‘first time lesbian’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
first time lesbian 

Category

Locker Room Shower

Erin’s new position with the secretly lesbian sports team.

H
4.62
135.1k
195
13
310
0

A Conspiracy of Circumstances

Annie's bi-sexual curiosity tempted fate, and fate won!

H
4.64
29.1k
38
7
68

First Steps Ch. 01: A Trip to Heaven

A shy Asian girl is tempted on a night out.

H
4.7
38.3k
74
27
108
0

Captain of Her Heart

Two cheerleaders take their friendship to the next level.

H
4.54
59.1k
52
10
88
0

Submission! (with a Student?)

Professor tries a new sport and gets owned on bottom.

H
4.71
70.4k
99
18
143
0

PTA Diaries - Lips for Licking

Rimming, sucking, and licking the new church mom.

H
4.61
86.3k
100
15
143
0

Hazel

A powerful witch finds her soulmate.

H
4.8
35.2k
130
31
196

PTA Diaries - Mindy’s Breast Milk

Teacher shares her breasts with a new friend.

H
4.68
99.9k
131
18
206

Alicia's First Lesbian Sex Ch. 01

Alicia continues to cheat on her husband.

4.01
39.2k
14
2
25
0

A Welcomed Delay

Kassie's canceled flight leads to a hot new experience.

4.45
47.7k
28
7
37
0

New Neighbor

You're so glad you worked from home today.

4.24
44.2k
14
4
21
0

Intrusion Ch. 10

Epilogue: The geek and the soldier.

H
4.64
3.3k
1
1
2

Isn’t She Vibrant? (Office Squirt)

Professors discreetly share a powerful vibrator.

H
4.66
79.9k
87
13
129
0

PTA Diaries - Strap-On Submissive

When a PTA mom gets owned by the sexy principal.

H
4.63
113.4k
146
10
191

Wife Ch. 01: Tijuana

Wife finds out about herself.

4.22
22.6k
15
5
28

Dinner Party Cum Eating

"Shoshana, do you prefer tasting husbands or wives?"

H
4.52
112.5k
132
20
218
0

Turning Contest: A Fateful Birthday

MILF seduces chubby cute girl at the beach.

H
4.72
91.8k
90
16
135
0

Violating Sandie Ch. 05

Sandie's conditioning is activated by accident.

H
4.74
58.7k
65
5
83

Dinner Party Sex-Object

"I want you naked on the table for my guests."

H
4.65
120.9k
147
30
221
0

Straight Girl Problems

Her BFFs are straight. There's a first time for everything.

HW
4.81
300.5k
373
54
567
0

Mouse

What happens when the assistant gets caught pleasing herself.

4.49
68.3k
46
9
63
0

Country Girl

A simple country girl has a big surprise for this city girl.

H
4.53
55.5k
124
9
192
0

Gay for Candy

Afraid he's been turned gay, Ash must confess to his girl.

H
4.81
38.9k
99
22
160
0

My Parent's Neighbors Pt. 03

Samantha asks Casey to help her with a problem.

4.3
27.5k
13
1
19

Allison's Addiction Ch. 04

A straight girl is pushed into lesbian sex.

H
4.72
80k
66
11
89

Edie's Adventures: First Class Beginnings

An air hostess has a life-changing experience in Rome.

H
4.55
27.2k
24
5
32
0

Hotel Rooms are for Horny Boys

Boys get way too drunk on spring break couple's vacation.

H
4.67
196.5k
337
34
464
0

Soccer Girls Have Naughty Fun

A long bus ride leads two best friends to experiment.

H
4.64
145.9k
193
7
286
0

The Pro Boner Doctor Ch. 03

Susie has to re-negotiate the deal with the doctor.

4.4
14.4k
4
0
4

Le Chateau Club: Bride-to-Be Straight No More

A straight woman discovers the joys of lesbian sex.

H
4.61
114.2k
159
19
225
0

Riley Seduces Elderly Couple

College grad introduces elderly woman to lesbian.

4.05
33.3k
17
0
23
0

Trio Ch. 01

A "Yummy" girl and a spicy redhead get together.

4.4
14.1k
13
4
21
0

Straight Top to Gay Bottom Toy Ch. 04

Candy's turnout continues as Tina takes control.

H
4.74
49.6k
61
7
77

Dressing to Thrill

Girls with extra-long nipples discover extra-long orgasms.

H
4.56
43.5k
28
10
48
0

NYU Summer Break Threesome

Girlfriend's best friend comes to visit during summer.

H
4.76
140.8k
190
12
297
0

The Brave

Kindly barmaid and vengeful Lakota connect in 1882 Arizona.

H
4.85
43.6k
79
31
113
0

Borrowing a Book

A chance meeting with an ex-teacher leads to lust.

H
4.7
49.2k
73
16
100
0

Playing the Game

A woman finds love through the game of soccer.

H
4.69
27.4k
77
13
90
0

A God of Old Ch. 10

Next steps are discussed; another priestess is broken.

H
4.57
14.4k
10
1
13

The Valentine's Day Mascara Ch. 01

Frustrated young woman in need of sex finds adventure.

4.27
18.1k
11
4
13

Pam's Lesbian Experience

Someone from her recent past helps fulfill another fantasy.

4.49
29.7k
31
1
40
0

Lace Curtains on a VW Van

Keep their secret safe from prying eyes.

H
4.58
20.4k
19
2
26
0

Room Service New Girl

Stockings games and erotic gifts.

H
4.67
62.1k
57
10
89
0

Tricked into Lesbian Sex and Love

She disguises herself as a man and seduces a straight girl.

4.18
72.6k
39
1
76
0

Snakebite Ch. 01

A snakebite to the butt leads to desperate measures.

H
4.66
65.5k
92
7
127
0

J&S Journey - Sidestory Ch. 03

Jessica Finds her Perfect Woman.

3.57
9.7k
4
2
9

J&S Journey - Sidestory Ch. 01

Jessica Dominates Young Girls.

3.7
24.7k
12
4
24

Short Shorts

A surprise sighting of a new neighbor leads to romance.

H
4.79
83.2k
169
39
241
0

A God of Old Ch. 08

He shows more of his priestesses what it means to serve him.

H
4.69
16.2k
10
2
18

Love's Embrace

Two amateur ghost hunters discover a love long past.

H
4.54
12.2k
16
7
18
0

For the First Erotic Scene

Filming sex can be difficult for an actress.

H
4.7
85.3k
88
11
146
0

Overdue

A library is no place to be so overdue.

H
4.65
39.2k
37
11
67
0

Quite Neighborly

The neighbors have a secret that will shake up Wendy's world.

H
4.74
105.8k
100
12
153
0

Jim's Genie Ch. 01

I wish my wife would fuck the genie.

4.32
49.3k
63
12
89

My Metamorphosis

Change can be a good thing.

4.49
21.5k
6
2
14
0

Rose and Dragon

A young sorority initiate is pulled over for speeding.

4.33
44.4k
13
7
20
0

Agents of Pleasure Ch. 02

Marie stirs a memory.

H
4.67
11.3k
9
1
11

Agents of Pleasure Ch. 01

There's no such thing as a coincidence!

H
4.52
18.2k
25
1
45

Penny Wants To Experiment: Ch. 01

A woman fantasizes about women and makes it a reality.

4.39
19.8k
11
6
14
0

Karen's First Time (Lesbian)

Karen's First time Lesbian experience.

H
4.54
97.5k
39
14
56
0

Kelsey's World Ch. 40

Wendy and Barb talk at the gym.

H
4.84
23.2k
9
0
15

X-Rated: Daddy's old VCR Tapes

Looking at her father's old Porn gives two friends ideas.

4.29
73.9k
40
4
64
0

Housesitting Ch. 02

Tara is shocked when her mother walks in Delores' house.

H
4.66
66.5k
43
13
54

How I Became a Real Woman

From straight woman on her Honeymoon to lesbian wife.

4.46
125.7k
78
31
115
0

Last Day of School Pt. 02

Maria and Riley decide to take it home.

4.47
20.8k
16
1
18

Mountain Trip with My Bestie

A trip away with my bestie satisfies certain desires.

4.47
44.5k
19
3
36
0

Lana's First Taste of Milk

Nursing the professor's lactating breasts.

H
4.72
139.2k
219
27
323
0

Pleasure & Business

Lawyer duties and a hardcore lifestyle.

H
4.63
64.7k
59
6
92
0

Overtime at the Office

A young woman is seduced by her lesbian boss.

H
4.65
160k
164
13
254
0

Afternoon Daydreams Ch. 02: Meeting Her

I re-imagine what my first time with a woman could have been.

4.46
12.8k
8
3
12

Lactating Breasts, Office Girl

Sucking the boss’s milky breasts at work.

H
4.73
325.3k
478
47
666
0

Fantasy Costume Party

Costumes help a shy woman fulfill boyfriend's fantasy.

4.41
47.8k
41
5
57
0

Pregnant Passions

Britt has a secret fantasy and Shelly can help fulfill it.

H
4.6
71.8k
61
13
78
0

House of Lana's Breast Milk

Working mom seduces & breastfeeds the new babysitter.

H
4.71
334.4k
432
38
636
0

There I Was

Confessions of a pretty little Asian raver girl.

H
4.52
53.4k
50
4
90
0

A Girl and Her Coach

Kissing each other in the pool & locker room.

H
4.69
193.5k
275
40
385
0

A Girl who Squirts

Roommates share a brand new vibrator.

H
4.68
249.5k
283
25
417
0

Prof. Keeley & the Sorority Girls

Backstage gloryhole before the choir performance.

H
4.58
87.7k
125
7
210
0

Gotham Nights Ch. 12

Talia Al Ghul captures Catwoman, with unexpected results.

H
4.61
11.8k
11
1
18

Threat of Foreclosure Ch. 03

Tanya proves her value to the studio.

H
4.51
9.1k
2
2
2

How I Seduced the Professor

Slowly vibrating the teacher’s pussy (in class).

H
4.64
191.2k
256
17
370
0

Overwhelming Darkness Ch. 02

Confusion reigns when she awakens next to a naked woman.

4.47
13.4k
11
0
12

Summer Afternoon Fun

The first time I played with another woman.

4.21
54.2k
28
19
39
0

Crimi, For My Friends

When does "curiosity" end, and "orientation" begin?

3.58
17.2k
8
2
12
0

Policewomen Ep. 05: Cindy

Unable to orgasm, a friend suggests she date women.

0
24k
20
2
28

Giving What I Need

A first time lesbian fantasy is more than just fantasy...

3.97
20.6k
6
3
8
0

Lingerie Mom Ch. 02

The benefits of Agent Provocateur's generous return policy.

H
4.72
117.1k
157
10
214

As The Professor Speaks

When a teacher/student relationship turns erotic.

H
4.77
195.7k
338
69
430
0

Hmmm... Her Surprise Birthday

She receives a surprise and wildly erotic birthday present.

H
4.75
35.7k
9
1
19
0

The It-Girl's Assistant

An assistant. Her famous crush. His fiance. A hot night.

4.42
27.2k
11
3
16
0

Across The Water Ch. 01

Coming of age and learning about love, sex and life.

4.2
7.7k
5
1
8
0

Jennifer’s Loving Daughter

Mother & Daughter share a connection over a vibrator.

H
4.65
249.3k
272
26
416
0

She Loves Sucking Cock

Office party lets Erin showcase her oral sex abilities.

H
4.67
169.9k
222
14
339
0

Sweet Gwendoline Ch. 08

Gwen is abused by Robin, then seduced by Julie.

H
4.7
39.7k
33
5
42

An Enchanted Desire

A young witch uses her powers in a forbidden way.

H
4.72
46.4k
69
14
108
0

J&S Journey into Insatiable Ch. 02

Jessica Teaches Young Girl not to Mess with her Man.

4.13
36k
9
2
13

Red Lipstick Paradise

Pop star explores her exhibitionist sexual fantasies.

H
4.6
48.6k
47
5
71
0

Taylor Pays for College Ch. 02

Taylor continues to try and earn her tuition.

H
4.68
68.3k
36
8
50

Taylor Pays for College

A freshman has a unique financial aid plan.

4.46
115k
107
11
163

Seducing Jenna

Older woman seduces teen girl.

H
4.71
246.6k
254
31
331
0
Active tags
Active tags
first time lesbian
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ