‘anal first time’ stories

Charlotte didn't know her virgin ass would pay her master.

I learned how anally erotic I am.

Richard and Buddy go deeper, at last.

Couple breaks in wife’s new shoes, and her ass.

My desires are altered forever by a manipulative older TV.

How his lady discovered the joys of anal erotica.

A spring break camping trip.

AnnaSophia Robb asks friend to take her anal virginity.

First time anal love.

Hot friends enjoy a Halloween dinner theater orgy.

Asian girl wants to be taken by a white stud or does she?

Argument leads to a first.

Ella seeks two men for pleasure.

Losing my anal virginity.

Matt finds out Andrea wanted him from the minute she saw him.

Her second experince taught me a valuable lesson.

Shy stablehand recounts first time and how it changed him.

Silky loses her anal cherry.

A first time anal story featuring a man and woman.

When he daydreams, his mind always takes him to the old bridge.

Katie dreams of losing her anal virginity.

Party conversation leads to something new.

Janet seeks an Arab lover and suffers the consequences.

Better this time?

A girls visit to a sex club turns into a very wild night.

We revisit a younger couple to fulfill a specific request.

Hot blonde tricked into foursome by possessed garden gnome.

She performs emotionally and gives him her virgin ass.

A sequel to the original story, I did go back to work.

Three's not a crowd.

...hopefully it won't be virgin long.

Carmina's sexuality unleashed.

Mistress takes a virgin ass.

She plays with toys and Richie. Experiments are fun.

Donna offers Todd her anal cherry.

A need met, a reward given, as told by the Horsemaster.

Finally take the plunge loosing my anal cherry.

The "full report" Master requested- at least, the first part.

Tara comes to terms with Daniel's cuddling with his mom.

Virgin ass no more, I wanted to play and turn him on.

A gay man falls in love with a straight one.

Identical twins surprise Harley for her birthday.

A viral Valentine's Day love spell backfires.

In Which I Take Sarah's Last Virginity.

Mistress claims reluctant male slave's anal virginity.

Anya's desire to care for her man leads to something new.

Kassandra learns there is a third way a man may take her.

Priscilla awakens Tommy; Tommy loves Sarah.

Daughter has sex with mother's boyfriend.

Joy meets a group of much older men who show her a good time.

Sasha Gibson is back with a new pleasure to explore....

Megan could be Matt's perfect girl.

A chance encounter in a store lead to new experiences.

Jazzy goes bowling and balling.

The Tale of Agnetha and Draxas.

Sensual Sunday stroll down memory lane.