‘gay reluctance’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
gay reluctance 

Category

Plowed Pt. 01

Str8, blue-collar Brad meets ebony Jayden on a snowy night.

4.26
26.1k
40
5
76

Conquered

To seduce sexy straight CEO, twink decides to hire gunman.

H
4.74
23.6k
66
29
123
0

Jason's Journey Pt. 01

Helen introduces Jason to cum play and reveals her fantasy.

4.4
9.8k
11
0
28
0
H
4.64
119.4k
167
17
278
0

Bent

A story about two straight guys, who didn't see it coming...

H
4.66
112.7k
183
33
290

My Fantasies Ch. 08

There's no harm in writing a few kinky stories, is there?

H
4.53
12.4k
8
0
11

Good Neighbor John Ch. 02

A young man performs a variety of odd jobs for his neighbors.

4.49
27.7k
15
2
22

Special Inducements

I have been a bad man for a long time.

4.37
40.2k
18
5
25
0

James Ch. 05: A Boi is Born

James comes to terms with his new identity.

4.4
34.6k
23
5
29

Bizarre Days Ch. 01: A Ridiculous Love Story

John takes it all and loves it.

H
4.58
14.8k
10
2
14
0

Strange Days Ch. 02: Hospital Hot Bed

John is in the wrong place at the wrong time, again.

H
4.51
36.3k
21
5
30

A Thrust into Power

A guard is challenged in his notions of desire by a rebel.

4.34
21k
18
1
31

Debt Relief

Did I lose the bets on purpose? Hmmmm....

H
4.53
54.9k
49
4
82
0

Better Late Than Never

An older man finally gives in to his urges.

H
4.7
48.7k
42
21
55
0

College Fund Ch. 07

Sometimes you have to go thru hell to get to heaven.

H
4.53
12.8k
5
1
7

Turning Out My Neighbor Ch. 02

It may not be right, but it's for his own good.

4.49
56.3k
22
1
29

Nico Herst, You're the Worst! Ch. 02

Mr. Herst next culinary ambition emerges.

0
6.6k
2
0
4

Turning Out My Neighbor Ch. 01

A young man must make the decision of his life.

4.3
81.8k
39
5
56

Nico Herst, You're the Worst! Ch. 01

Upstanding Officer Slate visits the quaint Herst Home.

0
13.4k
5
1
8

College Fund Ch. 06

Life becomes a bit more complicated.

4.45
15.3k
8
3
11

Quid Pro Quo

A rich benefactor pays for the education of many boys.

H
4.51
48.6k
74
6
102
0

College Fund Ch. 05

In love with Andy AND my latest role-playing game.

H
4.6
13.5k
11
5
12

The Never Ending Desire

A college jock's search for satisfaction.

4.08
44.8k
31
0
54
0

Grass Is Sometimes Greener....

His adventure thru denial, awareness & acceptance.

4.11
26.1k
25
2
33
0

Nephlim World Saga: The Prime

The nigh-immortal shapeshifters begins with the first one.

3.92
6.4k
3
2
5

James Ch. 03: Surprise UPS Throat Fuck

James' stalker appears once more to show James his true slut.

H
4.57
82.5k
52
12
63

For the Love of My Brother

Some things aren't worth fighting for.

4.09
100.3k
62
63
103
0

Now or Never: Escape to Freedom Ch. 03

Worlds Collide: The boys' world is turned upside down.

H
4.53
37k
46
49
50

Boy Story

After dirty handjob, straight guy becomes gay hottub fantasy.

H
4.52
253.4k
345
32
449
0

Of Tongues and Muscles

A sexy muscular stud is stripped, licked, and sucked.

3.82
70.6k
20
1
27
0

Don't Call Me Fag

Two men lock up after a bit of sparring.

3.84
53.3k
19
1
27
0

Web Cam Show

Straight guy tricked into humiliating gay blowjob live show.

H
4.6
260.3k
332
29
429
0

Price of Passage

Away from human eyes, an intimate toll is exacted.

4.43
39.7k
24
5
32
0

Steam Room Daddy

A young straight guy is forced to obey him.

H
4.5
1.55M
1.6k
211
2k
0

Seducing a Friend

I seduce a straight friend of mine from college.

2.8
139.7k
12
10
15
0

Stevie

Dom man realizes his best friend is a sub.

3.73
114.5k
25
3
38
0

For The Girl

Girl uses boyfriend to negotiate for gym membership.

4.42
612k
1k
56
1.2k
0

Hardcore Holiday Ch. 04

Held captive Dan sees another, gentler, side to Franco.

4.44
20.2k
5
4
10

Pheonix

A story of abuse.

4.2
60.5k
24
1
30

Sucking Cock for Carla

He's blackmailed into sucking his first cock.

4.42
434.9k
182
53
223

A Gun to My Head

He "forced" me to suck him.

4.16
142.5k
71
1
85
0

Trapped at the Gym

When the big boys meet - don't get between them.

4.41
85.7k
32
1
44
0

Cowboy Wannabe Rides Again

Actually he gets ridden again.

4.35
59.6k
27
3
32
0

Saturday at the Cement Plant

What do you do when you find out you're the bitch?

4.39
139.3k
70
6
87
0

Tiffany: Reveal The Truth

She's determined to prove he loves cock.

4.03
73.8k
17
1
27

Accidental Slave

He gets used - but is it really an accident?

4.07
77k
30
2
43
0

Across the Threshold

Coaxing down the barriers.

4.38
77.3k
26
5
30
0

College Roommate Ch. 01

Straight male seduced by bisexual roommate.

4.31
302k
130
21
192

Surprised and Used Again

Gay male, reluctance, and hard sex.

4.32
171.2k
57
2
74

The Mistake

Man gets more than he asks for from an online hookup.

3.98
91k
26
4
34
0

Croquis Grotesque

Discovering a new pleasure.

4.22
31.4k
1
1
2
0

Illegal Drilling

Burglars aren't gentle, one man discovers.

4.17
115.7k
37
5
45
0

A Captured Barbarian

The mighty barbarian is captured and tied up, then taken.

4.1
117.2k
58
3
63
0

I Meet a Barbarian

He's overcome by a huge traveller on the road.

4.26
90.6k
34
3
41
0

Vacation at the Beach

Guy takes an island beach vacation.

H
4.51
174.5k
50
16
65
0

Killing Time

What can happen when browsing in a bookshop.

4.42
123.7k
24
8
31
0

The 5th Floor

Rough encounter begins in the elevator.

H
4.53
185.4k
128
12
160

Not Part of the Contract

A mercenary gets more than he signed for.

3.92
99.2k
32
3
38
0
Active tags
Active tags
gay reluctance
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ