‘first time anal’ stories

Removalist gets more than he bargained for from a client.

Sex therapist helps a wife explore unique pleasures.

A mature married man finds his true calling.

Cat, Colt, & Jem- the final resolution.

Disgruntled employees turn the tables on their boss.

A willing girl offers me her ass.

Forbidden friends reunite for her first anal experience.

Getting my wife a big one and I get something special too.

Yes, she'll do anal ... for a price.

The story of Kasey Legs.

The Vibrating Tranny Hooker.

In love with Andy AND my latest role-playing game.

Virgin student's summer job search lands her in a porn film.

She helps her boss seduce his secretary into chastity.

And mother of the groom.

"Straight" boys test their limits.

How much is her body worth?

She loses her anal virginity (on film).

A rebuttal.

Sir meets his newest slave.

Daddy isn't too happy after work and gets really rough.

A shocking revelation has heady consequences (mf).

An island of sex slaves.

An exciting homecoming for a lover.

A princess is ravaged by orcs & enjoys it.

Sissy takes anal cum first time.

Wyatt experiences two new things, and loves both!

The story of my first (and only) experience with another man.

Hitch Hiker and gay sex.

Who survives the rescue?

Part one of a three-part sequel to Predators.

A woman becomes a submissive slut.

The situation worsens & Opal is in the middle.

He ties me down and takes me in all three holes.

A woman in a sauna is seduced by three strange men.

An eager submissive's first time with anal.

Sub loses her anal virginity to her Dom.

Surprises start in the morning, but go throughout the day!

Liz finally takes it in the butt!

Visiting an old friend, she makes a new one.

I join my well-endowed lady in the next room.

Diana gets the first part of her graduation present.

Jenny's fantasy is fulfilled.

Daddy catches his daughter masturbating!

Mick and his no-biological Niece have anal sex.

Long distance relationship between two lovers.

The convention begins...Who is Albert?

Married cocksucker has crazy submissive night including anal.

Kasey must make a decision to run or stay.

Two men continue to play after college and marriage.

The Tail End - doc introduces her to anal for the very first time.

The first time I had sex with another man.

Feline incited misadventure turns amourous.

Kate experiences a first with Castle.

Taking her in every way.

When Luka starts over he learns more about himself.

Problems and Firsts with the magic dick.

Kate's first anal sex, the end of the vacation.

Revelations about Jillian, plus spanking & butt-fucking Mom.

Sissy gets used by the inexperienced guests.

Son and Father make a D/s Sandwich with Mom.

Nina experiences anal sex for the first time.

Hannah wants Joel to watch another man fuck her, and more!

Aiko and Gerald try something new.

New into town - The guilt trip.

An older man lets a younger man fuck his wife.

Can a bi-guy seduce his gay roommate?

Wife wants sex after her run; he has a surprise for her too.

She was once taken by her cousin, now their reunited.

Daddy finally takes my ass, but he doesn't have permission.

Rachel has first time anal with random guy from the internet.

My first steps into gay anal sex and enjoying being a slut.

Jen's boyfriend helps her get revenge on an old classmate

Asserting his dominance, she loves it

Two teens join a super team with a big secret.

I get to be a daddy.

Ali is Mistress for a day

A harem recruiter gets to test run the Sultans concubines.

Katherine's first anal experience.

Plumber stops by to play with his new toy's ass.

A sucking turns into losing my Anal Virginity.

Nicole begs for reconciliation by offering her Anal cherry.

A sexy Asian babe has hot sex with a stranger on the river.

Josh discovers what all 'being a delivery boy' can include.

Donna offers Todd her anal cherry.

A young lady's further debaucheries!

Monica, Kelly, and Tony finish what they started.

A gypsy's curse is a Doctor's dream come true.

Sheila catches me with her dirty panties.

A figurative complaint becomes literal.

A girl asks her best friend to take her anal virginity.

Teens Toni and Rachel party with a male friend.

Boundaries broken & fantasies fulfilled with fiance's cousin.

A gay man falls in love with a straight one.

Maria and I get to know each other further...

Anal loving for him & her on the 4th.

Jenny makes it up to Dave

Playing with my straight-laced GF's ass soon escalates.

They enjoy their roller coster ride of a summer together.

A story of wife sharing, first time anal, and interracial.