‘gay first time’ stories

First Time I Sucked Off Another Guy

I get my first taste of sexual experimentation in college.

Gay Male 10/04/2018

I'm Bisexual

My first time with a guy.

Gay Male 10/02/2018

One Day at the Adult Bookstore

A new experience at an adult bookstore

Gay Male 10/01/2018

Block Party

A very fun block party that ends with an older man.

Gay Male 10/01/2018

Straight Jock's College Boyfriend

I gain a gay fuck toy at college.

Gay Male 09/30/2018
Active tags
gay first time
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ