‘first time anal’ stories
Active tags
Active tags
Cherry
There's a first time for everything.
Just Friends?
She thinks they're just friends. He proves her wrong.
Asleep
She pretends to be asleep while he fucks her ass.
Just the Tip
He's too big for her tight backdoor, but just the tip...
Mr. Grinch
Fred's Christmas was stolen it comes back.
Three Toppings
A pizza delivery college girl takes a break with two studs.
Allison
Widowed wife's friend has a secret life and a craving.
The Palace
A virgin is initiated as a slave at the mysterious Palace.
The Removalist
Removalist gets more than he bargained for from a client.
Separate tags with commas. More info in the
FAQ