‘first time gay’ stories

Active tags
first time (67)anal (49)gay first time (38)bisexual male (35)blowjob (33)gay (32)gay anal (27)bisexual (26)mmf (20)gay blowjob (18)gay oral (18)oral (17)threesome (17)domination (17)oral sex (16)gay virgin (16)straight (16)big cock (16)anal sex (15)seduction (15)blow job (15)rimming (14)cocksucking (14)gay romance (13)cum swallowing (12)older man (12)cock sucking (12)submission (11)submissive (11)group sex (11)bareback (11)shower (10)18-year-old (9)college (9)bicurious male (9)straight guy (9)turned out (8)straight to gay (8)younger man (8)masturbation (8)gay college (7)forced (7)cum (7)gay male (7)gay sex (7)non-consent (7)first time anal (7)older-younger (6)nonconsent (6)gym (6)humiliation (6)cum eating (6)gay anal sex (6)femdom (6)married (6)bisexual husband (5)gay seduction (5)male virgin (5)reluctance (5)swallow (5)blackmail (5)gay cocksucking (5)camping (5)bicurious (5)creampie (5)begging (4)older (4)male bisexual (4)reluctant gay (4)panties (4)voyeur (4)massage (4)gay drama (4)huge cock (4)fantasy (4)friends (4)daddy (4)friend (4)virgin (4)love (4)romance (4)forced bi (4)group (4)first anal (4)gay incest (4)handjob (4)gay love (4)jock (4)gay husband (4)two men one woman (4)first (4)non-con (3)big dick (3)older/younger (3)first time bi (3)seduced (3)19-year-old (3)forced gay (3)gay group (3)crossdresser (3)sloppy seconds (3)gay older man (3)bisexual men (3)cocksucker (3)older younger (3)cuckold (3)bisexual man (3)lesbian (3)18 year old (3)twink (3)stranger (3)gay nonconsent (3)beach (3)swinging (3)his first time (3)swingers (3)sleeping (3)cock (3)bdsm (3)sissy (3)bi-curious (3)gay handjob (3)sauna (3)cream pie (3)female dominant (3)deep throat (3)drunk (3)cheating (3)first gay blowjob (3)reluctant gay sex (3)gay fantasy (3)dilfs (3)male masturbation (3)noncon (3)football (3)gloryhole (3)mind control (3)gay blow job (3)best friends (3)kissing (3)first blowjob (3)control (2)mutual masturbation (2)gay oral sex (2)virgin gay (2)male incest (2)jerking off (2)bisexual seduction (2)halloween (2)bi husband (2)gay submissive (2)male submissive (2)dad (2)reluctant (2)first time lesbian (2)gay bdsm (2)cunnilingus (2)mdom (2)eighteen (2)gay domination (2)revenge (2)feminized (2)dominating woman (2)incest gay (2)encounter (2)cock sucker (2)gay orgy (2)interracial (2)gangbang (2)gay interracial (2)inexperienced (2)facial (2)hot (2)fetish (2)crossdressing (2)exhibitionism (2)glory hole (2)strap-on (2)teen (2)dildo (2)double penetration (2)married men (2)office (2)bi (2)military (2)bondage (2)gay forced (2)outdoors (2)voyeurism (2)gay reluctance (2)gay male romance (2)anal virgin (2)first gay (2)dad/son (2)breeding (2)cousin (2)gay acceptance (2)first time gay anal (2)muscular (2)straight man (2)latina (2)dirty talk (2)hand job (2)gay co-worker (2)first time bisexual (2)virginity (2)armpit licking (2)gay massage (2)school (2)abs (2)true story (2)fellatio (2)men kissing (2)gay gangbang (2)gay age difference (2)strapon (2)str8 (2)cumplay (2)old/young (2)gay virginity (2)dominant (2)small penis (2)frottage (2)gay submission (2)cross dressing (2)divorced (2)mystery (2)butt plug (2)ass licking (2)gay masturbation (2)cock worship (2)cum swapping (2)three-way sex (2)
first time gay

Straight Top to Gay Bottom Toy Ch. 04

Candy's turnout continues as Tina takes control.

Lesbian Sex 04/13/2018

Lost in a Blizzard Ch. 01

A guy gets lost in a blizzard in Sweden and is rescued.

Gay Male 04/07/2018

Friend and Husband Seduction

High School best friend and bull husband take me new places.

Gay Male 02/22/2018

Straight Top to Gay Bottom Toy

How my neighbor made me his cock sucking man bitch.

NonConsent/Reluctance 02/16/2018

Sports Massage from Friend's Dad Ch. 02

Braden's back at the Coleman household for 4th of July party.

Gay Male 02/10/2018

Turning Out the Wife

Husband Introduces Wife to a Special Lady.

Group Sex 02/09/2018

My First Time Becoming a Slut

My first time with a man.

Transsexuals & Crossdressers 01/31/2018

Dick in an Elevator - I'm Not Gay!

Straight man meets big dick up close and personal.

Gay Male 01/17/2018

Slutty Sleepover Ch. 02

Jason and Jacob assume their roles as the night continues.

Gay Male 01/13/2018

Road Trip Turnout Ch. 02

Straight man's conversion continues as he fully submits.

Gay Male 01/12/2018

Road Trip Turnout

Straight man turned gay sex servant.

NonConsent/Reluctance 01/06/2018

Sports Massage from Friend's Dad

Friend's professional father helps with pulled muscles.

Gay Male 12/30/2017

Dressing Room Encounter

Straight man's gay encounter in a dept. store dressing room.

Gay Male 12/30/2017

Tied to the Bed

Helping his best friend takes an unexpected turn.

Gay Male 11/25/2017

She Makes Him

Kinky girlfriend seduces boyfriend into becoming her slut.

Group Sex 11/17/2017

Las Vegas Best Friend Threesome

Three best friends vacation in Sin City and sin becomes them.

Group Sex 11/05/2017

Slutty Sleepover

Two, straight best friends make some discoveries.

Gay Male 10/27/2017

Gab's Seduction

I become closer with a friend that needs my help.

Gay Male 10/20/2017

New Awakening Pt. 02- A Taste for Cock

Straight boss pays for spying on his secretary with his ass.

Gay Male 10/15/2017

Learning to Surrender Pt. 01

Rick loses his virginity to his new older lover.

Gay Male 10/06/2017

New Awakening - Straight to Bi/Gay

Divorced boss spying on hot secretary, "turns" his life.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 10/02/2017

Road Side Assistance

Straight man pays the tow truck driver the hard way.

NonConsent/Reluctance 09/27/2017

Straight Invaded Pt. 02

Home invaders continue his turnout.

NonConsent/Reluctance 09/19/2017

Horny Dylan and his Dad Ch. 01

Dylan and his experiences growing up around older men.

Incest/Taboo 09/11/2017

Jack's Dad

Jack seduces his dad.

Incest/Taboo 09/07/2017

Straight Invaded Pt. 01

Married straight man turned by home invaders.

Gay Male 09/06/2017

The Duplex Ch. 01

Husband and wife experience something new.

Gay Male 08/03/2017

The Football Player's Cocksucker Ch. 06

Brandon takes Matt out bowling.

Gay Male 07/22/2017

Unexpected Swimming Lesson

My mistress wanted me to publish me most recurring fantasy.

Gay Male 06/07/2017

Turning Boys into Men Ch. 02

Two young men explore further with mature woman.

Incest/Taboo 05/20/2017

Turning Boys into Men Ch. 01

Two young men learn much from a mature woman.

Incest/Taboo 05/19/2017

The Football Player's Cocksucker Ch. 03

Matt's desires move beyond just merely cocksucking.

Gay Male 05/17/2017

The CL Tease Ch. 02

The tease gets more than he bargained for.

Gay Male 05/16/2017

The CL Tease Ch. 01

Straight, online tease gets get turned out by his 'victims'.

Gay Male 05/04/2017

The Football Player's Cocksucker

Matt is crushing on hot jock Brandon, who takes advantage.

Gay Male 05/02/2017

Gym Sauna Therapy Leads To More

First timer has unexpected encounter with older gym owner.

Gay Male 04/26/2017

Insatiable Rob & Eric Ch. 08

Rob and Eric help Jay with his needs.

Gay Male 04/03/2017

The Pirate King Ch. 01

Pirates, ropes, and desire!

Gay Male 03/14/2017


First time male gay sex story.

Gay Male 03/08/2017

Mark and Melanie: The Meeting

We meet Mark and Melanie, maybe our next sexual companions.

Group Sex 03/05/2017

Failed Threesome

Bi-curious guy gets his man-card permanently revoked by bull.

Gay Male 02/22/2017

New Territory

A young man's first experience with his fellow gender.

Gay Male 02/16/2017

James Pt. 01

Story of a straight guy's first time.

Gay Male 01/26/2017

Straight Boy to Bi Bottom Ch. 01

My first cock.

Gay Male 01/12/2017

Bears, Beets, Butt Stuff

[Office fanfic] Jim and Pam stay at Dwight's agritourist B&B.

Celebrities & Fan Fiction 01/08/2017

Experiencing Oral

Former straight guy goes orally bi.

Gay Male 12/28/2016

A Gay Change of Mind

I find myself increasingly attracted to Gavin.

Gay Male 12/15/2016

Just for You

An Oral Fantasy.

Gay Male 12/11/2016

How I Lost My Anal Virginity

My first time losing my anal virginity to a 9 in cock.

Gay Male 11/02/2016

Camping with the Neighbor Ch. 03

A lonely married man tries his best to get off.

NonConsent/Reluctance 10/30/2016

Camping with the Neighbor Ch. 02

A lonely married man tries his best to get off.

NonConsent/Reluctance 10/29/2016

Camping with the Neighbor Ch. 01: Intro

A lonely married man tries his best to get off.

NonConsent/Reluctance 10/28/2016

Please Wait for Me

Two troubled men find each other at an airport gate.

Gay Male 10/27/2016

Mike, Helen, and Hannah

Ben is bribed with sexual favors to have oral sex with Mike.

Gay Male 10/10/2016

The Real Kasey Ch. 01

The story of Kasey Legs.

Transsexuals & Crossdressers 10/07/2016

Meating Terry

My first experience with a submissive sissy boy.

Transsexuals & Crossdressers 10/05/2016

Twelve Sexual Men Pt. 02

Ari recalls his 1st crush and steps closer to his obsession.

Gay Male 10/02/2016

An Old Friend

I meet a friend in a bar, and one thing leads to another...

Gay Male 09/28/2016

A Night Out

Drunken fun between three new friends.

Gay Male 09/25/2016

My 30th Birthday

Crossing to the other side with a party guest.

Gay Male 09/19/2016

A Hot White Mess Pt. 03

Alex's curiosity leads him to spy on a campsite.

Gay Male 09/09/2016

First Bisexual Experience

Friends discover new sexual dimensions.

Gay Male 09/06/2016

A Hot White Mess Pt. 02

Alex seeks relief at the beach but then Steve appears.

Gay Male 08/30/2016

A Hot White Mess Pt. 01

18 year old Alex has his first gay crush on Steve.

Gay Male 08/25/2016

First Time With a Guy

Straight but curious guy has his first gay experience.

Gay Male 08/25/2016

Trip with Friends Ch. 01

A sexual awakening in San Francisco.

Gay Male 08/16/2016

An Afternoon with Charlie

My first gay experience with an older man.

Gay Male 08/15/2016

Breaking My Cherry

Man to man seduction.

Gay Male 08/14/2016

Nutritional Supplement

A curious bodybuilder learns a new work out.

Gay Male 08/14/2016

College Bi Fun

College sophomore has bi fun at his girlfriend's urging.

Group Sex 08/09/2016

Down the Rabbit Hole Ch. 08

Mr. C opens his door.

Gay Male 07/28/2016

Wrestler's Shower

A sexually repressed wrestler has his first gay encounter

Gay Male 07/28/2016

Down the Rabbit Hole Ch. 07

Mr. C plays with new toys.

Gay Male 07/22/2016

Surfers Experiment in Speedos

These Aussie surfers experiment in speedos.

Gay Male 07/10/2016

My First Cock

The first time I ever gave a blow job to a man.

Gay Male 07/06/2016

My First Time With Gordon

1st time bi experience.

Gay Male 06/27/2016

Seduced on Liberty

My early Navy days and my first gay encounter.

Gay Male 06/13/2016

The Birthday Party

A 30 year old loses his virginity to three men.

Transsexuals & Crossdressers 06/07/2016

First Gay Experience in Steam Room

My first gay experience in my Gym's Steam Room.

Gay Male 05/22/2016

To Protect and Serve

Breaking up leads to cop car sex.

Gay Male 04/02/2016

Picture Perfect

Picture of couple and gay friend unleashes bi lust.

Gay Male 02/26/2016

Our First Meeting

A first-person imaging of what a first time might be like.

Gay Male 02/06/2016


Caro's mistress prepares a masculine surprise for him.

BDSM 02/02/2016

Seduced in a Hotel Room

College guy seduced to have sex with another man & likes it!

Gay Male 01/05/2016

Frank's Hot First Time Sex

First Time unexpected gay.

Gay Male 12/15/2015

The First Time for My Father

Charles has to finally face the truth, he wants his son.

Incest/Taboo 10/21/2015

First Time in an ABS

Young guy stops by ABS to see what it's all about.

Gay Male 10/15/2015

Fun on a Boat

A curious guy goes for a boat ride with two sexy older men.

Gay Male 08/04/2015

It Was The Summer Of '85

First time male-male sexual experience

Gay Male 08/03/2015

The Other Boy in Goodwell

High lonesome cowboy's first time w/ an experienced hipster.

Gay Male 07/05/2015

Blowjobs for Beers

Teenage boy is forced to suck cock for beer.

Gay Male 06/19/2015

The Myth about Big Black Cock

I discover the truth behind the myth of Big Black Cock.

Gay Male 06/13/2015

My First Time

The first time I had sex with another man.

Gay Male 06/12/2015

Easing My Stress

A massage to combat stress turns into better relief.

Gay Male 05/01/2015

Nosy Dad Ch. 02

Dad hooks up with son's lover.

Gay Male 04/22/2015

Teen Goes To Swinger Party Ch. 01

Teen boy goes to swinger party and has some kinky fun.

Group Sex 03/27/2015

Cody Becomes Chloe Pt. 01

A teen goes on Craigslist and meets Will.

Transsexuals & Crossdressers 03/19/2015

Trent's First Cock Ch. 02

Trent gets his first taste, and then some.

Gay Male 02/22/2015

Casey's Revenge

Fat guy gets revenge on hunk by making him submit.

Gay Male 02/07/2015

Wanting Him Ch. 02

Ashton and Thomas resolve some differences.

Gay Male 01/23/2015
Active tags
first time gay
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ
Related Tags