‘gay reluctance’ stories

Active tags
gay anal (17)gay first time (12)gay romance (9)gay nonconsent (8)gay oral (8)gay submission (8)gay forced (7)gay blackmail (6)guilt and shame (5)gay ravishment (5)gay anal sex (5)bisexual male (5)gay oral sex (4)gay seduction (4)gay domination (4)college (4)gay blowjob (4)gay awakening (4)gay college (3)reluctance (3)blackmail (3)masturbation (3)domination (3)gay d/s (3)older man (3)jock (3)male-male sex (3)submissive boy (2)first time (2)gay shame (2)panty fetish (2)female domination (2)gay bdsm (2)forced (2)nonconsent (2)gay denial (2)gym (2)humiliation (2)gay interracial (2)hypercock (2)spanking (2)exhibitionism (2)gay (2)bdsm (2)alpha male (2)bondage (2)straight bottom (2)gay bondage (2)gay humiliation (2)gay novella (2)gay incest (2)muscle slut (2)muscular (2)analingous (2)male humiliation (2)incest (2)male masturbation (2)gay rough (2)gay masturbation (2)first time gay (2)straight (2)big cock (2)violation (1)dungeon (1)gay non-consent (1)muscle stud (1)gay bareback (1)reluctant incest (1)sparring (1)fighting (1)mutual masturbation (1)submissive boys (1)gay black (1)gay cock sucking (1)interracial sex (1)pissing (1)hottub (1)giant (1)hairy (1)unknown stranger (1)forced gay (1)gay submissive (1)shame (1)male submissive (1)foot fetish (1)gay foreplay (1)gay licking (1)gay group (1)anal sex (1)ball play (1)gay brothers (1)big muscles (1)wings (1)male domination (1)gay older man (1)barbarians (1)bisexual (1)freedom (1)jocks (1)judge (1)cop (1)black cock (1)panties (1)audience (1)interracial (1)e-mail (1)dominant men (1)gay drama (1)golden shower (1)job interview (1)blowjob (1)twink (1)gay male (1)dominance (1)nonconsensual gay (1)fantasy (1)leather (1)sci-fi (1)finger (1)crew (1)shifter (1)alien (1)mining (1)threesome (1)gay muscles (1)non-con incest (1)gay muscle (1)gay cocksucking (1)gay supernatural (1)man love (1)arab (1)first time anal (1)subs & doms (1)latex (1)gay cum eating (1)gay dildo (1)chained up (1)gay threesome (1)bookshop (1)gay forced bondage (1)sex games (1)gay punishment (1)gay anal toys (1)cowboy (1)gay voyeurism (1)blow jobs (1)dragon (1)swords (1)primeval (1)gay stranger (1)gay athlete (1)hitchhiker (1)gay male massage (1)rescued by a stranger (1)gay foot fetish (1)gay jock (1)lap sitting (1)sauna (1)gay exhibitionism (1)gay massage (1)gay alien (1)rough gay (1)handjob (1)workout (1)medieval (1)adult store (1)gay older-younger (1)gay age difference (1)ass fucking (1)gay jack off (1)anal (1)gay one-on-one (1)gay public nudity (1)dominant (1)gay slave (1)gay romance novella (1)gay australia (1)gay dominance/ bondage (1)gay cumshot (1)female dom (1)ups (1)bicurious male (1)gay bottom (1)home invasion (1)gay nonhuman (1)lost bet (1)muscle (1)fat man (1)football (1)gay captive (1)slapped (1)gay noncon (1)gay stud (1)muscle hunk (1)gay voyeur (1)cigarette (1)naked male (1)gay cyber (1)femdom (1)gay roommate (1)penetration (1)web camera (1)bareback (1)brisbane (1)big cocks (1)cell (1)chained (1)
gay reluctance

Bizarre Days Ch. 01: A Ridiculous Love Story

John takes it all and loves it.

Gay Male 11/16/2017

Hospital Hot Bed

John is in the wrong place at the wrong time, again.

Gay Male 11/09/2017

A Thrust into Power

A guard is challenged in his notions of desire by a rebel.

Gay Male 07/18/2017

Debt Relief

Did I lose the bets on purpose? Hmmmm....

Gay Male 03/28/2017

Better Late Than Never

An older man finally gives in to his urges.

Gay Male 01/26/2017

College Fund Ch. 07

Sometimes you have to go thru hell to get to heaven.

Gay Male 01/10/2017

Turning Out My Neighbor Ch. 02

It may not be right, but it's for his own good.

Gay Male 01/09/2017

Nico Herst, You're the Worst! Ch. 02

Mr. Herst next culinary ambition emerges.

Gay Male 01/05/2017

Turning Out My Neighbor Ch. 01

A young man must make the decision of his life.

Gay Male 12/29/2016

Nico Herst, You're the Worst! Ch. 01

Upstanding Officer Slate visits the quaint Herst Home.

Gay Male 12/27/2016

College Fund Ch. 06

Life becomes a bit more complicated.

Gay Male 11/27/2016

Quid Pro Quo

A rich benefactor pays for the education of many boys.

Gay Male 11/15/2016

College Fund Ch. 05

In love with Andy AND my latest role-playing game.

Gay Male 09/26/2016

The Never Ending Desire

A college jock's search for satisfaction.

Gay Male 08/06/2016

Grass Is Sometimes Greener....

His adventure thru denial, awareness & acceptance.

Gay Male 03/29/2016

Blake's Bitches Ch. 01

College crew guy submits to rich bully teammate.

Gay Male 03/20/2016

Nephlim World Saga: The Prime

The nigh-immortal shapeshifters begins with the first one.

Sci-Fi & Fantasy 01/29/2016

James Ch. 03: Surprise UPS Throat Fuck

James' stalker appears once more to show James his true slut.

Gay Male 10/27/2015

For the Love of My Brother

Some things aren't worth fighting for.

Incest/Taboo 04/02/2015

Now or Never: Escape to Freedom Ch. 03

Worlds Collide: The boys' world is turned upside down.

Gay Male 12/12/2014

Boy Story

After dirty handjob, straight guy becomes gay hottub fantasy.

Gay Male 11/21/2014

Of Tongues and Muscles

A sexy muscular stud is stripped, licked, and sucked.

Gay Male 07/17/2014

Don't Call Me Fag

Two men lock up after a bit of sparring.

Gay Male 02/01/2014

Web Cam Show

Straight guy tricked into humiliating gay blowjob live show.

Gay Male 05/12/2013

Price of Passage

Away from human eyes, an intimate toll is exacted.

Gay Male 08/28/2012

Taking Out the Competition: Theo

Who's the loser now?

Gay Male 06/11/2012

Steam Room Daddy

A young straight guy is forced to obey him.

Gay Male 10/23/2011

Seducing a Friend

I seduce a straight friend of mine from college.

Gay Male 10/15/2011

Stevie

Dom man realizes his best friend is a sub.

Gay Male 09/14/2011

For The Girl

Girl uses boyfriend to negotiate for gym membership.

Gay Male 04/28/2011

Hardcore Holiday Ch. 04

Held captive Dan sees another, gentler, side to Franco.

Gay Male 04/01/2011

Pheonix

A story of abuse.

Gay Male 01/05/2011

Sucking Cock for Carla

He's blackmailed into sucking his first cock.

Gay Male 06/18/2010

A Gun to My Head

He "forced" me to suck him.

Gay Male 11/12/2009

Trapped at the Gym

When the big boys meet - don't get between them.

Gay Male 05/22/2009

Cowboy Wannabe Rides Again

Actually he gets ridden again.

Gay Male 02/06/2009

Saturday at the Cement Plant

What do you do when you find out you're the bitch?

Gay Male 09/26/2008

Tiffany: Reveal The Truth

She's determined to prove he loves cock.

Fetish 07/18/2008

Accidental Slave

He gets used - but is it really an accident?

Gay Male 04/17/2008

Across the Threshold

Coaxing down the barriers.

Gay Male 03/12/2008

College Roommate Ch. 01

Straight male seduced by bisexual roommate.

Gay Male 02/17/2008

Surprised and Used Again

Gay male, reluctance, and hard sex.

Gay Male 12/19/2007

The Mistake

Man gets more than he asks for from an online hookup.

Gay Male 06/23/2007

Croquis Grotesque

Discovering a new pleasure.

Gay Male 05/12/2007

Illegal Drilling

Burglars aren't gentle, one man discovers.

Gay Male 03/10/2007

A Captured Barbarian

The mighty barbarian is captured and tied up, then taken.

Gay Male 10/17/2006

I Meet a Barbarian

He's overcome by a huge traveller on the road.

Gay Male 09/10/2006

Vacation at the Beach

Guy takes an island beach vacation.

Gay Male 09/06/2006

Killing Time

What can happen when browsing in a bookshop.

Gay Male 08/20/2006

The 5th Floor

Rough encounter begins in the elevator.

Gay Male 03/10/2006

Roommate From Hell

Football jock makes hot roomie his toy.

Gay Male 10/19/2005

Not Part of the Contract

A mercenary gets more than he signed for.

NonConsent/Reluctance 06/15/2005
Active tags
gay reluctance
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ
Related Tags