Try the free LITEROTICA WEBCAMS!

‘gay first time’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
gay first time 

Category

Sort by:
ViewsRatingFavoriteNewest
7 Days30 DaysAll Time

With Corey and His Roommate

Talk with my buddy and his new roommate turns interesting.

by AtlantisGuy in Gay Male 04/08/2024
H
4.86
16.4k
50
12
73
0

Karl and Scott

My college buddy crashed with me, and feelings... awoke.

by AtlantisGuy in Gay Male 03/21/2024
H
4.8
20.5k
39
16
67

Our Love Life Transformed

My wife gets ruined, and I get turned.

by syn4321 in Fetish 04/10/2024
4.06
15.9k
25
1
50
0

The Paperboy Delivers Pt. 03

Paperboy has bi threesome with customers.

by LoveScribe62 in Gay Male 04/06/2024
H
4.86
13.1k
24
5
41

Karl and Scott (Ch. 02)

The next morning we awoke to a new world of sex.

by AtlantisGuy in Gay Male 03/24/2024
H
4.89
7k
23
3
31

Karl and Scott (Ch. 03)

The more we explored, the hungrier we were for each other.

by AtlantisGuy in Gay Male 03/29/2024
H
4.89
5.1k
18
5
24

The Horny Club Ch. 01

Join 18yr old Todd, Tom, and Jeb down on the farm.

by posingstrap1 in Gay Male 03/29/2024
4.39
7.8k
14
3
22
0

Karl and Scott (Ch. 04)

After a weekend of raw sex, we try to understand what's up.

by AtlantisGuy in Gay Male 04/02/2024
H
4.94
4.6k
14
12
20

Unexpected - A Quick Fantasy

Travelers fantasy is fulfilled in an unexpected way.

by LoveScribe62 in Gay Male 04/10/2024
H
4.6
6.3k
10
5
19
0

Posing Strap Trio Ch. 03

Hidden passions burst out between three muscular buddies.

by posingstrap1 in Gay Male 03/21/2024
H
4.78
2k
9
2
9

Roofer Calling

Does your roof leak? No, but this roofer fixed it anyway!

by LaTourEiffel in Gay Male 04/17/2024
NEWH
4.51
2.7k
9
0
12
0

Very Best Friends

Jon and Tony explore their budding friendship.

by posingstrap1 in Gay Male 04/19/2024
NEWH
4.84
2.2k
8
2
12
0

From Glory Hole to Hotel Room

Upgrading our experience

by Dazman in Gay Male 04/11/2024
H
4.7
5.4k
6
1
18
0

Posing Strap Trio Ch. 08

Hidden passions burst out between three muscular buddies.

by posingstrap1 in Gay Male 03/26/2024
H
5
2.4k
5
2
6
0

Posing Strap Trio Ch. 04

Hidden passions burst out between three muscular buddies.

by posingstrap1 in Gay Male 03/22/2024
H
4.67
1.7k
5
1
5
0

Posing Strap Trio Ch. 06

Hidden passions burst out between three muscular buddies.

by posingstrap1 in Gay Male 03/24/2024
H
4.79
2.1k
4
2
4
0

Lust On The Beach

Straight male has firrst time gay experience on the beach.

by biglenny74 in Gay Male 04/04/2024
4.2
7k
4
2
14
0

Posing Strap Trio Ch. 09 - Final

Hidden passions burst out between three muscular buddies.

by posingstrap1 in Gay Male 03/27/2024
H
4.76
1.7k
3
3
4
0

MWM Bisexual Musings Ch. 04

Short exchange leads to forced anal.

by fitfidelityfifty64 in Gay Male 04/19/2024
NEW
4.4
576
1
0
2
Active tags
Active tags
gay first time
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ

Category filter