‘first time gay’ stories

Active tags
first time (67)anal (47)gay first time (38)blowjob (34)bisexual male (34)gay (31)gay anal (27)bisexual (25)mmf (19)gay blowjob (18)gay oral (18)oral (17)threesome (17)gay virgin (16)domination (16)anal sex (15)oral sex (15)seduction (15)blow job (15)straight (15)big cock (15)cocksucking (14)rimming (13)gay romance (13)cum swallowing (12)older man (12)cock sucking (12)submission (11)group sex (11)bareback (11)shower (10)college (10)submissive (10)18-year-old (9)bicurious male (9)straight guy (9)turned out (8)straight to gay (8)gay college (8)younger man (8)cum (8)masturbation (8)forced (7)gay male (7)gay sex (7)non-consent (7)first time anal (7)older-younger (6)nonconsent (6)gym (6)humiliation (6)cum eating (6)gay anal sex (6)femdom (6)bisexual husband (5)gay seduction (5)male virgin (5)reluctance (5)swallow (5)blackmail (5)gay cocksucking (5)camping (5)bicurious (5)creampie (5)married (5)older (4)male bisexual (4)reluctant gay (4)panties (4)voyeur (4)massage (4)gay drama (4)fantasy (4)friends (4)daddy (4)friend (4)virgin (4)love (4)romance (4)forced bi (4)group (4)first anal (4)gay incest (4)handjob (4)gay love (4)drunk (4)jock (4)gay husband (4)two men one woman (4)first (4)non-con (3)begging (3)older/younger (3)first time bi (3)seduced (3)19-year-old (3)forced gay (3)gay group (3)crossdresser (3)sloppy seconds (3)gay older man (3)bisexual men (3)cocksucker (3)older younger (3)cuckold (3)bisexual man (3)18 year old (3)twink (3)stranger (3)huge cock (3)gay nonconsent (3)beach (3)swinging (3)his first time (3)swingers (3)sleeping (3)cock (3)bdsm (3)sissy (3)bi-curious (3)gay handjob (3)sauna (3)cream pie (3)female dominant (3)deep throat (3)cheating (3)first gay blowjob (3)reluctant gay sex (3)gay fantasy (3)dilfs (3)male masturbation (3)noncon (3)football (3)gloryhole (3)mind control (3)gay blow job (3)best friends (3)kissing (3)first blowjob (3)control (2)big dick (2)mutual masturbation (2)gay oral sex (2)virgin gay (2)deepthroat (2)male incest (2)jerking off (2)halloween (2)bi husband (2)gay submissive (2)male submissive (2)dad (2)reluctant (2)gay bdsm (2)cunnilingus (2)eighteen (2)gay domination (2)revenge (2)feminized (2)dominating woman (2)incest gay (2)encounter (2)cock sucker (2)gay orgy (2)interracial (2)gangbang (2)gay interracial (2)inexperienced (2)facial (2)lesbian (2)hot (2)fetish (2)crossdressing (2)glory hole (2)strap-on (2)teen (2)dildo (2)double penetration (2)married men (2)office (2)bi (2)military (2)public (2)bondage (2)gay forced (2)seduced gay (2)outdoors (2)voyeurism (2)gay reluctance (2)gay younger man (2)gay male romance (2)anal virgin (2)first gay (2)dad/son (2)breeding (2)cousin (2)gay acceptance (2)first time gay anal (2)muscular (2)straight man (2)latina (2)dirty talk (2)hand job (2)gay co-worker (2)first time bisexual (2)virginity (2)armpit licking (2)gay massage (2)school (2)abs (2)true story (2)fellatio (2)men kissing (2)gay gangbang (2)gay age difference (2)strapon (2)str8 (2)old/young (2)gay virginity (2)dominant (2)small penis (2)frottage (2)gay submission (2)feminization (2)cross dressing (2)divorced (2)mystery (2)butt plug (2)ass licking (2)gay masturbation (2)cock worship (2)cum swapping (2)three-way sex (2)
first time gay

My First Taste of Another Man

An evening at the bars leads to unexpected fun.

Gay Male 11/14/2014

Gypsy Cure

Frank uses a Gypsy potion to enslave Spence.

Gay Male 11/13/2014

New Gym Friend

Straight man is seduced after a workout.

Gay Male 09/25/2014

True First Time with a Man

Recounting the first time I made love to another man.

Gay Male 09/23/2014

College Massage Experience

On the advice of a friend, I go see Michael for a massage.

Gay Male 09/11/2014

Turning Into a Cocksucker Ch. 01

Married Man agrees to suck cock for first time.

Gay Male 09/03/2014

Show Me Yours

Can a bi-guy seduce his gay roommate?

Gay Male 08/14/2014

Burning Honey Ch. 01

Aspen meets a golden man.

Gay Male 08/03/2014

Becoming a Gay Fuck Toy

The Secret is out, now I was fucked.

Gay Male 07/25/2014

The Hunt Pt. 01

Halloween party, dressed as a woman, the perfect disguise?

Transsexuals & Crossdressers 07/13/2014

College Life

Jake and I become more than friends.

Gay Male 07/07/2014

Dominated By Daddy Ch. 01

A dominant and controlling older top gets what he wants

Gay Male 07/06/2014

The Road Sometimes Traveled

An unrequited cuckold takes the gay way out.

Gay Male 06/06/2014

A Night of Firsts at the ABS

A young man's night of discovery.

Gay Male 05/07/2014

2 Cocksluts Share a Big Cock

I share Daddy's big cock with my new blowjob buddy.

Gay Male 04/03/2014

Bicurious Fantasy Becomes a Reality

My fantasy of being submissive to another man is fulfilled.

Gay Male 02/12/2014

My First Time

The story of how I had my first gay experience.

Gay Male 02/11/2014

A Quiet Understanding

Straight man introduced to erotic male massage.

Gay Male 01/29/2014

Falling for Matt

Falling helplessly in love with my straight best friend.

Gay Male 10/10/2013

Banging Big Time Is No Theory Ch. 02

The boys explore what's always been there

Celebrities & Fan Fiction 10/09/2013

Telling Secrets

One young man's boss offers an unexpected proposition!

Gay Male 09/30/2013

The Web Cam Experiment

Two virgin boys experiment with sexuality.

Gay Male 09/23/2013

Burying the Hatchet

A man comes to terms with an old adversary.

Gay Male 08/19/2013

Trust Ch. 03

A gay man falls in love with a straight one.

Gay Male 08/14/2013

Trust Ch. 02

A gay man falls in love with a straight one.

Gay Male 08/13/2013

Crime Doesn't Pay

A man catches a thief in his hotel and teaches a life lesson.

Transsexuals & Crossdressers 08/12/2013

First Time Cum Swallowing Adventure

My first time ever sucking a huge cock to completion.

Gay Male 08/11/2013

One More Time Ch. 01

Cameras, soccer balls, the darkroom, and a new best friend.

Gay Male 08/09/2013

Virgin No More

"Straight" man goes to party, doesn't leave straight.

Gay Male 08/01/2013

First Time at 7/11

He gets his first time in a cooler.

Gay Male 07/17/2013

Broken In

He gets a first taste of man love.

Gay Male 07/16/2013

First Time with a Man

My first encounter in a sexual relationship with a man.

Gay Male 07/15/2013

Never Did This Before

Older gentleman moves into a Seniors' Community.

Gay Male 07/12/2013

Loving Him Ch. 02

Lexan and Max's relationship takes a drastic turn.

Gay Male 07/12/2013

Loving Him Ch. 01

A story of the beginning, bitter and sweet.

Gay Male 07/12/2013

Getting Even The Hard Way

Cheating leads to gay humiliation.

NonConsent/Reluctance 06/17/2013

First Time with Ian Ch. 01

A first time with Ian in a shower room.

Gay Male 06/17/2013

In Consequence of Danny

Memories of that first time with Danny.

Gay Male 06/17/2013

More Than I Bargained For

Rob's fantasies come true while browsing old records.

Gay Male 05/12/2013

First Time

My first time with another guy.

Gay Male 05/07/2013

Beast in a Cage

An imprisoned pirate is dangerous thing for a young guard.

Gay Male 05/05/2013

Highway Encounters Ch. 01

A man's boring trip takes a turn for the interesting.

Gay Male 04/27/2013

Sexuality Shock

Surprise handjob initiates his new sexuality.

Gay Male 04/23/2013

Tony's First Time

Tony hooks up with a guy from work.

Gay Male 12/31/2012

Girl for Charlie

Unexpected gay visitor gives him a chance to dress up.

Transsexuals & Crossdressers 12/28/2012

If You Drop Your Wallet In P'town

Young guy's first bisexual adventure.

Gay Male 12/23/2012

Becoming a Star

Two straight men find more in a gay porno done for money.

Gay Male 11/17/2012

Cable Hook-Up

A married man's first time with another man.

Gay Male 11/07/2012

College Sophomores Seek Relief 01

Matt and Scott get drunk, high and curious.

Gay Male 11/04/2012

My Life With Rose Ch. 04

A friend of Rose's stops by to take my picture.

Gay Male 10/29/2012

Meetings with Mark Ch. 01

Every time with him was another first.

Gay Male 10/09/2012

Sarah's Poker Surprise

Surprise bi first time.

Gay Male 07/26/2012

My Best Friend

A typical day between two friends turns into something more.

Gay Male 07/19/2012

Finding Myself

Teen with a much older man.

Gay Male 07/08/2012

The Party

Boldness can get you spanked and more.

BDSM 07/05/2012

Gym Shower

A curious young man makes a connection at the gym.

Gay Male 07/02/2012

Club Games

Who will they choose.

Group Sex 06/27/2012

Jake's Awakening

Supressed feelings between friends leads to more.

Gay Male 06/19/2012

Unrequited Love Ch. 01

A young man describes his first time.

Gay Male 06/18/2012

Charles

My first time with another guy.

Gay Male 06/17/2012

First Time

My first sexual encounter with a man.

Gay Male 06/14/2012

Becoming Bi

Straight guy finally goes through with it.

Gay Male 06/11/2012

He Had No Idea

A guy's first time with a real man.

Gay Male 05/03/2012

First Time Guy...

A great cure for loneliness.

Gay Male 04/29/2012

First Sergeant

His first sexual experience, with an older man.

Gay Male 04/22/2012

The New Guy Ch. 02

Part two of a guy earning some experience.

Gay Male 04/13/2012

Finally Found the Courage

First time with Robbie is one I will never forget.

Gay Male 02/05/2012

Mattress Delivery

Straight horny 18-year-old's gay first time with black delivery man.

Gay Male 01/22/2012

Short-Term in Chicago Ch. 02

Straight guy learns more from gay neighbor.

Gay Male 01/13/2012

First Time In Front of My Wife

I was encouraged to suck a man by my wife.

Gay Male 12/14/2011

A Fantasy Realized Ch. 01

Adult website leads to great first encounter.

Gay Male 11/14/2011

A Familiar Story Ch. 02

Breaking in a willing virgin.

Gay Male 10/22/2011

Blind Man's Bluff

Straight Guy/Gay Sex.

Gay Male 10/06/2011

Rebecca and Alan and the Summer Ch. 02

Alan brings home a girl and gets more than he bargained for.

Incest/Taboo 09/11/2011

Discretion Has Its Rewards

He joins a couple to satisfy wife's unusual desires.

Loving Wives 09/07/2011

Party with Wife and Her Lover

Conned into gay encounter.

Gay Male 09/03/2011

Sean and Roger

A night on the town leaves 2 unlikely lovers together alone.

Transsexuals & Crossdressers 08/04/2011

Be Careful What You Hope For Ch. 01

My first time with a man.

Gay Male 08/04/2011

Remembering the First

Two young men discover sex with each other.

Gay Male 07/21/2011

My First Time Experience

My first time gay experience, and how I knew I was bisexual.

Gay Male 07/17/2011

My Photo Shoot

My first time with another man is during a modeling shoot.

Gay Male 05/05/2011

Neighbor Kid

Couple initiates a young neighbor into their play.

Loving Wives 05/02/2011

Short-Term in Chicago

Straight guy is seduced by gay neighbor.

Gay Male 03/03/2011

Island Love Ch. 02

Teen is taught about his need for gay love by an older man.

Gay Male 01/29/2011

The Intern

Arrogant intern rekindles man's forgotten bi side.

Gay Male 01/12/2011

First Guy

My first time with another guy.

Gay Male 01/10/2011

In the Shower

First time being blown by a guy.

Gay Male 12/15/2010

Possessed by a Dream Ch. 01

A young man has disturbing dreams of a dark intruder.

Gay Male 12/02/2010

His First Mouthfull

Tim finally gets to fulfill his dream of sucking another guy.

Gay Male 10/24/2010

Boredom Can Be Dangerous Ch. 02

Young husband has sex with Father-in-Law.

Gay Male 10/10/2010

Boredom Can Be Dangerous Ch. 01

Man encounters Son-in-Law at adult bookstore.

Gay Male 10/09/2010

Homework Help

Two men enjoy helping each other with a problem.

Gay Male 09/28/2010

The Swimming Pool

My first sex with a man.

Transsexuals & Crossdressers 09/28/2010

Coach CockStud

Married man dreams about sucking cock... and does

Gay Male 09/17/2010

Special Delivery

The pizza delivery guy was a hot black man.

Gay Male 08/11/2010

Stress Relief

Inexperienced married guy tries gay sex while traveling.

Gay Male 07/11/2010

Lost & Found Ch. 01

Ayden's accident unravels his world.

Gay Male 06/26/2010

Island Love

Man seduces teen on the beach for his first.

Gay Male 02/11/2010

My Leiben Herr

Innocent crossdressing leads to sex with a man.

Transsexuals & Crossdressers 12/11/2009

A Bend in the Road

A middle-aged straight man finds love with a young gay man.

Gay Male 11/24/2009
Active tags
first time gay
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ
Related Tags