‘first time gay’ stories
Active tags
Active tags
Neighbor
Kinky wife wants to see her husband suck on a cock.
She Makes Him
Kinky girlfriend seduces boyfriend into becoming her slut.
Neighbor Kid
Couple initiates a young neighbor into their play.
The Holiday
Straight guy is enjoyed by his five best friends.
Blanket Bitch
Straight friends first gay time happens under a blanket
Huge
His new penis did not want his wife. It wanted men.
Trapped
Two straight guys trapped in the snow do what they must.
Being Taken
An alpha bull turns a straight man into a submissive slut.
My Best Friend
A typical day between two friends turns into something more.
Island Love
Man seduces teen on the beach for his first.
My Photo Shoot
My first time with another man is during a modeling shoot.
Separate tags with commas. More info in the
FAQ