‘mystery girl’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
mystery girl 

Category

The Trainer Pt. 01

Expat Amy welcomes a challenging new girl into her life.

H
4.73
43.8k
109
30
194

Tied and Abandoned Ch. 02

He finds out who sucked him, and it's not what he expected!

4.44
20.9k
10
1
16

Tied and Abandoned

She ties him up, then disappears...

4.44
30.3k
14
5
30

In This Midnight Hour

Tyler gets an unannounced visitor this Halloween.

4.21
19.7k
2
2
10
0

Darkroom - Wednesday

College girls plan to appreciate nice guys in the dark.

H
4.77
82.3k
34
13
52
0

Darkroom - Monday

College girls plan to appreciate nice guys in the dark.

H
4.74
112.7k
91
30
121
0

Seducing a Friend

John seduces his friend as Belinda.

4.11
101.9k
14
1
17
0

Mystery Girl Ch. 02

He figures out who she is.

H
4.52
25.8k
1
0
1

Mine Ch. 05

The truth is revealed.

4.35
59.1k
18
7
19

Analholics Anonymous

Some anonymous anal fun in a college dorm.

H
4.53
155.6k
76
10
95
0

Night Bus To Sudbury

He gets unexpected sex during boring ride.

H
4.61
74.4k
17
0
22
0

The Big Night Out Ch. 03

After some dancing they finally get back to her place.

H
4.64
20.6k
1
0
1

And Sister Makes Three

Mistress Chelle has a hell of a surprise for Lila.

3.89
66.5k
14
3
18
0
Active tags
Active tags
mystery girl
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ