‘gay first time’ stories

Bathing Suit Dilemma

Two straight guys get surprisingly horny in the Jacuzzi.

Gay Male 07/31/2018

Caught in August Pt. 01

Eric's summer job is interrupted by the touch of an older man.

Gay Male 07/28/2018

Runt and Giant

A different type of werewolf story.

Gay Male 07/27/2018

A Day to Remember Ch. 01

Jayy is madly in love with the swim team captain, Aaron.

Gay Male 07/25/2018

My Trusted Friend

My best friend helps me live my secret fantasy.

Gay Male 07/23/2018

One Night in Helsinki

A visitor to Finland finds unexpected ecstasy in a sauna.

Gay Male 07/18/2018
Active tags
gay first time
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ