Try the free LITEROTICA WEBCAMS!

‘first time’ and ‘straight’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
first timestraight 

Category

Sort by:
ViewsRatingFavoriteNewest
7 Days30 DaysAll Time

My Baseball Buddy

My new neighbor invited me over to watch baseball, and...

by AtlantisGuy in Gay Male 04/18/2024
H
4.81
25k
70
18
112

Two Straight Guys Ch. 02

Lee and George take it to the next level.

by TwistedManc in Gay Male 04/14/2024
H
4.85
10.9k
31
9
54

Straight Vegas Nights

Carson's bachelor party takes a turn with his best bud.

by Grayson87 in Gay Male 04/28/2024
H
4.72
10.9k
31
2
54
0

My Baseball Buddy Ch. 02

The next day I was still trying to make sense of everything.

by AtlantisGuy in Gay Male 04/25/2024
H
4.87
7.3k
20
6
38

My Baseball Buddy Ch. 03

Our friendship, and our fucking, blurred. With the game on.

by AtlantisGuy in Gay Male 04/28/2024
H
4.9
6.6k
16
3
33

Used by Backpacking Frat Bros Pt. 03

Patrick realizes what Nick's done with Josh.

by jtwy in Gay Male 05/07/2024
NEWH
4.73
5k
18
4
23
0

Straight Man forced sell underwear

My Girlfriend forced me to sell my underwear and get sucked.

by MuscleLooking in NonConsent/Reluctance 04/14/2024
4.21
4.8k
3
1
8
0

My Baseball Buddy Ch. 04

The sex was epic... but the feelings were becoming... more.

by AtlantisGuy in Gay Male 05/02/2024
H
4.89
4.5k
10
2
25

The Most Mysterious Song

It's never too late to hear the music.

by AwkwardApple415 in Lesbian Sex 04/25/2024
H
4.85
4.2k
23
22
46
0

My Baseball Buddy Ch. 05

Nate and I try to make sense of the magical weekend we had.

by AtlantisGuy in Gay Male 05/07/2024
NEWH
4.89
3.7k
4
2
11

My Baseball Buddy Ch. 06

Nate and I try to finally work things out.

by AtlantisGuy in Gay Male 05/11/2024
NEWH
4.95
637
2
1
3
Active tags
Active tags
first timestraight
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ
Related Tags
Show More