‘peanut butter’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
peanut butter 

Category

Guilty Pleasures Ch. 06

A man's gotta do what a man's gotta do.

H
4.82
21.5k
12
17
22

BabySitter's Penalty

When you stuff up there is always a penalty.

4.16
76.5k
20
2
24

Touch of Mocha

Playful roleplay between a couple.

H
4.51
40k
37
9
50
0

Getting to Know Her Ch. 03

Fun with peanut butter and more.

4.26
20.8k
2
1
5

More Than Just a Fairy Tale Ch. 09

Luc and Meg go camping after a sticky ordeal.

H
4.63
32.8k
15
4
17

12 Days of Christmas

A task, a jar of peanut butter and a diary.

4.44
20.2k
6
2
8
0

Peanut Butter & Jelly Ch. 03

She was ready for him when he got home.

4.38
29.1k
4
0
9

The Peanut Butter Game

They found a way to cut the tension.

4.46
73.9k
12
3
15
0

Passion of the Priest Ch. 02

Fall from grace leads to enlightenment.

3.92
26.3k
00
1

Cricket Call

Lodger is drawn to much older landlady.

H
4.56
240.3k
30
8
34
0

Russian Invasion

Horde of Russian girls take over Gene's apartment.

4.22
94.7k
9
0
11
0

It All Adds Up Now!

Hindu coed unwraps her hairy secret.

4.29
91.5k
12
1
15
0

Out For A Walk

Woods hike leads to encounter with hunky Aussie.

4.09
28.4k
1
0
1
0

A Bacon & Peanut Butter Sandwich

About the mourning--I mean, morning after.

E
4.2
44.1k
7
0
8
0

I Pushed My Pud Up Her Poop-Chute

& other words/phrases to avoid in stories.

E
4.32
240.5k
30
58
35
0

Blindman's Bluff

The use of food for erotic response.

4.25
13.6k
1
0
1
0

FuckMart

In the future, department stores will offer it all.

2.93
96.5k
3
0
3
0

Peanut Butter

The sticky stuff can be fun in more ways than one.

3.61
58.9k
2
0
4
0
Active tags
Active tags
peanut butter
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ