‘shy girl’ stories

Active tags
first time (6)female virgin (6)college (5)threesome (5)masturbation (4)virgin (4)bwwm (4)texas (3)tease (3)bbw (3)lesbian (3)blowjob (3)romance (3)hairy pussy (3)older man (3)cowboy (3)coed (2)romance drama (2)small breasts (2)innocent (2)redhead (2)black woman (2)costume party (2)oral (2)large breasts (2)sex with a stranger (2)cunnilingus (2)family (2)blonde girl (2)reluctance (2)vibrator (2)romantic (2)party (2)bdsm (2)bondage (2)exhibitionist (2)drama (2)blonde (2)cheating (2)young woman (2)her first time (2)anal (2)rough sex (2)jock (2)sexy (2)office romance (2)new york (2)first blowjob (2)scissoring (1)forced to watch (1)uncircumcised cock (1)mutual masturbation (1)one night stand (1)fashion photographer (1)18-year-old (1)lesbian romance (1)chubby girl (1)younger girl (1)film (1)demon (1)halloween (1)pakistan (1)sex (1)orgasm denial (1)australia (1)fingering outside (1)restraint (1)asian (1)first time lesbian (1)wallflower (1)scared (1)bad girl (1)edge sofa (1)mdom (1)student and professor (1)machine (1)nerdy girl (1)metamorphosis (1)library (1)older woman (1)beautiful girl (1)kidnap (1)two girls (1)long hair (1)shower (1)lesbian pick-up (1)back cushion (1)interracial (1)voyeur (1)first love (1)humiliation (1)inexperienced (1)vibe (1)nipples hard (1)online chatting (1)sucking dick (1)female masturbation (1)drew legs (1)girl being forced to suck cock (1)professor (1)new york city (1)stranger (1)seduce (1)shaved (1)girl sucking cock (1)dark theater (1)sex slave (1)outdoor set (1)sticky fingers (1)club (1)ace droid (1)shy (1)white blouse (1)mff (1)shaven cunt (1)dominate (1)magic (1)girls kissing (1)husband john (1)submissive (1)toys (1)eyes staring (1)dancing (1)passion (1)black girl (1)love (1)orgasms (1)sex lips (1)erotic couplings (1)trib (1)black hair and busty (1)force (1)therapist (1)hairy girl (1)naked younger sister (1)strangers (1)feel sexy (1)old man/young woman (1)male dominant (1)nude teenager (1)lesbian love (1)naked time (1)athlete (1)games (1)talking (1)healing (1)new starts (1)princess (1)petite lesbian (1)young girl (1)brunette girl (1)girl with glasses (1)getting a blow job (1)cupid (1)wet dream (1)g-spot (1)frequency (1)hotel room (1)suspense (1)cheating husband (1)model (1)bereavement (1)fear (1)girl on girl (1)drunkenness (1)teasing (1)muscular (1)voyerism (1)dirty talk (1)petite (1)enormous nipples (1)flat chest (1)explicit photos (1)muscular man (1)public masturbation (1)rain (1)fashion model (1)virgin coed (1)dirty slut (1)sexy boss (1)tickiling (1)young love (1)girlfriend's sister (1)school (1)handjob (1)busty teen (1)young man (1)porn star (1)18th birthday (1)middle eastern man (1)scared girl (1)stage (1)first kiss (1)bikini (1)librarian (1)finding love (1)makeover (1)bullying (1)father/daughter (1)literature (1)hairy woman (1)younger woman (1)mythological beings (1)university (1)shy guy (1)neighbor (1)multiple orgasms (1)creampie (1)gentle seduction (1)workers (1)vulnerable (1)doggy style (1)masterbation (1)valentines day (1)couple (1)accidental creampie (1)secret fantasies (1)redheads (1)flat chested girl (1)self insert (1)mystery (1)semi-public (1)porn ssite (1)femdom (1)xxx cinema (1)interrical (1)foursome (1)transformation (1)bareback (1)first (1)intrusive man (1)bare cunt (1)big cock (1)
shy girl

Walking Lessons

Shy girl has to learn to catwalk and I'm willing to help...

Anal 06/24/2017

Beyond Plain Jane

Someone new in the office brings Jane out of her shell.

BDSM 06/12/2016

The Plaything Ch. 02

She faces the aftermath and embarks on a new adventure.

Group Sex 04/04/2016

Never Been Far Before

She is an innocent virgin, he is an experienced bad boy.

First Time 03/16/2016

Chocolate Girl

A confectionery Pygmalion of sorts.

Sci-Fi & Fantasy 02/03/2016

Party Time

Quiet girl and designated driver.

Erotic Couplings 01/14/2016

The Guest Speaker

A shy college girl takes a risk with a professor.

Romance 11/21/2015

As Time Goes By Ch. 03

Fran helps Dusty overcome her problems.

Lesbian Sex 11/08/2015

As Time Goes By Ch. 02

Fran must adjust to a new life.

Lesbian Sex 11/07/2015

I Will Never Be Loved Ch. 05

A BBW girl finding herself for the first time.

Interracial Love 09/11/2015

I Will Never Be Loved Ch. 04

A BBW girl finding herself for the first time.

Interracial Love 09/09/2015

I Will Never Be Loved Ch. 03

A BBW girl finding herself for the first time.

Interracial Love 09/04/2015

I Will Never Be Loved

A BBW girl finding herself for the first time!

Interracial Love 08/19/2015

Behind Bookcases

Books are a wonderful way to take someone away.

Toys & Masturbation 06/04/2015

Redwood Manor: Autumn Pt. 02

Faced with no good option, Clayton crosses a fine line.

Erotic Couplings 10/31/2014

Tall Drink of Water

Skinny teen gets a job working for her Uncle Don.

Incest/Taboo 10/24/2014

First Sex Video

A couple makes a sex vid. Detailed with camera angles

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 09/14/2014

Ella's First Ch. 02

Ella finally loses her virginity.

First Time 07/18/2014

Reverie Ch. 02

Educate me.

Interracial Love 05/03/2014

Reverie Ch. 01

Save me.

Interracial Love 02/22/2014

Poor Paige

My boyfriend and I force Poor Paige to watch.

NonConsent/Reluctance 01/24/2014

Figure 8 Ch. 06

Emma trusts Sylar.

Romance 12/30/2013

Close Neighbors Ch. 02

Together again with Lisa and Becky.

Group Sex 11/03/2013

The Door Shut Behind Me

Seven minutes in heaven with her best friends crush.

NonConsent/Reluctance 06/12/2013

A Conspiracy of Sluts Ch. 01

Our heroine makes a sexy new friend. And vice-versa.

Lesbian Sex 01/01/2013

Lunch Break Fun

Hungry boss with a rack, or innocent work girl with a heart?

First Time 05/17/2012

Forgetting Her Mistake Ch. 02

I share my vibrator with her.

Lesbian Sex 04/08/2012

Your Grandfather Might Stop By

Her mother's words sent chills down Christie's spine.

Incest/Taboo 02/12/2012

Oh, Library Boy!

Bookshelf seduction and a sexual encounter.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 07/18/2011

Join in the Dance

A night of passion banishes the demons of her past.

Romance 11/01/2010

First Time...Even For Barbara

There's a first time for everything, especially for winning.

First Time 10/05/2010

JuneBugg Ch. 02

Shy girl is teased by jock.

Interracial Love 09/26/2010


Shy girl is teased by jock.

Interracial Love 09/09/2010

The Bush Girl Ch. 01

Shy virgin is taken advantage of in the Outback.

NonConsent/Reluctance 01/06/2010

Not Shy Anymore

Jenny gets a massage and some confidence.

Group Sex 12/30/2009

Neighbor Girl

How I seduced my neighbor.

First Time 12/26/2009

M and H Ch. 02

Mari and Henry's first meeting.

Erotic Couplings 10/22/2009

Natly Burning Fire

Shy and timid Natly gets a makeover.

Lesbian Sex 08/02/2009

Love and Papyrus

A female graduate student gets a curse and a date.

Sci-Fi & Fantasy 06/14/2009


Stranger stalks Alli and visits her in the night.

NonConsent/Reluctance 05/16/2009

The Very Long Tease

Timid girl finds extraordinarily patient man.

First Time 04/11/2009

Another Walk In the Woods

He recuperates and wants more.

Mature 10/30/2008


She's anti-social, but one kiss may just change that.

Interracial Love 10/15/2008


Lone husband offers neighbor girl dessert; gets virginity.

Erotic Couplings 08/15/2008

Fornicating Felicia

A housewife teaches a shy girl about lesbian sex.

Lesbian Sex 03/09/2008

Grandpa: After Molly Ch. 01

His forbidden desire continues.

Incest/Taboo 12/06/2007


Girls find love.

Lesbian Sex 09/03/2007


First voyeur and exhibitionist experience.

Incest/Taboo 01/08/2007

Coffeehouse Comfort

She finally gets the girl of her dreams.

Lesbian Sex 11/07/2006

What the Hell Happened to Heather?

Heather's homecoming isn't as planned for Carl.

Group Sex 10/08/2006


A bookworm is transformed.

First Time 09/12/2006

Memoirs of a Sex Slave Ch. 01

The kidnap - even librarians have dreams!

Humor & Satire 07/27/2006

Blackhawk Hall Ch. 04

Ari is reunited with a recent beau in the Wayfarer's Rest.

Sci-Fi & Fantasy 05/13/2006

Perfect Moments

Shy girl's boyfriend gives her the ultimate present.

Group Sex 01/22/2006

Anna Ch. 01

Anna travels to Montreal to live out her fantasies.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 01/08/2006

Saving Geri

In her loss, she finds so much more.

Romance 01/07/2006

A Lover for Maddie

Beautiful girl shy girl goes after someone she wants.

Romance 11/07/2005

Plain Jane

Encounter with a jogger in a rainstorm.

Erotic Couplings 06/19/2005

Mary at the Royal Court Ch. 01

Going to the big city.

NonConsent/Reluctance 06/07/2005

The Unexpected Affair

Unexpected encounter with a shy but sexy girl.

Erotic Couplings 05/18/2005

Dead Heat: Death For Breakfast Ch. 03

Brodie begins his seduction.

NonHuman 07/28/2004

Mind Frequency Ch. 03

Erin unleashes her wild side.

Mind Control 09/23/2003

Nudism, Shaving, & Me

Shy girl discovers public nudity.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 05/10/2003

Ready or Not (Here I Come) Ch. 3

The bedroom was her cage.

NonConsent/Reluctance 07/01/2002

Ready or Not (Here I Come) Ch. 2

Innocence is no excuse.

NonConsent/Reluctance 06/25/2002
Active tags
shy girl
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ
Related Tags