‘mystery man’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
mystery man 

Category

Rachaels Birthday Stranger

Rachael is surprised as a mystery man joins their lovemaking.

3.88
8.7k
15
3
28
0

The Order Ch. 01-02

Cara likes it rough, but not with monsters.

H
4.54
3.1k
5
0
10
0

Cheerleader Tale Ch. 07: First Day's Study Surprises

Susan's 1st Day of Study, Shocks, Sex & Cindy.

H
4.57
6.4k
4
1
10

Electric Dreams

Andy uses technology to explore his sexuality.

H
4.72
9.2k
13
2
30
0

When Ordinary Isn't Ch. 03

Realization begins to dawn.

H
4.87
17.1k
24
10
35

When Ordinary Isn't Ch. 02

The improbable becomes probable.

H
4.87
19.2k
31
16
44

My Muse and Me

What happens in Tuscany stays in Tuscany.

4.49
9.6k
3
3
7
0

Thursday's Child

She accepted that love wasn't for her...and then he appeared.

4.26
14.1k
8
4
10
0

She Makes Up for Lost Time

A senior lady rediscovers her erotic self.

3.63
15.8k
6
5
6

The Girl Kneeling in the Foyer

A girl kneeling naked in the foyer, waiting for her Master.

4.16
18.1k
2
5
5

His Son's Teacher Ch. 05

Pt 2: A spring break full of surprises.

H
4.78
38.5k
32
14
37

Steamy in the Sauna

People at the sauna can get clean - or they can get dirty...

4.42
18.4k
5
2
8
0

Gail and Darian Ch. 01

Strangers meet, this is their story.

4.46
13.2k
7
4
9

Fantasy Stranger

Zeela has her dark fantasies filled by a mysterious stranger.

H
4.51
29.7k
35
2
51
0

A Teacher's Little Adventure

Teacher receives an invite from a secret admirer.

0
53.5k
6
3
7
0

Alone In the Country

A mystery man is catapulted into Kate's quiet haven.

4.4
14.4k
5
3
8
0

The Masquerade Ch. 02

The mystery man is unmasked.

H
4.62
12.7k
5
3
5

A Taste of Wildness

Cheating on the cheater at a concert.

4.25
14.2k
4
6
4
0

The Masquerade Ch. 01

She has a delightful discovery of a mystery man.

H
4.63
18.5k
16
5
19

Paper Cock

A cardboard erection preludes sex with a stranger.

4.22
40k
9
7
12
0

I Dare You

An e-mail leads to hot sex with a mystery man.

H
4.62
38.1k
14
9
19
0

Mage and The Bad Men

"He has a special tool to use on naughty women."

3.39
22.4k
4
0
6
0

The Shortcut

College co-ed virgin is taken.

3.86
60.2k
12
1
22
0

How I Cuckold Myself

It all started as role playing.

4.09
115.1k
34
22
59
0

Chloe in the Boy's Room

One night of hot, drunken, bathroom sex.

4.28
39.3k
8
1
11
0

My Mystery Man

A dream that wasn't a dream.

3.88
7.9k
0
2
00

The Train Ride

Stranger? Maybe, but he rocks her world.

H
4.66
49.5k
11
4
22
0

Mystery Man Ch. 01

Trapped in suburbia, lusting after sis.

3.89
31.3k
3
0
3

Wanted

Joan Severance gets off big with mystery man.

3.64
23.5k
1
0
2
0

Mystery Pie Ch. 03

Who is the source?

4.05
111.7k
8
23
8

Mystery Lover

Husband gets her to try something with mystery man.

H
4.55
279k
70
8
103

Friday Night w/ Cassie & Deb

Another hot threesome with a lucky new stranger.

H
4.54
47.8k
4
2
9
0

Payback

A bitter girlfriend gets revenge on her cheating mate.

4.13
41.6k
1
0
2
0

Executive Decisions: Going Up?

Spontaneous pleasure ride in a mirrored elevator.

4.33
55.2k
3
1
5

A Lesson in Flirtation

Business by day. Flirt by night.

4.42
114.4k
6
2
9
0

Green Eyed Stranger

Who is this mystery man that knows her so well?

H
4.55
57.6k
26
11
33
0

My First Taste of a Woman

Husband's surprises just keep getting better.

4.39
293.6k
16
11
19
0

The Soul of a Good Wife

Her Internet fantasy to a mystery man.

4.07
10.8k
3
0
6
0

Silence is Golden Ch. 3

Karen finds out about her mystery man.

4.2
27.8k
2
0
2

A Storm's Eye

Dee experiences a 'special' porn shop.

4.29
62.6k
5
1
6
0

Absolutely Sexy

The wildest dream she ever had never goes away.

3.97
23.1k
2
0
2
0

Mystery Man Takes Young Girl

18-year-old girl is romanced by an unknown man.

4.13
76.6k
8
0
13
0

Shannon Elizabeth: Leaving...

Shannon Elizabeth finds passion on a plane ride.

4.28
73.2k
7
0
10
0

Finding Myself at USF Ch. 1

Coed finds the man of her dreams, who is more than she imagined.

3.85
27k
1
0
1

Watched

Voyeur gives her a real thrill.

4.4
85.7k
9
1
18
0

Katie's Awakening Ch. 1

Conservative housewife is taken as her husband watches.

4.34
403.2k
161
0
198

Cock on a Rock

She finds mystery man imprisoned in stone.

4.15
25k
8
0
10
0

Megan & the Mystery Man

Hubby has a surprise for Megan.

3.95
43.7k
9
0
10
0

Stalked Ch. 3

Mystery man enters her life again.

H
4.59
25.5k
2
1
3
Active tags
Active tags
mystery man
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ