‘gay first time’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
gay first time 

Category

Thankful For What?

Fun Thanksgiving first time gay male.

4.37
30.2k
6
2
10
0

DJ Pt. 05

DJ/Jamie get ready to start college Doug tries to adopt DJ.

H
4.58
6k
3
1
3

My Roommate Mark

Mark gets curious as we watch porn.

4.4
99.4k
65
13
100

Slutty Sleepover

Two, straight best friends make some discoveries.

H
4.6
861.2k
1.2k
84
1.6k

Like a Good Neighbor

Little did they know they were helping each other.

4.47
54.4k
28
6
41
0

Special Procedure

He gets a special prostate exam.

H
4.5
103.9k
54
13
81

Salt's Quest for Charisma

Salt loses his anal virginity on Halloween.

0
28.5k
10
7
19
0

On The Clearing - A First Time

A young naked man receives a pleasant and unexpected gift...

4.01
30.4k
3
4
3
0

A New Experience Ch. 01

First time gay sex.

4.3
79.8k
16
14
28

Billy and David - Reunited

Chubby Billy reunites to find love with his best friend.

4.42
18k
19
3
29
0

Discovering Boys Ch. 02

Jake faces the fallout from kissing Matt.

H
4.71
28.5k
35
16
41

Discovering Boys Ch. 01

A kiss makes me realise that guys can be hot too.

4.47
40.6k
35
10
56

My Fake ID Ch. 02

Voyage of Self Discovery - At long last. (The Fox with Mike)

H
4.84
9.8k
4
3
7

Attitude Adjustment

Research into a writing topic gives a writer new viewpoints.

4.07
8.2k
1
0
1
0

My First Penis

College hitchhiker undergoes initiation by older gent.

4.48
85.6k
33
16
58
0

Field of Blooms: The Beginning Ch. 03

Eric and Austin's summer comes to a happy end.

H
4.84
10.4k
3
7
5
0

Losing My Virginity

A young Chubby Chaser finally makes a connection.

4.43
34.9k
23
4
31
0

The Forest Ch. 04

When your eyes can't see the way, your heart will show you.

H
4.64
9.6k
11
4
12

Indulging a Senior Counselor

Jr Counselor gets schooled on what it takes to get ahead.

4.2
31.6k
14
3
17
0

The Forest Ch. 03

The forest can help you relax, but beware the hidden danger.

4.48
13.8k
8
2
10

It's Rain on Men

Wanton, Wet and Wild.

H
4.53
24.9k
18
9
22
0

My Straight Roommate

Joe's roommate Russ is a walking wet dream, and he knows it.

H
4.6
178.4k
192
20
277

You Deserve This Orgasm Pt. 01-02

Liberated to explore touch and desire, I rediscover penis.

4.3
15.7k
12
8
16
0

Rail Trail

He had no idea he was such a whore.

4.46
49k
54
8
73
0

Tumblr Friends Meet Ch. 01

Married men make long distance hookup.

H
4.51
31k
15
5
22
0

My Sexy Roommate Ch. 01 - Steam

Sexy shower surprise.

3.94
52.1k
18
3
34
0

Field of Blooms: The Beginning

Eric and Austin's summer begins with a rocky start.

H
4.65
20k
22
6
45

What Choice Did I Have?

A young man's journey in becoming a real man's boy.

4.39
108.8k
55
2
80
0

Northern Country Boy Finds Himself

A young college man figures out who he is and what he wants.

4
17k
10
3
12
0

First Time with a Guy: A True Story

Young dude tops a jock for the first time.

4.37
70k
25
12
37
0

Chase N' Justice

A Low Country love story...

H
4.61
18.3k
21
9
33
0

Drunk at College

A drunk college student stumbles into a whole new world.

H
4.64
116.9k
134
29
164
0

Can I Really Do This?

I let my desire to suck a cock result in action.

H
4.51
93k
61
23
78
0

His Girl Wont... I Take Her Place Ch. 02

Part 2 of 2. My first time getting fucked by another guy.

H
4.52
60.4k
35
8
43

Best Friends Finally Fuck

After 28 years of friendship, Stephen and I finally fucked.

3.95
64.4k
20
6
30
0

First Bi-Guy Experience Ch. 02

The experience continues.

H
4.51
37.6k
19
5
21

Cock Sucker App

Straight guy discovers a sex app that changes his life.

H
4.69
236.1k
473
132
636
0

An Eventful Weekend

Brent has a series of racy encounters with a stranger.

4.28
22.5k
8
6
14
0

After the Party

Teasing a friend has surprising results.

4.42
50.5k
26
2
37
0

Caught

Caught crossdressing and blackmailed into submission.

4.39
72.5k
53
6
68
0

Unexpected Swimming Lesson

My mistress wanted me to publish me most recurring fantasy.

4.02
16.5k
2
1
4
0

We Love It When You're Intoxicated

Watching their boyfriends being naughty can be fun.

4.42
59.4k
47
8
59
0

Hitchhiking Hookup

My first gay experience.

H
4.5
73k
42
7
51
0

I Lost it at Fire Island

Rusty submits to a new experience while helping his brother.

4.41
23.7k
11
0
16
0

Bi-Trick Ch. 01: Hammering Her Husband

She wants to see him with another man.

4.46
129.8k
105
13
135

Dom's Playtime

Dom, who we know little of, has a little fun.

4.43
10.5k
5
3
6
0

Jono's Journey Home Ch. 02

An Arab orphan returns home.

H
4.71
13k
15
6
15

A Sissy's Journey Ch. 07

Rick and Jesse find love together.

H
4.69
19.2k
11
7
18

A Sissy's Journey Ch. 06

After dinner out, things heat up at Rick's house.

H
4.65
21.5k
11
2
13

A Sissy's Journey Ch. 05

Amanda and Briana get Jesse ready for a date with Rick.

H
4.64
20.2k
5
3
6

A Sissy's Journey Ch. 04

Jesse learns about makeup and models for Rick.

H
4.65
18k
8
2
10

Bi-College Ch. 01 - Boys without Girls

Boys play while their girlfriends are away.

H
4.62
113.9k
143
17
196
0

A Sissy's Journey Ch. 03

Jesse enjoys cross-dressing and Amanda's tops him.

H
4.67
33.4k
21
11
26

A Sissy's Journey Ch. 02

Jesse has a boyfriend, and Amanda offers support.

H
4.52
30.4k
17
8
21

Improper Advances Ch. 01

A boy finds himself drawn to his girlfriend's older brother.

4.49
51.8k
50
8
76

A Sissy's Journey Ch. 01

A young man's journey of self discovery.

H
4.52
55.8k
48
14
82

A Learning Experience

A guy thinks he is curious; finds out he is a whore.

H
4.58
86.2k
80
17
111

First Experience with Another Man

Seduced by my tennis partner.

4.47
88.8k
37
9
58
0

Bartender's Help

A platonic friendship changes to be more.

4.47
25.4k
25
4
38
0

Coming Out Strong

Bad break-up to first gay hook-up.

H
4.59
52.1k
23
12
36
0

A Hidden Life - First Time

This is a story of my first time sucking a man.

H
4.5
90k
26
16
36
0

A Pleasure Trip

A night on a shroom trip ends in the unexpected.

4.49
21.6k
22
1
26
0

The Neighbor

An older man meets a former neighbour boy after many years.

4.4
101.6k
38
32
57

Hungover and Horny

First time with a man when hungover and horny.

H
4.5
58.3k
34
10
47
0

Misdelivered Package

Redelivering a package leads to a new package delivery.

H
4.65
49.6k
57
9
71
0

Used in the Night Ch. 01

My straight housemate is horny and gets me to help him out.

4.32
56.2k
45
1
61

My Chance Encounter Ch. 01

A story detailing my first chance encounter.

4.44
31.5k
18
7
23

New Territory

A young man's first experience with his fellow gender.

4.33
63.7k
5
7
14
0

Mac and Me Ch. 02

Joe returns the favor and more.

H
4.57
31.7k
17
3
17

Giving My Ass to a Wealthy Stranger

Straight young man dolls himself up and services cock.

H
4.72
111.3k
165
18
194
0

The Power of a Man

Meredith guides you along your first homosexual experience.

4.03
117.6k
25
11
35
0

02 - Rebirth

An experience in self-discovery.

3.96
13.6k
1
3
1
0

Nirvana Ch. 06

Noel and Owen get together after a hard day's night.

H
4.76
11.1k
7
4
7

How I Lost My Anal Virginity

My first time losing my anal virginity to a 9 in cock.

H
4.52
138.5k
52
17
69
0

Mirror Image

I explore my other self.

4.41
18.2k
9
8
11
0

Wagner Park Ch. 01

His first gay sex in a public park.

H
4.52
68k
39
16
46

Van Trouble

My best friend and I try a little hot motel room fun.

4.14
51.5k
20
2
24
0

My 30th Birthday

Crossing to the other side with a party guest.

4.25
67.4k
12
9
20
0

First Time with an Older Man

First and second experience with an older man.

4.16
125.3k
18
13
25
0

My First Time

An ad in the newspaper for accomodation brings a new lover.

4.43
38.1k
14
5
15
0

Myth of Masculinity

Straight young married guy begins a journey of realization.

H
4.58
73.1k
44
7
59
0

Seth Takes Me Camping

Alone in a tent, a close friend takes him completely.

H
4.64
239.5k
315
67
434
0

Prison School Ch. 18

Two huge cocks meet, Kurt watches Adam fuck Nate.

4.29
21.3k
3
0
5

A Hot White Mess Pt. 03

Alex's curiosity leads him to spy on a campsite.

4.24
32.1k
7
6
14

A Naturist Weekend Ch. 03

The group have fun in the sun.

H
4.65
24.5k
13
5
13

Summer of Black Cock

One man witnesses the fall of men & women to a BBC teen…

H
4.65
270.8k
417
59
560
0

Ski Trip With The Guys From Work

First in the Forced to Suck Cock series.

H
4.5
74.7k
59
9
89

Craigslist Hookup Ch. 01

A first time experience hooking up with a stranger.

4.44
85.2k
33
11
44

Your Turn

Newly-met couple exchange past erotic experiences.

H
4.82
263.4k
79
14
124
0

He Made Me

I'm forced to blow a burglar. It's my first blowjob ever.

4.32
149.1k
55
19
87
0

Learning my Love for Black Cock

Straight married man is turned by younger black colleague.

H
4.68
209.3k
182
44
240
0

The Forest Ch. 01

Straight guy moves to a new state. Learns new things.

3.81
35.2k
16
11
29

New to Cock

Straight guy goes to a bi massage parlor.

H
4.65
185.9k
135
22
157
0

Kyle Kissed First

Kyle finally makes a move on his Asian friend Kevin.

H
4.63
38.5k
44
17
55
0

My Experiments

I Decided to Act on my fantasies for Cocks.

4.39
52.7k
25
7
33

Eric

Gay White Water Rafting.

4.41
20.2k
15
4
15
0

The Hottest Sex of My Life (So Far)

The story of my first (and only) experience with another man.

H
4.66
89k
73
23
82
0
1...34567...16
Active tags
Active tags
gay first time
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ