‘painful anal’ stories

Florida Whore: Daisy Pays Rent

Daisy's gets a buttery surprise from her landlord.

Anal 11/24/2015

Hard On the Trail Ch. 09

Daddy teaches me a lesson for having a sleep over.

Gay Male 08/16/2015

Hard On the Trail Ch. 07

I make my bitch mine in his home.

Gay Male 03/14/2014

Guess What I Saw? Ch. 05

Monica, Kelly, and Tony finish what they started.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 10/23/2013

Kiki, the Town Slut Ch. 10

An initially unpleasant anal experience.

Anal 02/04/2011

Anally Submissive Gilly Ch. 01

College virgin finds BBW coed anally submissive.

Anal 03/20/2006
Active tags
painful anal
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ