‘butt plug’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
butt plug 

Category

Handcuff Sister

A tale of siblings, bondage, love, and experimentation.

H
4.82
378.7k
1k
105
1.5k
0

Life's a Beach

Mother and Mother-in-law entertain son at the beach.

H
4.76
446.1k
605
86
933

The Bet

My girlfriend puts her ass on the line.

H
4.79
490.4k
461
44
734
0

Party Favor

Mr. Miller makes Shane service his male guests at his party.

H
4.69
245.4k
417
16
608

Myka's Tail Ch. 01

Confessions of a Teenage Sex Kitten.

HW
4.86
146.4k
376
59
528

Cuddle-Slut Ch. 02

More sexy times for the sisters.

H
4.77
196.4k
362
61
448

Because We're Bad Ch. 02

Kristin keeps things interesting for her brother.

H
4.75
258.5k
336
86
433

My Exhibitionist Nudist Daughter Ch. 01

My daughter reveals her secrets to me.

H
4.68
176.2k
324
39
625

Diamonds and Girls

My best enemy wins.

H
4.79
137.4k
320
64
373
0

The Boys Next Door Ch. 05

Diana gets the first part of her graduation present.

H
4.83
233.9k
305
65
350

Client Satisfaction: Anal Play

Secretary gets trained for her new (anal) position.

H
4.56
259k
294
20
442
0

Popping My Husband's Cherry

Wife discovers the joys of anal sex - her husband's anus...

H
4.66
222k
264
30
366
0

Ass is Now in Session

"Professor, I think we'd like to fuck your ass now."

H
4.52
202.5k
255
19
350
0

Family Photos

A mother tries out some new swimsuits.

H
4.77
109.4k
250
29
497
0

Jackie Makes Things Right

Jackie finds Brandon AND a love for strapon man-fucking.

H
4.81
331.2k
244
44
327
0

Moving in With Daddy Ch. 01

A dysfunctional family gets closer during the Pandemic.

H
4.75
119.5k
229
17
433

Butt Jewelry

Wherein sex toys and fashion trends collide very publicly.

H
4.73
110.5k
223
22
371
0

Catalysts

Professor inadvertently reveals her submissive streak.

H
4.83
111.1k
204
21
320
0

Mommy Daycare Ch. 03

A third mom, plus butt play, naughty walks, and mommy sex.

H
4.81
115.4k
201
23
296

Life's a Beach Ch. 02

Mother, mother-in-law and wife. The conclusion.

H
4.68
156.6k
201
30
274

A Slave Pet's Dream

Her boss trains her to be his slave pet.

4.3
393k
200
13
346
0

At the Professor's Mercy

She seeks the professor's guidance & dominance.

H
4.74
159.6k
197
16
273
0

Side Slut Ch. 01

Young wife offers her sister for her big-dicked spouse’s use.

4.24
110.6k
196
24
452

Hadley's Other Cherry Ch. 03

Prom night finally arrives & Jack takes Hadley's anal cherry.

H
4.69
172.9k
191
29
243

Loving Uncle Mike

Uncle and niece engage in incestuous love affair.

4.44
157k
191
9
255
0

Living with Great Aunt Helen

Peter moves in with his sixty-six-year-old great aunt.

H
4.82
119.1k
188
24
314

Hadley's Other Cherry Ch. 01

Jack introduces his tiny teen gymnast to anal pleasure.

4.46
169.4k
188
8
277

Life Worth Living

Two strangers, attempt suicide meet, and find love instead.

H
4.77
45.5k
186
32
214
0

Humiliated at Airport Security

Girl receives a cavity search in front of hundreds.

4.02
278.1k
185
40
251
0

Sissy Son Taken to Costume Party

Son is caught dressing up on halloween night.

4.41
277k
180
32
242
0

Old Man's Maid

This wasn't in the job description!

H
4.61
171.1k
169
0
211
0

Kitten Becomes Prey

Kitten plays with herself and a stranger takes advantage.

4.42
135.8k
163
6
263
0

Dr. Chloe Burrell, Sex Researcher

Researching strapon fantasies in, and out, of the lab.

H
4.78
252.8k
163
32
222
0

Jack and Jill

Ali turns her little brother into a futa-sister.

H
4.51
117.8k
162
13
243

Sister in Law Backseat Pt. 04

Family Dinner and Anal with SIL.

H
4.68
119.5k
161
9
207

Freckles

A brother and sister have a day home alone.

4.31
150.2k
161
27
219

Office Slave, Obedient Gift

A submissive secretary is loaned for the night.

H
4.59
215.6k
157
11
258
0

What Are You Doing?

Wife comes home early to catch husband experimenting.

H
4.62
98k
154
17
253
0

Step Mommy Slut Ch. 02

What is next for the submissive step slut.

H
4.55
153.9k
154
10
200

O Holey Night: Ass, Mouth, Pussy

Anne goes from Dirty Girl to Filthy Girl.

H
4.69
149.8k
151
8
210
0

Mommy Daycare Ch. 04

Butt stuff, naked walks, important talks, and lots of love.

H
4.8
82.4k
150
16
230

Our Dirty Secret

A couple enjoys some steamy anal sex in public.

4.41
170.3k
149
14
197

Shared Against my Will

Husband binds me, helps his friends rape me.

4.45
111.3k
145
14
269
0

From Her Ex-Boss to her Bitch

An employee turns her straight married ex-boss into her bitch.

4.44
179.5k
144
11
233

I'm Grandma's Sex Toy

Grandma caught me jerking off and wanted the cock.

H
4.6
125.3k
143
13
248
0

From Escort to Fuck Toy

They make her their fuck toy.

4.34
123.2k
142
7
209
0

The Whore Next Door

A new next door neighbor changes Dalton's life forever.

4.49
128.6k
142
47
226
0

Blackmailed Becky: Anal Training

Becky's blackmail continues as Steve trains her for anal.

H
4.66
120k
141
8
268

Company Whore Ch. 02

She accepts her role as company whore.

4.4
224.3k
139
6
192

My Exhibitionist Nudist Daughter Ch. 02

We continue our new way of life with a new surprise.

H
4.79
92.7k
138
12
238

A T-Girl and a Tomboy Pt. 01

A closet CD is outed by the cheerleaders.

H
4.73
49.9k
135
23
234

Baby Sit the Wife Ch. 01

Nadine is mistaken for husband's niece.

4.21
512.8k
133
7
221

Silent Nights

How one unusual guy handles cheating by his wife.

4.16
213.5k
132
115
178
0

Master and Cum Slut

Her Master trains her to be a good Cum Slut.

4.3
251.1k
132
8
197
0

A Proper Young Woman's Guide to Anal Etiquette Ch. 02

Laura wakes up her sleeping daughters.

H
4.58
201.3k
132
10
162

Becoming An Anal Slave

She knew she like anal, but...

4.29
301k
130
17
167
0

Mommy Daycare Ch. 05

Moms make it official, and a summer job becomes permanent.

H
4.69
101.1k
129
26
225

Daughter Sandra Ch. 01

Parents of newlywed learn of their daughter's transformation

4.31
154.3k
125
12
187

Helping Mom Move Ch. 04

Mom buys lingerie while her son expects a package.

H
4.55
107.6k
125
12
169

Five Christmases

Can David ever forgive Lauren's infidelity?

4.48
99.1k
124
47
182
0

Trophy Wife Ch. 01

Wives are the prizes in the Great Hunt.

4.46
155.6k
117
13
169

Weekend at Alice's Cottage

18 year old boy dresses as a girl & has first gay experience.

H
4.55
114.2k
117
14
147

Slutwife Training: Mastering Anal

Slutwife in Training learns to love anal play.

4.48
134.6k
116
7
173
0

Underneath Every Office Skirt

Law firm solicits prominent clients with her ass.

H
4.64
86.7k
116
22
206
0

Moms at the Beach Ch. 06

The twins' tale: Mama and becoming incestuous daughters.

H
4.63
113.1k
115
13
155

Humiliation with a Tail Plug

I wear a butt plug tail around a public mall.

H
4.52
302.9k
113
27
184
0

The Ass Fuck Slut

A married woman discovers pleasure in anal penetration.

4.36
139k
113
9
167
0

Hadley's Other Cherry Ch. 02

Hadley trains her virgin ass for Jack's big cock.

H
4.57
134.1k
113
7
148

The Palace

A virgin is initiated as a slave at the mysterious Palace.

H
4.51
135.5k
111
8
191

Sexual Enemies

Gay man faces wrath from his lover's girlfriend.

H
4.5
108.2k
110
16
140
0

Violating Sandie Ch. 06

Sandie's final violation?

H
4.7
68.5k
109
12
145

Naoko's Ordeal

Young Japanese wife rented out to pay debt.

4.41
250.9k
109
11
187

Big Ol' Barfly

College guy picked up by BBW granny at a bar.

4.39
216k
109
7
141
0

Wife's Friends Anal

Wife offers up my ass.

4.35
145.9k
106
18
171

Paige Submits Pt. 01-05

Paige submits to her roommate.

4.41
107.7k
106
10
182
0

Aunt Sandi Ch. 04

Spending two wonderful nights with Sandi.

H
4.55
172.2k
105
8
130

Tiffany's Timidities Ch. 03

Four tongues, six rules, one wet passenger.

H
4.71
151.2k
105
18
116

Over The Top?

A long term plan to deal with a cheating wife.

4.37
136.7k
104
40
179
0

Savannah's Day at Work Ch. 01

Having an adventure in the office.

H
4.59
83k
101
3
163

Does My Bum Look Big in This?

Girlfriend slowly turns lucky man into a beautiful girl.

4.43
281.3k
100
30
126
0

My Initiation

How I lost my gay virginity. The hard way.

H
4.57
232.5k
100
18
139
0

Up the Chimney

Her Santa is coming up the chimney this year.

H
4.67
155k
98
20
129
0

Blackmailed Ch. 01

A trip to a sex toy shop went wrong.

4.28
126.5k
98
4
151

Katrina Enjoys Her Cuckold Slave

Alan finds out how life is going to be from now on...

H
4.55
115.3k
97
15
137
0

Sin & The Prince

A Cinderella tale with a twist.

H
4.65
76.8k
97
15
114
0

The Iceman's Wrath Ch. 05

Jason hooks up with the one that got away - final chapter.

H
4.82
50.2k
97
75
116

My Exhibitionist Nudist Daughter Ch. 03

Our night of fun continues and things get crazier.

H
4.76
67.7k
95
6
169

Saga of Littown Ch. 03

Butt play, teacher trouble, and big sis's stress release.

H
4.57
80.8k
95
11
131

By Invitation

Femdom husband is made to serve her friends orally.

4.36
187.1k
95
9
137
0

Geeks Rule Ch. 01

A trip down memory lane.

H
4.82
41.1k
95
16
111

Nico's Girlfriend Pt. 02

Jill makes Nico her cocksucking boyfriend.

H
4.69
43.8k
94
0
117

Prize or Penalty Ch. 01: Size Queen

TV game show makes a bimbo of her.

4.41
69.5k
94
6
170

Passion Plug

Lucky guy helps out a new friend.

H
4.66
159.8k
93
5
119
0

Serendipity Ch. 01

Serendipity - moving day, part 1.

H
4.66
74.9k
93
3
117

Leave Well Enough Alone

Brian screws up a relationship, but not his life.

H
4.5
105.3k
93
43
134
0

Penis Pacifier

His girlfriend can’t fall asleep without sucking on a dick.

H
4.66
30.7k
92
6
161
0

My Husband, My Slave

A night out with friends turns into a new path in life.

4.16
290.6k
91
26
143
0
Active tags
Active tags
butt plug
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ