‘first time’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
first time 

Category

Use Your Sisters Instead

To stay out of hell, he'll have to stick it in his sisters.

H
4.67
2.25M
4.5k
339
6.1k
0

Road Trip with Mom Ch. 01

Busty mom and well-hung son go on a cross country road trip.

H
4.66
2.26M
2.8k
63
3.9k

Daddy, It Doesn't Fit!

Daughter asks Daddy to fill in on sex-tape dare.

4.46
1.95M
2.3k
232
3.2k
0

Word of Mouth

Not the usual, run-of-the-mill first-time story.

HW
4.88
1.85M
2.2k
773
2.6k
0

Beauty and the Geek Ch. 01

The rumors were true; the geek was hung.

H
4.68
984.4k
2.1k
0
2.8k

Daddy's Perfect Fucktoy Pt. 01

Can a father turn his daughter into the perfect fucktoy?

4.42
1.48M
1.9k
66
2.7k

The Class Nudist

Carson discovers the secret side to his lab partner.

H
4.8
974.3k
1.7k
294
2.1k
0

Shemale Surprise

A married man is seduced and taken by a friend of his wife's.

H
4.68
1.29M
1.7k
236
2.2k
0

How I Became A Gay Cock Slut

Young married man is seduced at a resort.

H
4.56
1.79M
1.6k
239
2k

Shhh!

Julie's little brother will never know what she did, right?

HW
4.81
821.9k
1.6k
186
2.4k
0

Backseat Introduction

Girlfriend's dad and boyfriend share the back seat.

H
4.62
984.1k
1.5k
145
1.9k
0

The Blushing Bride

Wedding night of arranged marriage.

4.39
1.3M
1.4k
104
1.8k
0

Oh My God, Bro!

A little trick creates a big problem for Tammy's brother

HW
4.81
706k
1.4k
235
2.4k
0

Blackmailed: Cheerleader's Mom

He forces the Cheerleader's Mom to be his eager ass-slut too.

H
4.6
1.44M
1.4k
83
1.8k
0

My Brother Broke Me

Injury leads to intimacy, incest, and impregnation.

H
4.66
624.4k
1.3k
119
2.2k
0

Daddy's Sunshine

I'm the only light in Daddy's life. He proves it once I'm 18.

H
4.55
819.7k
1.3k
178
1.9k

Senior Year Memories Ch. 01

A virgin nerd's HS senior year takes a surprise turn.

H
4.77
598.6k
1.3k
42
1.9k

Your Brother has to Cum

Siblings should stick together.

H
4.63
994.8k
1.3k
149
2k
0

My Sister Eva Continues It All

Brother-sister love grows as she includes many more.

H
4.75
511.9k
1.3k
160
1.7k
0

Cold Sister

Little sis needs my special heat.

H
4.81
390.2k
1.2k
137
2k
0

Waiting in Line for the New iPad

Waiting outside the Apple Store becomes a magical experience.

H
4.81
600.1k
1.2k
64
1.4k
0

Party Slut

Never fall asleep at parties!

H
4.54
969.8k
1.2k
104
1.5k
0

Endangered Ch. 01

A young dragon awakens.

H
4.8
513.8k
1.2k
50
1.6k

Tortured by the T-Girl Tutor

His world turned upside down and his ass inside out.

H
4.58
570k
1.1k
96
1.4k
0

I'm Coming! I'm Coming!

My younger sister is always running late.

H
4.74
437k
1.1k
130
1.9k
0

We Can Go Too Far

My sister likes taking risks.

H
4.65
540.4k
1.1k
69
1.7k
0

His Teacher, The Transsexual

A young man ends up very close to a teacher with a secret.

H
4.66
683.1k
1.1k
115
1.3k
0

"What Does She See in Him?"

A high school boy finds the girl of his dreams is a bit more.

H
4.64
504.7k
1.1k
45
1.5k
0

Just the Tip

He's too big for her tight backdoor, but just the tip...

H
4.73
680.7k
1.1k
59
1.5k
0

Beyond the Borderline

Mother and son find a love like no other.

H
4.72
876.1k
1k
128
1.5k

Sexy Doctor Gives Prostate Exam

Guy is surprised when female Dr. shows up for prostate exam.

H
4.72
521k
1k
98
1.5k
0

That's what Big Sisters are For

My older sister takes charge of my sex life.

H
4.75
356.6k
1k
123
1.7k
0

Tamed by Meg

Megan introduces me to the pleasures of being penetrated.

H
4.65
704.3k
1k
90
1.5k
0

It's Only Fair Pt. 01

Siblings stripping escalates to something spectacular.

H
4.81
371.5k
1k
69
1.6k

Sharing Dirty Stories With Sister

Our common interest keeps us cumming together.

H
4.8
290.8k
1k
112
1.6k
0

Double Blind Date

Two women who believe they are straight are set up on a date

H
4.82
302.6k
947
381
1.1k
0

Friend's Father

During a long weekend at a friend's, his father takes me.

H
4.54
871.6k
933
73
1.2k

Shemale Sister-in-Law

Man gets massage from sister-in-law with shocking results.

H
4.69
555.3k
918
97
1.2k
0

Private Lessons

Hot teacher gives her virgin student some special lessons.

HW
4.85
676k
855
105
1.2k
0

Path of the Necromancer Ch. 03

Ian learns what it means to be a necromancer.

H
4.86
249.4k
845
483
891

Anything I Want?

A poker bet puts Jackie's tight ass in the pot.

H
4.73
587.2k
841
44
1.2k
0

Sibling Swap

Fucking my sister's friend was just the beginning.

H
4.69
465k
832
95
1.3k
0

Daddy Didn't Pull Pt. 01

Daddy forgets his promise to Jenny.

H
4.65
668.1k
830
38
1.3k

Cuckolding my Husband

How my husband and I had our first Cuckolding adventure.

4.43
1.12M
828
340
1.1k
0

"We'll Do Your Mom First," I Said

Two virgins decide to seduce their moms.

H
4.7
1.22M
817
194
1k
0

Tied to the Bed

Helping his best friend takes an unexpected turn.

H
4.61
430.3k
804
59
1.1k
0

The Boys Next Door Ch. 01

Shy honors student lusts after the twins next door.

H
4.77
324.6k
787
36
1k

Straight Guy: Big Dick Syndrome

Seeing colleague's big dick in hotel room makes him curious.

H
4.68
623.3k
783
115
1k
0

Her Best Friend's Daughter

Karen helps her friend's daughter explore the softer sex.

H
4.79
614.9k
782
107
1k
0

My Evil Stepsister

My mother remarries a man with a daughter.

H
4.71
335.2k
769
218
963
0

A Nerds Last Laugh

Nerd gets last laugh on sis and friends.

H
4.68
284.2k
766
81
1.1k
0

Truth or Dare at Sister's Sleepover

Four girls, one guy play the game at his sister's sleepover.

4.48
844.7k
761
41
991
0

Keep it Down in There!

My sister is such a sexy bitch.

H
4.76
267.8k
720
85
944
0

Bathed in Sun, Naked Sister

Sister, her virgin brother, and a modeling job.

H
4.59
530.8k
711
51
981
0

Ms. Walker's Class Ch. 01

She helps him with a BIG problem.

H
4.69
593.3k
707
27
1k

New Girl in Town Pt. 01

Will the arrival of a new girl at school change his luck?

H
4.77
322.3k
701
63
996

Geek's BIG Break Ch. 02

Geo owns Twin Cheerleaders and his sister too. Mom's next.

H
4.61
359k
683
74
858

Cocksucking College Sister: Fucked

A brother finally fucks his shy, beautiful sister.

H
4.67
722.9k
682
42
866

Tricked into Lesbian Submission

Straight girl is tricked into becoming a submissive pet.

H
4.63
569.2k
681
93
975
0

A Sleepover Confession

Getting taken while everyone's watching a movie...

H
4.71
260k
677
67
956
0

To Fuck My Own Daughter

Clay bonds with his shy daughter by showing her how to fuck.

4.47
367.9k
665
35
980

Camera Buff

High school photography session gets out of control.

H
4.75
522.5k
657
57
816

My Brother, My Master

A trip to the Amazon has sister submit to her nerdy brother.

H
4.54
437.5k
645
37
898
0

Thank Heaven for Little Girls

Divorced man at a Catholic Girls school.

H
4.73
315.7k
637
62
907

Off with Her Pants

Relly discovers her sexuality and her brother. Concurrently.

H
4.8
307.8k
636
102
873
0

Wish Box

Guy finds a magic box that makes his life more interesting.

H
4.54
383.5k
634
29
1k

A Dare is a Dare

A night playing together corrupts a father and daughter.

H
4.83
296.4k
627
105
1k
0

Ashley's Dark Awakening Ch. 01

Ashley falls for a dark, dirty trick with a black man...

4.48
513.4k
624
40
854

Pushing Buttons

In love with his best friend the lesbian.

H
4.73
255.2k
621
65
867
0

My Virgin Nephew

Aunt helps nephew overcome nervousness with girls.

H
4.73
609.4k
608
95
854
0

Milky Ranch

Twins get milky fun during a summer on Daddy's Ranch

H
4.53
400.4k
604
20
851

A Massage for Mom's Headache

A simple neck massage became complicated.

H
4.79
297.1k
603
72
974

Motherfuckinghell

18 year old virgin looses his virginity in dark closet.

H
4.69
442.2k
600
66
748
0

Blackmail Has Consequences

Son catches mom cheating and makes her pay.

H
4.64
605.5k
599
65
760
0

Drink or Dare

A drinking game with new friends changes everything.

H
4.73
394.7k
596
65
833
0

Genie Chronicles Ch. 01

Jack's sexual Genie servant is out of the box.

H
4.75
424.3k
594
21
697

Teen Turns: Boyfriend's Mom

Sweet teen virgin is seduced by her boyfriend's pretty Mom

H
4.65
447.7k
587
72
853

Who's Your Daddy

Case of mistaken paternity leads to daddy breeding daughter.

H
4.69
253.6k
586
31
1.1k
0

Summer Sabbatical

Romance studies at Aunt Ava's beach retreat.

H
4.84
504.2k
585
152
866
0

A Boy's Last Summer

Passions flare between an older woman and her summer hire.

H
4.81
298.2k
581
90
810

The Bet

Hung girl wagers that Billy will love her cock in his ass.

H
4.76
187.2k
570
44
908
0

Intruder Ch. 01

Overpowered in her own home with no protection.

4.29
490.6k
563
22
840

Sisters

Twins fight and then learn about sex with their cousin.

HW
4.77
926.6k
562
86
727
0

Because I'm Your Sister Ch. 01

The one girl he wants is the one he can't have. Or can he?

H
4.61
363.7k
560
33
823

The Innocent Bride

A sheltered young woman finds herself wed to a stranger.

H
4.57
375.5k
545
32
668
0

The Supplement Pt. 01

Son's mail order pills pulls mom out of her shell.

H
4.79
162.2k
543
56
947

The Last Boy Scout Ch. 02

The Camp Savior, and hotel Alex gets 5 guests.

H
4.83
648.8k
542
42
618

From Dork to Dapper

Sister remakes brother, brother makes her pregnant.

H
4.71
234.9k
540
39
817
0

Two Friends Share A Halloween Costume

Straight buddies enjoy gay sex inside a costume.

H
4.52
480.8k
533
32
670

Claire's Prom Night

A special night made extra special by her father.

H
4.62
368.8k
532
33
787
0

Puppy Girl: The Stray

A broken man, an innocent injured girl, a time for healing.

H
4.55
173.3k
530
127
700
0

My Niece's High School Graduation

Well-endowed Uncle Jeff takes care of naive young Emma.

H
4.75
282.1k
530
19
775
0

Johnny's Big Secret

It's his freakishly huge dick. Duh.

H
4.8
196.7k
526
108
980
0

White Cocksucker

Seeing a big black cock in sauna turns straight married man.

H
4.61
551.4k
525
152
684
0

Dirty Naked Poker Pt. 02

Five people. Three friends. Two siblings. All come together.

H
4.71
258.9k
522
101
677

Captured

Eighteen-year-old girl kidnapped and taken.

4.18
424.3k
517
8
742

Massage Therapy Ch. 01

Sister's aching breasts need a massage.

H
4.67
331.2k
515
25
848

Young Wife's First Glory Hole

Wife goes to an adult bookstore with husband.

4.43
407.2k
514
37
757
0

The Deal

Freddy's wife convinces him to dress up and go clubbing.

H
4.67
239.4k
510
61
702

Jimmy's Mom

His friends help mom recover from a bad Halloween date.

4.47
284.2k
508
31
662
Active tags
Active tags
first time
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ