyfriend

Michael turns a straight boy that's out with his girlfriend.

H
4.64
93.5k
136
14
253
0

Turned Out In a Massage

Married man gets turned out during a massage.

H
4.67
126.6k
226
32
345

Journey From Straight To Gay Slut Ch. 02

Liam gets pushed a little further into becoming a gay slut.

H
4.71
43.4k
74
9
111

Straight Boy Fucked By Two Bulls Ch. 02

Part 2 of Straight Boy Fucked By Two Bulls.

H
4.64
75.9k
131
13
204

Monica Turns Me Out Ch. 02

Monica and Sarah continue their fun.

H
4.7
30.7k
78
15
108

Monica Turns Me Out

My domme ex girlfriend finishes what she started.

H
4.74
74.9k
214
15
339

My Son's Special Doctor Visit

Dad wonders about his son's strange doctor's appointment.

H
4.66
123.9k
198
15
308
0

The Houseguest

A visitor changes everything for his host.

3.64
27.7k
19
9
29
0

Canal or Anal

A light run turns into a straight guy's gang bang dream.

4.39
58.1k
58
7
75
0

No Strings Attached Ch. 02

More than a concept...

H
4.53
43.6k
13
6
15

My Girlfriend Turned Me Gay Ch. 02

She helps with his gay desire.

4.39
402.6k
154
36
199

My Girlfriend Turned Me Gay

She forced his fantasy down his throat - & up his ass.

H
4.55
1.18M
769
119
991

Turning Him Into A Whore

She turns him into a trick turning whore.

4.32
1.27M
658
0
850
0

Strapon Escort

Escort abuses a client with large strapon.

4.48
330k
176
0
234
0

Girlfriend Makes A Discovery

She discovers a strapon fetish with enthusiasm.

4.46
824.6k
590
0
767
0
Active tags
Active tags
turned gay
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ