‘mistaken identity’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
mistaken identity 

Category

Friendly Loving Joint Indian Family

A family of I, my wife and my friend.

4.37
130.7k
82
41
110
0

Gavin Screws Up Ch. 03

Ellie goes to a sex club in an attempt to forget him.

3.86
22.2k
2
0
8

Soap On A Rope - The Aftermath

What happens in Vegas stays in Vegas. Or does it?

4.16
98.3k
32
53
50

The White Rose Crisis Ch. 01

So many girls...but who could it be?

H
4.59
123.6k
189
27
327

The TSA Office

Man strip searched and more in a case of mistaken identity.

H
4.57
47.7k
32
4
54
0

I Lost His Number

She found him, lost him, but he didn't get far.

H
4.81
123.5k
379
45
469
0

Park Gang Sorta Bang

A surprise in the park might be even more of a surprise.

3.62
62.9k
18
2
24
0

Mistaken Identity at the Beach

Where does a mistake end and cheating begin?

3.64
166.3k
75
32
115
0

Sharing Toys

Wife sends house guest into my bed.

4.3
100.1k
33
10
70
0

Oh Santa!

The girls' Christmas party.

4.42
66.9k
34
33
47
0

Blindfold Trick

A son takes advantage of his mother blindfolded on her bed.

4.2
544.8k
311
28
497
0

The Phantom

Katie enjoys fucking a masked stranger at a Halloween party.

3.88
101.5k
28
0
62
0

The Bra Salesman

A man is mistaken for a lingerie salesman by a busty woman.

H
4.63
317.4k
504
28
616

Halloween Swap

Mr. Marcus sends Zeke as substitute to party in costume.

4.31
76.3k
24
0
50
0

Shell Game

You can't win a shell game, even when played with costumes.

H
4.54
51.9k
16
13
45
0

Masquerade Marriage

Masquerade party at the swing club: will the wife go?

2.89
65.4k
14
10
31
0

Masquerade Madness 02

Lisa discovers why her daddy wouldn't let her go.

4.05
66.1k
25
3
42

Bachelor Party Paranoia

A warning to a certain Literotica Author.

4.1
68.6k
24
80
44
0

A Gift Amongst Friends Ch. 03

Mandy begins to lose control as situations escalate.

H
4.67
83.3k
34
12
48

Ryan and Hayley

Ryan's friends trick him into fucking his younger sister.

3.94
342.8k
157
27
261
0

Teacher Is Mistaken

Hollie is mistaken for a student.

4.35
436.8k
349
16
553

Field Trip Follies Ch. 09

A sexy high school teacher is caught in a web of sin.

H
4.78
75.9k
33
5
46

Masks

Daughter pretends to be mom at a costume party.

H
4.57
572.2k
746
64
1k
0

One Debauched Weekend Ch. 01

Ally wakes up after a date to unexpected fun.

4.4
73.6k
57
3
87

Brandy's College Education Ch. 04

She gets schooled by her boyfriend's father.

4.27
137k
82
7
113

The Cock Clock Ch. 04

Charlie corrects Mrs. Hendricks' first time.

H
4.55
32k
20
0
32

A Wonderful Birthday

I got a great present and more.

4.3
197.8k
79
16
136
0

Lucky

A case of mistaken identity.

4.04
32.3k
4
5
14
0

On The Auction Block

Son unwittingly purchases his mother in an auction.

H
4.64
628.6k
755
63
1k

Halloween Tale

A mistaken identity at a Halloween party leads to more.

H
4.59
700.2k
566
74
828
0

What Mom Doesn't Know Will Fuck Her

Son masquerades in Dad's costume to fuck unsuspecting Mother.

H
4.67
1.79M
2.2k
99
2.9k

Who Woulda Known?

Trick and treat again and again.

4.13
48.5k
10
5
16
0

The BIG Bad Wolf

"Scare" was in the air..

4.24
23.8k
1
3
8
0

Sara-dipity

A desperate woman and a case of mistaken identity.

4.47
29.2k
13
6
22
0

Samantha's Revenge Ch. 01

Samantha gets back at the man who killed her mom.

3.7
42.2k
5
12
19
0

Blackmailing Laney

Sex. Blackmail. More blackmail. More sex. Happy ending.

4.29
160.1k
40
2
83
0

Dad's Looking for Love

Jilted hubby seeks companionship on the net.

4.49
129.5k
84
22
131
0

Son Secretly Takes His Mother

Mom's friend helps college son fuck her.

4.4
400.7k
213
14
326
0

Cupid's Gifts

Brother and sister, but didn't know it.

H
4.64
260.2k
143
32
275
0

Blindfolded

Coed tries light bondage with her boyfriend.

4.04
28.4k
9
3
21
0

Sally, Summer of Sex Ch. 06

An invitation to a swingers party turns into sex with her parents.

4.37
104.7k
16
3
34

Drunk Sister

Horny drunk girl mistakes her brother for her boyfriend.

4.29
828.9k
470
28
682
0

If Not for the Time

An apology letter for a husband's incestuous mistake.

4.04
34.9k
4
7
5
0

Kim Webcams with Daddy

Kim learns the man she is webcamming with is daddy.

H
4.52
151.9k
116
24
184
0

Surprise Treat This Halloween

Costume change makes for my treat at Halloween party.

4.31
331.3k
173
7
286
0

Don't Fear The Reaper

A case of mistaken identity goes terribly right.

4.45
224.6k
121
48
209
0

Cyberslut

Sean fulfills his younger sister's cyberslut fantasies.

H
4.58
359.1k
256
20
420

Beach Woops

Intentional exposure again has unexpected consequences.

4.27
96k
23
2
47
0

Another Girl

Which friend has the cheating wife?

4.42
264.9k
107
144
172
0

We Thought It Was Kenny

Costume party gets out of control.

4.05
106.4k
25
9
43
0

The Country Affair

A Regency romance of mistaken identity.

H
4.79
113k
201
35
253
0

Baroque Buggery

Costume party makes man question his sexuality.

4.15
90.8k
24
6
38
0

Anonymous Lover Ch. 02

Continuing story of lust and deceit.

H
4.52
115.4k
61
21
82

Anonymous Lover Ch. 01

Young man falls for an anonymous lover, but who is she?

H
4.61
161.3k
156
32
274

The Pet is Chosen

Mistaken identity leads to trouble for a Cat Person.

4.45
22k
4
0
10

Mistaken Identity

Maybe blondes really do have more fun.

4.23
57.7k
15
2
30
0

Accidental Incest

John accidently has sex with his own flesh and blood.

4.07
665k
216
21
379
0

The Girl From the Club

I pick up a girl and discover to my delight she's a shemale.

H
4.62
156.2k
92
9
114
0

Accidents Happen!

A brother and sister make a discovery.

H
4.58
10.51M
8.2k
452
9.6k
0

Blackout

A soldier is accosted by a prostitute in wartime London.

4.41
66.9k
37
6
66
0

My Ultimate Fantasies Ch. 03

She makes a startling discovery.

4.28
13.1k
3
0
7

Sleeping Sitter

Velvet didn't expect me home early.

4.3
136.7k
25
6
52
0

Mom's Bed

A simple case of mistaken identity starts it all.

H
4.61
1.06M
855
37
1.1k

Wrong Room!

Shy wife makes orgy-sized mistake

3.98
386.3k
145
19
229
0

The Supermarket Ch. 01

Mistaken Identity (Be careful what you grab in Produce).

H
4.6
108k
35
4
78

Allison's Online Tryst

Father-in-law doesn't know it's her.

4.24
60.4k
20
18
46
0

Do You Want a Lift?

Mistaken identity leads to an unexpected coupling.

4.35
37.8k
8
1
22
0

Ryan's Wife

Ryan escapes his wife at a nightclub and discovers something.

3.77
219.4k
29
26
54
0

Blind Date Ch. 02

A blind date gone wrong has got worse. But every cloud...

H
4.56
23.9k
5
5
9

The New Boss

Amishi, the new boss, finds herself in a drunken orgy.

4.43
140.5k
85
14
129
0

Gentlemen's Club Ch. 09

The Magic Show : how it all began.

4.16
30.4k
14
2
15

Fish Bowl Blunder Becomes Bliss

A case of mistaken identity.

4.32
29k
4
0
11
0

Blind Date Ch. 01

Blind date with the wrong man.

H
4.54
38.5k
23
5
44

Nerd's Reward Ch. 05

Larry can't get Jessica out of his head and pushes his luck.

4.44
84.5k
40
0
48

Tessa

Young sexy wife seduces wrong man.

4.24
144.7k
43
3
72
0

Mistaken Identity

Massage goes too far, and a woman must be satisfied.

4.22
85.6k
19
1
49
0

Just One of the Guys

She disguises herself as a guy - and finds true love.

H
4.57
89.2k
112
18
133
0

Red Fishnet Bodysuit Ch. 02

Her husband makes her think there is another man.

4.38
53.4k
27
6
39

Dr. Reynolds?

Julia has doubts about her doctor.

3.67
308.2k
20
7
40
0

Friend's Son Stayed With Us

Surprising events when a friend's son stayed at our house.

4.25
338.9k
95
28
155
0

Allie T - Valentine Virgin Violated

Teen loses her virginity to the wrong guy.

4.14
238.3k
87
55
138
0

Changing the Oil

Maureen makes a mistake in the garage.

H
4.5
57.4k
16
5
30
0

The Arrangement

A BBW overides her self pity by riding a man

4.48
28.5k
11
7
14
0

Rodin in the Bushes

A date in the sculpture gardens has an unexpected result.

4.41
19.4k
6
4
13
0

Vladimir Scott Bryan

True love, a ghostly curse, deception, & a plot for revenge.

3.75
10.1k
1
0
5

Masquerade Ch. 03

Still in disguise, Eleanor pushes Kevin past his limits.

4
23.9k
2
0
4

Masquerade Ch. 02

Behind a mask, Eleanor tricks Kevin into bed.

4.38
26k
2
0
7

Our Secret Diaries Ch. 02

Lucy and her best friend play a trick on her Dad.

4.33
100.9k
17
3
40

The Halloween Party

There couldn't be a mix up with the costumes - could there?

4.36
64.2k
18
1
47
0

Changing Sisters

The beautiful sister goes and her sister appears frumpy

H
4.51
47.9k
22
7
39
0

Masquerade Ch. 01

Behind a mask, Eleanor tricks & seduces her coworkers.

4.09
41.8k
16
0
33

Dirty Black Summer Ch. 03

The scheme climaxes as Trina meets Summer's husband.

4.4
37.1k
000

Dirty Black Summer Ch. 02

Sexy Trina is brought into the plan.

H
4.51
44.4k
4
0
8

The Only Difference is the 'S'.

He picks up a strange girl, but she isn't what he thought.

H
4.62
105.6k
46
5
68
0
Active tags
Active tags
mistaken identity
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ