‘first time gay’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
first time gay 

Category

Backseat Introduction

Girlfriend's dad and boyfriend share the back seat.

H
4.62
983.9k
1.5k
145
1.9k
0

Slutty Sleepover

Two, straight best friends make some discoveries.

H
4.6
860.5k
1.2k
84
1.6k

My Uncle's Cock

His first time giving a blowjob.

H
4.54
718k
216
94
272
0

Neighbor

Kinky wife wants to see her husband suck on a cock.

H
4.82
667.9k
1.2k
177
1.7k

Dominated By Daddy Ch. 01

A dominant and controlling older top gets what he wants

H
4.65
639.3k
845
100
1k
0

Bathing Suit Dilemma

Two straight guys get surprisingly horny in the Jacuzzi.

H
4.74
636.9k
1.2k
125
1.6k
0

Sports Massage from Friend's Dad

Friend's professional father helps with pulled muscles.

H
4.65
588.8k
987
55
1.3k

Her Boyfriend Subs In

Girlfriend uses her boyfriend for gay erotica shoot.

H
4.81
574.8k
1.4k
171
1.8k
0

She Makes Him

Kinky girlfriend seduces boyfriend into becoming her slut.

H
4.58
481.5k
614
41
910
0

Bicurious Fantasy Becomes a Reality

My fantasy of being submissive to another man is fulfilled.

H
4.65
479k
535
108
693

Tied to the Bed

Helping his best friend takes an unexpected turn.

H
4.61
430.2k
804
59
1.1k
0

My Girlfriend Turned Me Gay Ch. 02

She helps with his gay desire.

4.38
400.9k
154
36
199

A Friend's Confession

Two straight friends explore gay sex.

H
4.66
384.4k
301
31
383

Neighbor Kid

Couple initiates a young neighbor into their play.

H
4.61
381.9k
279
18
392

My First Blow Job

He gives his first blowjob at an adult bookstore.

4.48
357.8k
39
41
50
0

On the Job Training

Straight guy decides being a bottom is where it's at.

H
4.63
326.9k
258
30
308
0

Straight Best Friends Roll Together

The guys take Ecstasy and a wild night unfolds.

H
4.75
324.4k
634
47
841
0

Straight Top to Gay Bottom Toy

How my neighbor made me his cock sucking man bitch.

H
4.61
289.4k
402
28
586

Sports Massage from Friend's Dad Ch. 02

Braden's back at the Coleman household for 4th of July party.

H
4.72
288.2k
478
64
598

Bisexual Quarantine Seduction

Unexpected seduction during quarantine desperation.

HW
4.82
280.9k
519
62
757

Frat Party Costume Sex

Helping out the frat president with a costume emergency.

H
4.74
280.3k
826
47
1.1k
0

Slutty Sleepover Ch. 02

Jason and Jacob assume their roles as the night continues.

H
4.66
270.3k
538
79
677

Friend and Husband Seduction

High School best friend and bull husband take me new places.

H
4.79
264.8k
618
86
793
0

Curious with the Gay Kid

18-year-old gets big surprise during first gay experience.

4.32
253.8k
94
18
103

Turning Into a Cocksucker Ch. 01

Married Man agrees to suck cock for first time.

H
4.66
250.8k
297
88
379

Roommates Get Drunk And Horny

Straight roommates get horny after St. Paddy Day barhopping.

H
4.7
249.4k
508
41
693
0

The Holiday

Straight guy is enjoyed by his five best friends.

H
4.59
246.8k
148
22
197
0

Locker Room Surprise

A man becomes fasinated by his friend's small cock

H
4.58
244.6k
58
27
85
0

John's First Time

His wife does the teaching. He does the sucking and more.

H
4.6
240.8k
92
23
112
0

Virgin No More

"Straight" man goes to party, doesn't leave straight.

H
4.53
240.2k
179
24
232
0

Fantasy Revealed & Almost Fulfilled

Girlfriend makes fantasy come true with her strap-on.

H
4.56
235.5k
244
27
341
0

The Chance of a Lifetime

Straight guy gets fucked for the first time.

H
4.51
228.5k
68
38
88
0

Blanket Bitch

Straight friends first gay time happens under a blanket

4.31
215.6k
106
2
131
0

Summertime House-sitter's Seduction

Older men teach 20-year-old the ropes of gay sex.

H
4.67
213.6k
60
31
72
0

Bum Chums Have Fun In The Sun

A virgin stud loses his cherry to 4 hot men on the beach.

H
4.56
211k
60
0
82
0

Friends with Benefits

A friend's Halloween party ends with a surprise.

H
4.61
210.6k
113
0
154

I Used to be Straight

Divorced guy has shower sex with muscular cousin.

4.29
210.1k
57
6
80

Short-Term in Chicago

Straight guy is seduced by gay neighbor.

H
4.64
206.4k
155
29
210

Barbell Bottom

Seduced at my apartment gym.

H
4.74
205.7k
462
57
645
0

First Time In Front of My Wife

I was encouraged to suck a man by my wife.

4.38
199.5k
62
18
83
0

Bisexual Orgy Newbies

First bisexual orgy with my insatiable wife.

H
4.85
198.1k
446
42
658
0

Straight Invaded Pt. 01

Married straight man turned by home invaders.

H
4.54
197.6k
147
14
239

Hotel Rooms are for Horny Boys

Boys get way too drunk on spring break couple's vacation.

H
4.67
197.1k
336
34
465
0

Hell Night

18-year-old is taken in church.

4.24
195.6k
124
18
149
0

Straight Guy with a Gay Friend

When simple curiosity and fantasy becomes real.

4.17
195.6k
34
5
56
0

Blowjobs for Beers

Teenage boy is forced to suck cock for beer.

H
4.58
194.2k
387
19
512

A True Bisexual First

Twenty-year-old is seduced by an older gentleman.

4.32
193.4k
29
10
35
0

Evening in the Dunes

Friend is broken into at cottage, & loves it.

H
4.54
192.8k
31
13
39
0

A Friend's Confession Ch. 2

Straight male friends continue to explore with wives' help.

H
4.7
191.8k
125
27
142

Huge

His new penis did not want his wife. It wanted men.

4.48
187.2k
158
15
196
0

Las Vegas Best Friend Threesome

Three best friends vacation in Sin City and sin becomes them.

H
4.71
185.6k
289
9
388

State Fair Hypnotist

Girlfriend discovers the guys are still hypnotized.

H
4.81
183.7k
509
40
677
0

Vacation at the Beach

Guy takes an island beach vacation.

H
4.51
174.5k
50
16
65
0

His First Taste of a Man

She arranges a same-sex encounter for him.

H
4.56
173.9k
53
12
68
0

Trapped

Two straight guys trapped in the snow do what they must.

H
4.56
171.9k
385
54
555
0

Being Taken

An alpha bull turns a straight man into a submissive slut.

H
4.56
170.8k
249
17
376

Pantyhose Seduction

He seduces a "straight" cop.

4.37
169.6k
26
11
37

My Best Friend

A typical day between two friends turns into something more.

4.41
166.5k
73
11
101
0

Failed Threesome

Bi-curious guy gets his man-card permanently revoked by bull.

4.31
164.8k
210
30
322
0

Big Bot, Sex Hot, Breeder Gets Laid

Sex-starved guy gives in to gay colleague's desire.

4.45
163.7k
62
0
77
0

Show Me Yours

Can a bi-guy seduce his gay roommate?

H
4.71
162.2k
212
28
286
0

Rest Stop Management

Young married man forced to suck a stranger's cock.

H
4.52
161.9k
190
18
283

Dick in an Elevator - I'm Not Gay!

Straight man meets big dick up close and personal.

H
4.55
158.7k
107
16
185
0

Dressing Room Encounter

Straight man's gay encounter in a dept. store dressing room.

H
4.72
158.3k
109
21
183
0

I Fell In with The Masseur

Man finds out he's gay & finds happiness.

H
4.62
157.7k
64
22
82
0

Discretion Has Its Rewards

He joins a couple to satisfy wife's unusual desires.

H
4.57
157.5k
100
22
144
0

Spring Break Boys

Spring break drugs lead to first time gay sex.

H
4.79
156.4k
380
45
604
0

Bi-Sexual Seminar

Two straight guys explore bi-sexual fun.

4.16
155.1k
35
9
49
0

Please Wait for Me

Two troubled men find each other at an airport gate.

H
4.87
154.8k
257
124
331
0

Jogging Quickie

A neighborhood jog leads to first time magic.

H
4.7
154.2k
366
46
501

Island Love

Man seduces teen on the beach for his first.

4.43
152.1k
59
13
71

The Arrangement

With the lockdown in full swing, two housemates make do.

HW
4.87
151.1k
329
37
518

Becoming a Star

Two straight men find more in a gay porno done for money.

H
4.77
150.3k
302
27
387
0

A Hot Visit with a Neighbor

Divorcé joins his neighbor for more than just pizza.

H
4.5
147.8k
50
24
58
0

A Bend in the Road

A middle-aged straight man finds love with a young gay man.

H
4.55
147.7k
63
19
92

Finding Myself

Teen with a much older man.

4.19
145.6k
12
9
21
0

New Gym Friend

Straight man is seduced after a workout.

4.33
144.7k
92
14
123

Getting Even The Hard Way

Cheating leads to gay humiliation.

3.95
142.8k
47
14
65
0

Sarah's Poker Surprise

Surprise bi first time.

4.32
141.3k
39
8
53

Kitty Ch. 01

He becomes Kitty, and takes his first man.

4.37
140.6k
31
3
42
0

How I Lost My Anal Virginity

My first time losing my anal virginity to a 9 in cock.

H
4.52
138.5k
52
17
69
0

Poppers as Punishment

Fantasy Football Punishment Takes a Turn.

H
4.61
138.2k
317
20
470
0

Losing My Virginity To My Dad

He wanted to see if I inherited his dick.

H
4.63
137.3k
173
16
306
0

Party with Wife and Her Lover

Conned into gay encounter.

4.2
136.1k
83
13
101
0

Road Trip Turnout

Straight man turned gay sex servant.

H
4.66
133.7k
122
7
210

That Photo!

A straight man bends a little.

H
4.63
132.4k
48
6
70
0

My First Time Experience

My first time gay experience, and how I knew I was bisexual.

4.17
131.7k
27
11
34
0

I'm Not Gay - But

High school senior is seduced by family friend.

4.19
131.3k
26
7
34
0

Falling for Matt

Falling helplessly in love with my straight best friend.

H
4.76
129k
254
36
340
0

Finding My Boyfriend's Dildo

Finding my boyfriend's dildo leads to even bigger secrets.

H
4.85
128.3k
409
70
639
0

First Time Ch. 01

Married bisexual man has his first same-sex encounter.

4.24
128k
18
6
29

Bruce Don't Go There

His straight buddy introduces him to his dark side.

3.92
127k
14
0
25
0

The Daughter's Boyfriend

A father's descent into gay submission begins.

H
4.67
126.5k
188
15
280

Turning Out the Wife

Husband Introduces Wife to a Special Lady.

H
4.77
125.9k
149
23
239
0

The First Time for My Father

Charles has to finally face the truth, he wants his son.

H
4.54
125.6k
158
12
208
0

Boredom Can Be Dangerous Ch. 02

Young husband has sex with Father-in-Law.

H
4.5
124.4k
94
6
113

A Quiet Understanding

Straight man introduced to erotic male massage.

H
4.55
123.7k
119
21
157
0

My Cross Country Adventure

Kind elderly gentleman helps student in distress.

H
4.69
123.4k
49
19
66
0

My Photo Shoot

My first time with another man is during a modeling shoot.

4.32
123.1k
29
4
41
0

International Relations

Straight man reluctantly introduced to gay sex.

4.45
122.7k
59
8
81
0
Active tags
Active tags
first time gay
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ