‘straight guy’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
straight guy 

Category

A Bottoms Seduction Ch. 06

Carl and Martins relationship keeps heating up.

NEWH
4.74
3.8k
12
13
14

Pen-Pal Visits - 750

Straight pen-pal visits and tempts with grey sweats.

4
1k
1
1
3
0

Two Straight Guys

Straight guy Lee feels sparks with straight guy George.

H
4.79
25.5k
77
28
119
0

Mr. Koch

A young man meets a married silver-fox daddy.

H
4.85
19.3k
47
13
78
0

Neighbourhood Faggot: 1st Time

Straight boys summer starts off unexpectedly.

H
4.7
37.6k
149
30
231
0

A Bottoms Seduction Ch. 04

Martin allows Carl's Seduction to go further.

H
4.83
13.7k
32
16
44

A Bottoms Seduction

Martins new young employee takes a liking to him.

H
4.69
27.8k
63
15
109

MMM Pt. 06 - Homework

Twink's exam stress relieved by jocks.

H
4.78
6.6k
16
4
24

MMM Pt. 04 - A Twink for Dessert

Sexy twink fulfills fantasies of two straight jock friends.

H
4.86
10.5k
28
7
43

Breaking the Stallion Ch. 04

Dominant twink completes his conquest over a straight jock.

H
4.64
15k
51
6
57

Couple Fall for Huge Cock & Big Tits

A straight couple fall for huge cock and big tits.

H
4.57
33.7k
21
3
48
0

MMM Pt. 02 - Late Night Hot Tubbing

Two hot straight jocks take their gay twink bff - again!

H
4.82
18.6k
49
7
74

We all Start Somewhere

Straight guy feels the magnetism of cock.

4.41
14k
9
9
18

MMM Autumn Night Camping

Gay guy unexpectedly taken by two straight best friend jocks.

H
4.66
44.5k
105
8
178

Girlfriend's Little Brother Pt. 02

Straight guy can't seem to forget girlfriend's brother.

H
4.85
33.9k
139
48
184

Gym Daddy Ch. 02

Christian falls deeper to Daddy's dominance.

H
4.79
31k
93
26
127

Gym Daddy - Remake

Christian joins a new gym and gets unwanted attention.

H
4.74
36.8k
129
14
183

Theo Ch. 01: Bottom Roommate

Twisted Tales: Theo meets his new roommate.

H
4.52
16.8k
44
5
78

Jacob Ch. 02: Anal Love

Twisted Tales: Jack submits deeper to dominant couple.

H
4.83
12.9k
36
8
53

Do You Want to Hold My Cock?

Straight guy in welding class forces a guy to hold his cock.

4.33
30.9k
41
6
66

Straight Boy Makes Money Ch. 06

Harvey finds out who MrGTop is!

H
4.74
13.6k
49
25
67

Sleeping Faggot

Steven starts having strange dreams whilst away with work.

H
4.78
31k
127
21
215
0

Mixed Messages

University students find each other at last.

H
4.55
3.5k
1
0
4
0

My First Time being a Bitch

He turns me into his little slut.

4.46
51.7k
53
9
90
0

Breaking the Stallion Ch. 03

A dominant twink takes his straight jock even deeper.

H
4.86
25.5k
67
20
104

Turning the Teacher

Teacher gets seduced by student with wife's permission.

H
4.74
41k
120
35
200

Curious Husband Gets Cock

A married straight man lets his curiosity take over.

H
4.66
107.2k
186
62
292
0

Nosy Roommate

A nosy roommate finds more than what he bargained for....

3.27
15.3k
14
8
24
0

Plowed Pt. 03

Why is Brad feeling THAT? Jayden just grins and grins...

H
4.69
14.4k
17
4
27

Straight Boy Makes Money Ch. 05

Harvey sucks his first ever cock!

H
4.73
22.3k
53
19
76

Sharing Bed at Bachelor Party Pt. 04

Meeting Damon's Husband leads to new adventures.

H
4.54
10k
11
2
20

Neighbour Turns Me Out

John gets turned out by new, older neighbour.

H
4.71
96.7k
217
31
350
0

Straight Chris, One Who Got Away

Chris stays over, slides in & takes me to POUND TOWN.

H
4.8
40k
111
22
190
0

Straight Boy Makes Money Ch. 02

Harvey continues make money online whilst exploring his arse.

H
4.73
21.2k
56
11
87

Pole Vaulter and the Runner

18 Year Old HS Seniors hook up in the locker-room get caught.

H
4.79
24.1k
49
9
81
0

The Milking Den Ch. 06: Chase Comes Back

Sexy jock Chase is back to exchange edging for rent.

H
4.8
17.7k
25
6
37

Donald Comes to Town Ch. 02

Hurricane gets closer; Jeremy gives Logan a pounding.

H
4.83
19.2k
44
8
70

Wood City Ch. 04: Dorm Dick Down

Owen decides to have some fun in his university dorm.

3.94
4.1k
7
2
9

Spring Break Boys

Spring break drugs lead to first time gay sex.

H
4.79
156.3k
380
45
604
0

Monica Turns Me Out Ch. 02

Monica and Sarah continue their fun.

H
4.7
29.7k
77
15
106

Monica Turns Me Out

My domme ex girlfriend finishes what she started.

H
4.73
72.3k
208
15
329

The All Blacks

Rugby fan gets more than post-game autographs.

H
4.58
28k
66
5
104
0

The News Pt. 01

News presenter gets showered in cum.

4.27
15.2k
31
4
42
0

Knock Knock

When opportunity knocks, you suck cock.

4.38
40.5k
42
9
62
0

My First Year in College Ch. 10

Austin reveals what he had to do to join the fraternity.

H
4.53
19.2k
14
5
20

My First Year in College Ch. 04

Austin reveals some of his insecurities in a surprising way.

4.49
18.7k
11
13
18

My Husband Is a Slut

A special edible awakens the slut inside my husband.

H
4.73
52.6k
67
8
122

Neighbour's Hole

Young man finds glory hole in his suburban neighbourhood.

4.44
36.1k
38
8
67
0

One More Year Ch. 14

Jay tries to be Eric's friend, and Louis has regrets.

H
4.83
3.7k
4
10
6

Straight Boy Physical

Samuel needs a physical to complete his college enrolment.

4.18
50.8k
24
3
57
0

One More Year Ch. 13

The school holidays end, and the Science Fair happens.

H
4.84
4.4k
7
3
8

One More Year Ch. 12

Jay, Jamie and Ellie enjoy their break from school.

H
4.84
5.4k
10
9
11

That One Weird Time with My Doctor

He knew how to make me feel more comfortable.

H
4.65
46.5k
31
2
76
0

Baseballed Ch. 02

An encounter with star baseball player Anthony.

H
4.86
21.2k
41
10
60

Sports Massage from Friend's Dad Ch. 03

Waking up at the Coleman house continues the adventure.

H
4.77
134.2k
255
45
349

Barbell Bottom

Seduced at my apartment gym.

H
4.74
205.6k
462
57
645
0

A Rimjob to Remember

College date gives surprise rimjob.

H
4.72
89.7k
192
21
283
0

Girlfriend's Guinea Pig

I agree to be one of her test subjects.

H
4.68
118.8k
285
52
434
0

Neighbor Ch. 04

I take Daddy and Eric's morning wood instruction.

H
4.61
80k
138
38
196

The Porn Shoot Ch. 04

Jamie finally has to confront his true feelings.

H
4.86
20.6k
50
17
72

Trapped

Two straight guys trapped in the snow do what they must.

H
4.56
171.9k
385
54
555
0

Locked Out of Apartment

The sexy neighbor girls have a surprise.

HW
4.77
266.5k
793
109
1.1k
0

Jogging Quickie Ch. 02

Preston goes deeper with his new Daddy.

H
4.67
91.6k
199
33
256

LA Seduction

Straight guy gets seduced into Anal...and loves it.

H
4.72
98.6k
183
31
272
0

Poppers as Punishment

Fantasy Football Punishment Takes a Turn.

H
4.61
138.2k
317
20
470
0

Jogging Quickie

A neighborhood jog leads to first time magic.

H
4.7
154.2k
366
46
501

Bisexual Quarantine Seduction Ch. 02

The roommates continue their unexpected quarantine fun.

H
4.7
83.9k
148
36
209

Halloween Party Aftermath

Jessie needs a reminder about what happened last night...

H
4.74
101k
259
16
355
0

Wood City Ch. 03: Orientation?

Owen arrives at university for a one on one tour.

4.21
4.7k
4
0
5

Unexpected Wrestling Match

Wrestling for cash but losing your clothes.

3.79
33.8k
30
6
53

4 Questions For A New Neighbor

A new neighbor exploring a secret gay desire.

4.46
25.8k
20
14
35
0

Bisexual Quarantine Seduction

Unexpected seduction during quarantine desperation.

HW
4.82
280.8k
519
62
757

The Porn Shoot Ch. 03

Jaime has a drink with his scene partner and takes him home.

H
4.72
24.8k
54
14
70

My Roommate's Toy Box Ch. 03

Tyler gets in on the action, things definitely getting weird.

H
4.74
33.3k
82
22
105

The Porn Shoot Ch. 02

The guys perform the scene. "Brent" enjoys it way too much.

H
4.72
41.8k
84
16
107

The Porn Shoot

A straight guy needing cash gets an offer he can't refuse.

4.44
53.1k
93
12
169

My Roommate's Toy Box Ch. 02

Tyler finally catches his hot straight roommate in the act.

H
4.73
42.5k
81
13
128

My Roommate's Toy Box Ch. 01

Tyler's hot straight guy roommate has a massive secret.

H
4.56
47.8k
127
5
222

The Parade Pt. 03

An older man conquers a straight guy.

H
4.64
40k
66
16
91

Desperate Times...

Two housemates are stuck in quarantine together.

4.41
50k
31
7
65
0

My Best Friend's Dad

David has always had a crush on his best friend's father.

H
4.58
93.7k
130
13
174
0

Derek Pt. 03

Derek and Chris. This was no dream.

H
4.51
8.9k
7
1
17

Thai Boy Ch. 01

Employing a handsome Thai boy for the evening in Patpong.

4.33
34k
33
4
54

Frat Party Costume Sex

Helping out the frat president with a costume emergency.

H
4.74
280.2k
826
47
1.1k
0

Neighbor Ch. 02

First MMF Threesome with their sexy neighbor Daddy.

H
4.8
219.4k
446
64
572

My Date's Cousin

When his date passes out on him, he finds Les is more.

H
4.54
29.2k
34
4
44
0

The Client

My first little story and maybe not my last.

4.12
10.2k
2
1
5
0

Nailed by a Nine-Inch Dixie Boner

When the South rises again, who needs my pussy?

4.05
23.5k
8
4
18
0

Little Red Pill Ch. 01

A cure for small dick woes, may cause strange side effects.

H
4.56
71.4k
126
14
195

A Glorious Surprise

Straight guy doesn't know who blows him.

4.42
46.4k
25
7
34
0

Neighbor

Kinky wife wants to see her husband suck on a cock.

H
4.82
667.8k
1.2k
177
1.7k

Backseat Introduction

Girlfriend's dad and boyfriend share the back seat.

H
4.62
983.8k
1.5k
145
1.9k
0

A Moving Experience

A friend helped me move, and I got the load!

4.13
35k
11
9
17
0

Girth

A straight man has an endowed house guest come visit.

4.39
151.7k
156
32
243
0

Family Affair

A young gay man is hardfucked by his sister's boyfriend.

4.46
193.4k
275
19
416
0

Bathing Suit Dilemma

Two straight guys get surprisingly horny in the Jacuzzi.

H
4.74
636.8k
1.2k
125
1.6k
0

Her Boyfriend Subs In

Girlfriend uses her boyfriend for gay erotica shoot.

H
4.81
574.7k
1.4k
171
1.8k
0

Straight Guy Gives In

Straight guy gives in to gay sex.

4.33
84.5k
36
8
53
0

Hotel Rooms are for Horny Boys

Boys get way too drunk on spring break couple's vacation.

H
4.67
197.1k
336
34
465
0
12
Active tags
Active tags
straight guy
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ