‘gay first time’ stories

Active tags
gay anal (360)bisexual male (311)gay blowjob (173)gay oral (172)gay romance (122)anal (115)first time (109)blowjob (89)gay virgin (87)college (80)bisexual husband (70)gay (70)gay college (69)gay drama (68)18-year-old (63)oral (62)bicurious male (50)gay novella (49)gay husband (48)mmf (46)threesome (45)gay d/s (45)male virgin (44)his first time (43)first time gay (43)blow job (41)anal sex (39)bisexual (39)cum (38)gay interracial (37)gay seduction (34)older man (32)gay older man (31)interracial (30)gay male (30)gay blow job (30)gay stranger (29)two men one woman (29)gay bdsm (28)drama (27)straight (27)gay masturbation (26)gay forced (25)male masturbation (25)stranger (24)domination (24)gay 18-year-old (24)rimming (23)oral sex (23)masturbation (23)submissive (23)gay anal sex (23)gay incest (22)gay oral sex (21)male bisexual (21)shower (21)twink (21)gay younger man (20)bareback (20)big cock (20)submission (19)gay submissive (19)humiliation (19)outdoors (19)gay age difference (19)muscle (19)virgin (18)bicurious (18)best friends (18)mutual masturbation (17)younger man (17)gay domination (17)romance (17)gay bondage (17)gay rimming (16)forced (16)massage (16)gay love (16)crossdressing (15)blackmail (15)gay cocksucking (15)gay love story (15)gay threesome (15)gay massage (15)gay submission (15)male submissive (14)friends (14)friend (14)seduction (14)anal first time (14)cock sucking (14)handjob (14)married (14)gay group (13)gay kissing (13)crossdresser (13)curious (13)romantic (13)gay sex (13)gay shower (13)first gay blowjob (13)gay cock sucking (12)roommate (12)gay orgy (12)gym (12)voyeur (12)huge cock (12)gay nonconsent (12)gay reluctance (12)gay handjob (12)gay public (12)swallowing (11)cocksucking (11)cum swallowing (11)reluctance (11)nudity (11)bondage (11)gay athlete (11)gay cum (11)jock (11)femdom (11)forced gay (10)18 year old (10)force (10)gay friend (10)gay ravishment (10)gay twink (10)drunk (10)coming out (10)gay bottom (10)creampie (10)bi-curious male (10)hairy (9)cocksucker (9)jocks (9)black cock (9)camping (9)group sex (9)cum eating (9)gay friends (9)gay military (9)gay older-younger (9)gay roommate (9)gay cruising (8)seduced (8)older-younger (8)caught (8)hotel (8)gay bear (8)cuckold (8)panties (8)gay college guy (8)spanking (8)strap-on (8)manscent (8)gay blackmail (8)male dominant (8)transgender (8)gay jock (8)deep throat (8)gay gangbang (8)black man (8)gay hunk (8)bisexual male threesome (8)gay swallow (8)pegging (8)straight guy (8)gay married (7)gay black (7)fingering (7)19-year-old (7)romance novella (7)nonconsent (7)stockings (7)transvestite (7)swinging (7)student (7)married men (7)public (7)gay muscle (7)sissy (7)gentle femdom (7)gay sucking (7)gay gym (7)neighbor (7)gloryhole (7)gay big cock (7)gay asian (7)big cocks (7)first blowjob (7)jerking off (6)master (6)gay kiss (6)mmm (6)orgy (6)gay gloryhole (6)wife (6)lesbian (6)glory hole (6)military (6)gay deepthroat (6)first time anal (6)gay locker room (6)gay double penetration (6)gay cop (6)sauna (6)surprise (6)best friend (6)gay romantic (6)fellatio (6)historical (6)incest (6)musician (6)gay outdoors (6)gay cyber (6)foursome (6)kissing (6)submissive male (5)anal orgasm (5)lingerie (5)cock sucker (5)sucking cock (5)daddy (5)nerd (5)masseur (5)gay blow jobs (5)love story (5)gay coed (5)bi-curious (5)first time bisexual (5)older man younger man (5)bisexual boyfriend (5)roommates (5)
gay first time 

It's Hump Time!

I finally get fucked hard - and more than once!

Gay Male 11/21/2018

First Time I Sucked Off Another Guy

I get my first taste of sexual experimentation in college.

Gay Male 10/04/2018

I'm Bisexual

My first time with a guy.

Gay Male 10/02/2018

One Day at the Adult Bookstore

A new experience at an adult bookstore

Gay Male 10/01/2018

Block Party

A very fun block party that ends with an older man.

Gay Male 10/01/2018

Straight Jock's College Boyfriend

I gain a gay fuck toy at college.

Gay Male 09/30/2018

Winning the Blonde Goddess Ch. 03

Scott is forced into having gay sex.

Gay Male 09/01/2018

Where Do I Start?

A gay male story.

Gay Male 08/30/2018

A Run in the Park

A run in the park between two men turns into something else.

Gay Male 08/20/2018

Bathing Suit Dilemma

Two straight guys get surprisingly horny in the Jacuzzi.

Gay Male 07/31/2018

Caught in August Pt. 01

Eric's summer job is interrupted by the touch of an older man.

Gay Male 07/28/2018

Runt and Giant

A different type of werewolf story.

Gay Male 07/27/2018

A Day to Remember Ch. 01

Jayy is madly in love with the swim team captain, Aaron.

Gay Male 07/25/2018

My Trusted Friend Ch. 01

My best friend helps me live my secret fantasy.

Gay Male 07/23/2018

One Night in Helsinki

A visitor to Finland finds unexpected ecstasy in a sauna.

Gay Male 07/18/2018

Straight Boys Touch on Holiday

A card game between friends turns into a new experience.

First Time 07/04/2018

Her Boyfriend Subs In

Girlfriend uses her boyfriend for gay erotica shoot.

Gay Male 06/27/2018

First Cum Swallow

Swallowed my first load.

Gay Male 06/14/2018

Zara's Closet

Vacationing brothers find pleasure in sharing a bed.

Gay Male 06/12/2018

Learning Myself Through Jeff

Chance meeting opens man's eyes to new horizons.

Gay Male 06/11/2018

My Gay Ex-Roommate Pt. 01

Straight guy is pulled into his ex-roommate's activities.

Novels and Novellas 06/09/2018

College Bathroom

First time gay in a public college bathroom.

Gay Male 06/06/2018

The Moment When You Realize...Ch. 01

Straight guy forced to suck black cock on a street corner!

Gay Male 05/30/2018

That was Unexpected

First time gay anal sex.

Gay Male 05/29/2018

Growing Up Hung Pt. 02

Straight college guy's first time fucking his new cocksucker.

Gay Male 05/22/2018

Straight Best Friends Roll Together

The guys take Ecstasy and a wild night unfolds.

Gay Male 05/19/2018

Growing Up Hung

Young straight college jock needs his cock sucked...bad!

Gay Male 05/18/2018

Coming Out to Play

Man seeks a romantic alternative.

Gay Male 05/18/2018

Choices and Chances

Out of luck drifter gets lucky with a businessman hookup.

Gay Male 05/07/2018

Housesitting in the Suburbs

Two young friends house-sit together and become intimate.

Gay Male 05/03/2018

Late Night Walk at the Beach

A late walk becomes a lesson for a young man.

Gay Male 04/26/2018

The Poker Master

College buddy discovers porn stash, takes advantage.

Gay Male 04/25/2018

Caught Wearing Girlfriend's Panties

Friend catches him wearing his girlfriend's lingerie bottoms.

Gay Male 04/23/2018

My Wife's Hot Cousin Ch. 10

Two straight, married, muscle jocks spend a naked weekend...

Gay Male 04/17/2018

My Wife's Hot Cousin Ch. 09

Straight married men spend a couple of days naked in nature!

Gay Male 04/14/2018

I Popped a Cherry This Morning

A story of popping a recently divorced man's cherry!

Gay Male 04/10/2018

My Wife's Hot Cousin Ch. 08

Straight men flip/flop fucking!

Gay Male 04/09/2018

The First Time Pt. 02

Steve questions everything that happened last night.

Gay Male 04/08/2018

So, I Sucked My First Cock Today! Ch. 03

First time cocksucker gets fucked!

Gay Male 04/07/2018

My Wife's Hot Cousin Ch. 07

Straight Kyle can't believe what it feels like to get fucked.

Gay Male 04/05/2018

So, I Sucked My First Cock Today! Ch. 02

First time sucking cock goes farther...much farther!

Gay Male 04/04/2018

My Wife's Hot Cousin Ch. 06

Kyle gives Aaron his cherry...

Gay Male 04/03/2018

Straight Man Conquest!

Took a chance on a hot straight guy...

Gay Male 03/30/2018

Jake and Danny Ch. 02

The evening continues with hot sex between 2 best friends.

Gay Male 03/27/2018

David's Breakup

One friend tries to cheer the other up.

Gay Male 03/26/2018

The Invitation

Old friends finally get what they want.

Gay Male 03/14/2018

Pegging Peter Ch. 04

Another man joins the game.

Gay Male 03/14/2018

Craigslist Chronicles Ch. 01: Beginnings

Evan starts his craigslist adventures.

Gay Male 03/02/2018

A Curious Beginning

Years of bisexual fantasy becomes reality with a stranger.

Gay Male 02/28/2018

Pretty Perfect

Sean brings home a bad boy.

Gay Male 02/23/2018

Gay Awakening

My reflections on turning gay.

Gay Male 02/13/2018

Sports Massage from Friend's Dad Ch. 02

Braden's back at the Coleman household for 4th of July party.

Gay Male 02/10/2018

Her Idea

Sharing a dick brightens their future.

Gay Male 02/08/2018

A Fantasy Fulfilled

A couple experience what they had only fantasized.

Erotic Couplings 02/08/2018

Oh, Mr King! Pt. 04

A night of pleasure for Mr King and I.

Transgender & Crossdressers 02/02/2018

My First Time Becoming a Slut

My first time with a man.

Transgender & Crossdressers 01/31/2018

My Life as a Bisexual Man #01

First encounter. How I got starting on my bisexual voyage.

Gay Male 01/26/2018

Country Boys Valentine

A satire: Cupid+2 homophobes+4 queers, it’s gonna get interesting.

Gay Male 01/19/2018

Seduced by My Roommate

My roommate Rob gives me a new experience!

Gay Male 01/16/2018

My First Fight Club

A challenge from a rival leads to a first gay experience.

Gay Male 01/15/2018

Fear No Evil Ch. 01

Zach could be more than a friend, if Sid can accept himself.

Gay Male 01/13/2018

Unexpected Layover Pt. 02

Now it's Peter's turn to indulge.

Gay Male 01/12/2018

Bi-Curious 'Fantasy' Goes Awry

A straight guy replaces my fantasy with his own.

Gay Male 01/09/2018

The Downfall of Emily Ann Pt. 04

Emily and Officer Thompson meet again.

Group Sex 01/06/2018

Roger the IT Guy

Unexpected gay office bromance with the straight IT guy.

Gay Male 01/02/2018

Sports Massage from Friend's Dad

Friend's professional father helps with pulled muscles.

Gay Male 12/30/2017

Good Luck Starts Here

His girlfriend’s mother knows what he wants from a man.

Gay Male 12/24/2017

Special Procedure Ch. 02

The doctor gets an exam.

Gay Male 12/13/2017

A Reluctant Boy

Jason helps a shy friend come to terms with his feelings.

Gay Male 12/10/2017

Train Yards

A young man is opened up by two older men...

Gay Male 12/06/2017

Forced Bi

My girlfriend made me suck cock for the first time.

Gay Male 11/22/2017

Thankful For What?

Fun Thanksgiving first time gay male.

Gay Male 11/20/2017

DJ Pt. 05

DJ/Jamie get ready to start college Doug tries to adopt DJ.

Gay Male 10/30/2017

My Roommate Mark

Mark gets curious as we watch porn.

Gay Male 10/29/2017

Bro, What Are You Doing

David teases his bratty and annoyingly cute best friend...

Gay Male 10/28/2017

Slutty Sleepover

Two, straight best friends make some discoveries.

Gay Male 10/27/2017

His Love-Turned-Lover

Two 20yr old college friends have gay sex for the first time.

Gay Male 10/21/2017

Like a Good Neighbor

Little did they know they were helping each other.

Gay Male 10/11/2017

Special Procedure

He gets a special prostate exam.

Gay Male 10/06/2017

Salt's Quest for Charisma

Salt loses his anal virginity on Halloween.

Gay Male 10/02/2017

On The Clearing - A First Time

A young naked man receives a pleasant and unexpected gift...

Gay Male 10/01/2017

A New Experience Ch. 01

First time gay sex.

Gay Male 09/27/2017

Billy and David - Reunited

Chubby Billy reunites to find love with his best friend.

Gay Male 09/27/2017

Discovering Boys Ch. 02

Jake faces the fallout from kissing Matt.

Gay Male 09/17/2017

Discovering Boys Ch. 01

A kiss makes me realise that guys can be hot too.

Gay Male 09/14/2017

My Fake ID Ch. 02

Voyage of Self Discovery - At long last. (The Fox with Mike)

Gay Male 09/13/2017

Attitude Adjustment

Research into a writing topic gives a writer new viewpoints.

Gay Male 09/12/2017

My First Penis

College hitchhiker undergoes initiation by older gent.

Gay Male 09/11/2017

Field of Blooms: The Beginning Ch. 03

Eric and Austin's summer comes to a happy end.

Gay Male 09/09/2017

Losing My Virginity

A young Chubby Chaser finally makes a connection.

Gay Male 09/09/2017

My Sexy Roommate Ch. 05 - Dorm Heat

Roommates get sexy.

Gay Male 09/04/2017

The Forest Ch. 04

When your eyes can't see the way, your heart will show you.

Gay Male 09/02/2017

Indulging a Senior Counselor

Jr Counselor gets schooled on what it takes to get ahead.

Gay Male 08/25/2017

The Forest Ch. 03

The forest can help you relax, but beware the hidden danger.

Gay Male 08/25/2017

It's Rain on Men

Wanton, Wet and Wild.

Gay Male 08/15/2017

My Straight Roommate

Joe's roommate Russ is a walking wet dream, and he knows it.

Gay Male 08/12/2017

You Deserve This Orgasm Pt. 01-02

Liberated to explore touch and desire, I rediscover penis.

Gay Male 08/08/2017

Rail Trail

He had no idea he was such a whore.

Gay Male 08/08/2017

Tumblr Friends Meet Ch. 01

Married men make long distance hookup.

Gay Male 08/07/2017

My Sexy Roommate Ch. 01 - Steam

Sexy shower surprise.

Gay Male 08/06/2017
Active tags
gay first time
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ
Related Tags