‘first gay’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
first gay 

Category

The Hypontist Test

A hypnotist lets his friend experience hypnosis and more...

H
4.51
6.2k
18
3
29
0

First Time I have Sex with a Male

This is the first time ever having sex in my life. I like it.

4.42
15.1k
15
5
30
0

Hypnotised

That time they tried to hypnotize me. (Bi)

H
4.62
13.2k
23
7
44
0

April Fool Backfire

Colin's sexy prank backfires into a new experience.

4.46
26.2k
26
11
43
0

Unexpected Introduction

An unplanned first gay experience in 750 words.

4.49
13.9k
6
4
9
0

Hooking Up with Bob

Dave's first time with another Man.

H
4.64
19.8k
21
5
35
0

My Night with the Internet Star Pt. 02

A night of gay sex with the Internet Star.

4.34
4.8k
1
2
1

Morning Departure

Overnight guest thanks the husband personally...

H
4.56
22.8k
31
7
48
0

Mikes First Transgendered

A story of my first transgendered experience.

H
4.5
63.2k
79
7
125

Adventures With Close Friends

Adventures of four close friends.

H
4.51
25.1k
20
1
34
0

Best Friends Camping

A story about a gay first time between friends.

4.26
106.9k
24
6
38
0

What If... Pt. 01

First bisexual experience.

4.42
33.9k
29
7
41

Holiday Threesome

Sharing a cock on holiday is surprisingly fun.

4.47
64.6k
57
4
74
0

Why Do Married Men Play with Men?

Response to the question of why married guys have sex with men.

4.37
42.1k
18
18
19
0

Pathetic Ch. 00: Prologue Pt. 02: Coward

A friendly senior finally shares his feelings with his love.

4.4
12.4k
8
8
11

Pathetic Ch. 00: Prologue Pt. 01

An introverted senior finally opens up.

4.09
18.9k
12
11
20

Curio Shoppe

The path to my first gay encounter was a bumpy one.

4
20.7k
7
0
7
0

Suprises

She comes home to find her man has a huge surprise.

4.41
78.1k
25
3
30
0

Jay's Life Ch. 01

Jay visits his friend Ben after class on Friday night.

4
29.5k
9
5
15
0

Brother Spies on Sister

Brother secretly records his sister and gets caught.

3.53
161.8k
34
17
45
0

The Chance of a Lifetime

Straight guy gets fucked for the first time.

H
4.51
228.5k
68
38
88
0

Brian, My First Gay Experience

The day he found out my best friend was gay.

4.29
155.7k
24
16
40

The Jamesons Ch. 02

They find a fourth to share with.

H
4.56
33.9k
2
1
6

My First Time

His first gay experience, thanks to my girlfriend.

0
100.3k
17
11
29
0

Surprising New Interest

A young man's first gay experience.

4.05
84.2k
15
8
24
0

Dave and Linda Ch. 01

Wife gives hubby a bi surprise on anniversary.

4.36
178.1k
32
2
40

Daniel & I

His first experience, his best friend.

H
4.64
130.1k
31
12
40
0

C is for Cock

Kenny experiences a first - after hours.

4.13
118.8k
7
5
9
0

Our First Time

You give him his first taste of your cock.

4.36
120k
5
6
8
0
Active tags
Active tags
first gay
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ