Try the free LITEROTICA WEBCAMS!

‘reluctant gay’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
reluctant gay 

Category

Sort by:
ViewsRatingFavoriteNewest
All Time

Matt Needs a Place to Stay... Ch. 04

Tuesday afternoon, Matt is coming home from school...

by MingusLee in Transgender & Crossdressers 02/18/2023
H
4.8
11.7k
19
2
28

Plowed Pt. 01

Str8, blue-collar Brad meets ebony Jayden on a snowy night.

by bigturnout in Gay Male 02/09/2023
4.27
26.5k
42
5
79

Jason's Journey Pt. 01

Helen introduces Jason to cum play and reveals her fantasy.

by sensualstoryteller4 in NonConsent/Reluctance 04/30/2021
4.39
9.8k
11
0
28
0

Confessions Pt. 04: Ramond

Dad has his own confessions too.

by manly_bitch08 in Incest/Taboo 06/30/2020
4.09
6.7k
7
0
9

Sarah and Stevie

Two estranged friends relive their experimental past.

by tentoestoofar in Lesbian Sex 01/21/2020
4.33
17.9k
9
0
17
0

Natural Remedies are Best

Straight doctor breaks protocol to help adventurous patient.

by markindy in Gay Male 01/31/2016
H
4.56
61.8k
88
7
122
0

QJ Productions

Judy uses her fiancé's ass to negotiate porno deals.

by azburglar in Gay Male 07/28/2015
H
4.6
117.1k
260
30
359
0

Bending the Straight and Narrow Ch. 02

Two men continue to play after college and marriage.

by markindy in Gay Male 06/21/2015
4.45
41.2k
54
4
75

Losers Give Head

Chris loses a bet and pays up.

by Sean Renaud in Gay Male 02/01/2014
4.22
95.7k
66
9
91
0

Sexy Swimsuit

Straight guy with girl's ass gives dirty lapdance at the pool.

by azburglar in Gay Male 06/28/2013
H
4.58
1.04M
1.6k
180
2k
0

Discretion Has Its Rewards

He joins a couple to satisfy wife's unusual desires.

by markindy in Loving Wives 09/07/2011
H
4.57
157.7k
100
22
144
0

I Hate Queers

A man who is driven by his hatred of gay sex.

by Cyanlot in Gay Male 05/28/2011
4.27
91.6k
49
20
65
0

Short-Term in Chicago

Straight guy is seduced by gay neighbor.

by markindy in Gay Male 03/03/2011
H
4.64
206.7k
156
29
211

Boredom Can Be Dangerous Ch. 02

Young husband has sex with Father-in-Law.

by markindy in Gay Male 10/10/2010
H
4.5
124.6k
94
6
113

Boredom Can Be Dangerous Ch. 01

Man encounters Son-in-Law at adult bookstore.

by markindy in Gay Male 10/09/2010
4.47
120.5k
92
6
131

Dylan's Desires Ch. 02

A stripper uses blackmail to turn a man gay.

by stevem619 in Gay Male 06/04/2010
4.35
107.7k
42
14
53

Domestic Affairs

Two married men find mutual interests.

by markindy in Gay Male 12/21/2009
H
4.6
99.3k
50
10
65

March Madness Ch. 03

First creampie helps man accept fate as blackmailed slave.

by watchdwag in Gay Male 07/30/2009
H
4.52
193k
69
8
81
Active tags
Active tags
reluctant gay
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ