‘mistaken identity’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
mistaken identity 

Category

Accidents Happen!

A brother and sister make a discovery.

H
4.58
10.51M
8.2k
452
9.6k
0

What Mom Doesn't Know Will Fuck Her

Son masquerades in Dad's costume to fuck unsuspecting Mother.

H
4.67
1.79M
2.1k
99
2.8k

Truth or Dare

Mother and Son play truth or dare in front of her friends.

H
4.69
1.08M
2k
0
3k
0

Tricking Twin Sister

Brother in costume fucks all 3 of his bitch sister's holes.

H
4.56
927.3k
1.3k
61
1.8k
0

Wrong Room

Drunken mom makes a huge mistake.

H
4.53
1.82M
947
49
1.3k

Spring Break Surprise

A son walks in on his mother wearing only an apron.

4.45
566.5k
895
0
1.2k
0

Mom's Bed

A simple case of mistaken identity starts it all.

H
4.61
1.06M
854
37
1.1k

On The Auction Block

Son unwittingly purchases his mother in an auction.

H
4.64
628.5k
755
63
1k

Masks

Daughter pretends to be mom at a costume party.

H
4.57
572.1k
746
64
1k
0

Masquerade Party

Mother and son unknowingly meet at a party.

4.32
475.4k
611
26
897
0

Halloween Tale

A mistaken identity at a Halloween party leads to more.

H
4.59
700.1k
566
74
828
0

My Sister and her Cheerleader Friends Ch. 01

Darren's sister and her friends stay the week.

H
4.55
327.6k
539
0
868

The Bra Salesman

A man is mistaken for a lingerie salesman by a busty woman.

H
4.63
317.3k
504
28
616

Sharing a Bed with Little Sister

Accident happens when two siblings share a hotel room.

4.32
611.6k
503
33
826
0

Table for Two

A straight girl accidentally has sex with her own sister.

H
4.67
324.4k
498
42
731

Drunk Sister

Horny drunk girl mistakes her brother for her boyfriend.

4.29
828.8k
470
28
682
0

Light's Out Party

The party's pitch black, and it could be anyone...

H
4.62
281.7k
433
30
649
0

The Wrong Tent

He went to my tent by mistake, and I didn't stop him.

H
4.61
222.6k
402
45
723
0

Bella's Halloween Treat

Bella and her daddy have a Halloween party accident.

4.29
391k
401
42
572
0

Daddy in the Dark

In the dark of night a young woman's dream comes true.

H
4.59
174.9k
396
38
604

The Mask, The Trick and The Treat

Costume change results in mistaken identity.

4.49
528k
394
0
589
0

More than a Substitute

A single dad meets an extra-friendly preschool teacher.

H
4.81
122.6k
384
67
498
0

I Lost His Number

She found him, lost him, but he didn't get far.

H
4.81
123.5k
379
45
468
0

Accidental Encounter

Brother and sister accidentally meet in a dark room.

4.42
897.8k
378
28
506
0

Teacher Is Mistaken

Hollie is mistaken for a student.

4.35
436.8k
348
16
552

The Amnesia of Beth's Father Ch. 01

Beth's father doesn't remember who his wife is.

4.45
266.4k
334
6
457

Accidental

Man has accidental sex with his stepdaughter.

4.04
792.7k
329
0
488
0

The Upside

Helping my drunk neighbor back to her bed has its benefits.

4.34
232.9k
318
31
589
0

Blindfold Trick

A son takes advantage of his mother blindfolded on her bed.

4.2
544.7k
311
28
497
0

How I banged My Lesbian Sister

Mark finds his lesbian sister nude and blindfolded.

4.36
262.3k
301
36
482
0

Mom Thought I Was Dad

I couldn’t resist such a wonderful temptation.

H
4.51
199.4k
282
24
438
0

Happiest Halloween

My costumed partner wasn't who she seemed...

4.45
191.1k
258
15
396
0

Cyberslut

Sean fulfills his younger sister's cyberslut fantasies.

H
4.58
359.1k
256
20
420

The Princess and the Villain

Felix attempts to stop his sister from making a mistake.

H
4.57
138.9k
248
26
406
0

Accidental Slut, A Halloween Party

Mistaken for brother's slutty wife.

4.23
197.9k
244
65
452
0

A Case Of Mistaken Identity

Man accidentally rapes his girlfriends twin sister

4.12
494.2k
233
45
337
0

Switched Up Costumes

A Halloween party costume change becomes interesting.

H
4.67
259.2k
228
13
355
0

Surprise!

She meant to surprise her husband.

4.36
452.4k
218
24
336
0

Accidental Incest

John accidently has sex with his own flesh and blood.

4.07
665k
216
21
379
0

Gloryhole Porn Trick

Evil woman creates an incest situation

4.27
351.2k
215
11
340
0

My Sister and her Cheerleader Friends Ch. 05

Discovery & his sister... finally!

H
4.73
130.8k
215
27
268

Accidental Cuckolding of Dad

Mother & father unknowingly arrange a date with their son.

4.43
231.2k
213
22
317
0

Camping with My Girlfriend and Family

Sometimes animal instincts takeover - even when it's mom.

4.25
282.4k
213
18
338
0

Son Secretly Takes His Mother

Mom's friend helps college son fuck her.

4.4
400.7k
213
14
326
0

Halloween Surprise 2019

A mom mistakes her son for a stanger and puts on a sex show.

H
4.6
149.2k
208
11
347
0

The Country Affair

A Regency romance of mistaken identity.

H
4.79
113k
201
35
253
0

Mistaken Identity

He takes advantage of Natalie's case of mistaken identity.

4.45
258.6k
197
0
266
0

He Didn't Hear What I Said

Miscommunication leads to mistaken fucking.

3.98
200.9k
192
71
266
0

The White Rose Crisis Ch. 01

So many girls...but who could it be?

H
4.59
123.6k
189
27
326

I Don't Need a Father

Hannah meets her father for the first time.

H
4.56
65.9k
179
30
296
0

Parenthood

How does one recover?

H
4.67
66.5k
177
222
308
0

One Night, in a Motel

Father, Daughter bonding on a roadtrip.

4.35
119.5k
175
28
308
0

Surprise Treat This Halloween

Costume change makes for my treat at Halloween party.

4.31
331.2k
173
7
286
0

B. A. B. - Big Ass Bitch

Mistaken identity leads to rough & tumble lust.

4.4
510.9k
173
10
251

Having Fun With My Aunt and Mom

Accidentaly fucking my aunt, and my mom thinks I am dad.

4.42
136.8k
172
17
322
0

Mistaken Identity

A randy dad slips it in the wrong hole.

4.3
391.7k
172
12
266
0

The Halloween Masquerade Ball

Twin siblings join their parents' party.

H
4.5
324.5k
171
7
302
0

Wrong Seat

She sucks guy she mistakes as her husband at crowded airport.

4.45
198.1k
161
10
215
0

Santa's Naughty Aunt

Woman with Santa fetish fulfills fantasy, & her nephew's too!

H
4.53
409.3k
160
11
224
0

Daddy's Cock Forever!

Father of the bride makes daughter his slut.

4
191.2k
157
11
280

Ryan and Hayley

Ryan's friends trick him into fucking his younger sister.

3.94
342.8k
157
27
261
0

Anonymous Lover Ch. 01

Young man falls for an anonymous lover, but who is she?

H
4.61
161.3k
156
32
274

Pranking the Distance

Gina pranks fiancé, but can't stop what she set in motion.

H
4.74
98k
155
20
276
0

A Shave and a Haircut

A few changes and would his wife know him?

4.26
321.9k
153
0
210
0

Daddy's Cock Forever Ch. 01-04

Mistaken identity shows daughter that Daddy's cock is best.

4.1
113.2k
152
5
316

Mistaken Identity

Mom should stay sober!

4.31
442k
151
16
245
0

To Serve and Protect

Mistaken identity, a cop, a victim.

H
4.76
125k
149
31
179
0

College Party & Mistaken Identity

Bro/sis accidental hookup.

H
4.66
65.3k
149
28
309
0

Wrong Room

My roommate's girlfriend gives me a blowjob by mistake.

4.49
121.8k
147
11
230
0

Wrong Room!

Shy wife makes orgy-sized mistake

3.98
386.3k
145
19
229
0

A Simple Case of Opportunity

18-year-olds exploit possibility of mistaken identity.

4.3
189.8k
145
0
199
0

Cupid's Gifts

Brother and sister, but didn't know it.

H
4.64
260.2k
142
32
274
0

Russell's Sinful Christmas

Mom and Aunt must act to save him.

4.45
196.6k
142
20
204
0

Dear Prudence

Another dangerous wager on fidelity.

H
4.57
314.2k
140
144
244
0

She's Mine Now

Surprised by his little sister at work.

H
4.57
68.6k
137
13
279
0

My Best Friend's Drunk Wife

My best friend's wife gets drunk and crashes on my couch.

4.22
154.7k
135
38
254
0

The Amnesia of Beth's Father Ch. 02

Beth continues to play the role of her mother.

4.48
183.2k
133
14
169

A Mask of Intimacy

A playful costume switch has unpredictable consequences.

H
4.5
111k
128
15
216
0

Busty Indian Mother Submits to Son

At first he loved her, but now he just wants to fuck :)

4.23
176k
125
8
203

Hotel Mom Ch. 01

Your sexy mom at 75 is never too old to be fucked.

4.43
376.8k
125
8
182

Table for Two Ch. 02

Emily's and Stephanie's date escalates.

H
4.53
90.1k
124
31
154

Don't Fear The Reaper

A case of mistaken identity goes terribly right.

4.45
224.6k
121
48
209
0

Halloween Party with Mom

Found my mom at a swing club.

4.28
102.7k
121
9
242
0

A Daughter's Love

Confusion and mistaken identities lead to love.

4.48
209.2k
120
0
180
0

Kim Webcams with Daddy

Kim learns the man she is webcamming with is daddy.

H
4.52
151.9k
116
24
184
0

Drunken Love

Son in disguise tricks his alcoholic mother into having sex.

4.2
88.8k
114
4
217
0

My Greatest Fantasy

The gang was supposed to do it to his wife.

4.41
128.9k
112
14
137
0

Just One of the Guys

She disguises herself as a guy - and finds true love.

H
4.57
89.2k
112
18
133
0

Finding her Father

Young girl meets her father for the first time.

H
4.56
61.3k
111
8
177

My Sister Sharon

A case of mistaken identity, then brother pushes his luck.

4.3
304.2k
109
9
171
0

Split Second Thoughts

Things go wrong when twin sisters switch places.

H
4.76
54.2k
109
36
242
0

The Mommy Masquerade

Jason received a mysterious invitation to a masquerade ball.

H
4.63
52.5k
109
22
235
0

Battered & Bruised

A woman is attacked while walking home from a night out.

H
4.59
63.8k
108
10
181
0

Masked Ball

Brother's plan to get back at sis succeeds big-time.

4.28
363.7k
108
12
184
0

Another Girl

Which friend has the cheating wife?

4.42
264.8k
107
144
172
0

Craving Daddy's Cock

Daughter is desperate to seduce her dad, whatever it takes!

4.49
93.6k
107
14
205
0

Chad and Jen...and Joy

Sister moves in temporarily.

H
4.6
107.4k
107
10
184
0

Was She or Wasn't She...My Daughter?

Our daughter was in an accident and I found out...

4.05
97.6k
105
143
165
0
Active tags
Active tags
mistaken identity
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ