‘shy’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
shy 

Category

The Liquids Rule Ch. 01

TSA agents force naive girl into stripping completely naked.

4.03
89.9k
44
6
64

Irrevocable Ch. 00: Introduction

A modern day retelling of Alice in wonderland meets BDSM.

3.59
25.9k
5
0
6
0

Sex Club: New Lady to Swapping

A newbie beauty to swinging is my target. An erotic game.

4.42
43.7k
35
3
46

My First Public Masturbation

I'm so nervous but so aroused...won't you listen...?

4.42
89.9k
37
4
57
0

The Blind Date Ch. 01

A homely girl on a blind date makes a big comeback.

H
4.51
61.2k
52
7
90

My Shy Teen Slave Ch. 08

Juliet is played with...on camera.

4.26
48.9k
16
4
20

My First Girlfriend

A shy college kid tells the story of getting his girlfriend.

4.05
39.7k
17
5
20
0

Princess's Story

A King and Queen decide to take a girl under their wing...

4.45
22.9k
22
2
42
0

My Shy Teen Slave Ch. 07

Juliet faces her shyness at a cocktail party.

H
4.53
46.3k
24
4
28

Slow and Painful Ch. 01

Long term, hard-core, non-consensual enslavement.

3.75
210.2k
70
11
128

It Started With a Snog

Virgin James encounters a bad Penny.

4.38
28.2k
19
4
25

My Shy Teen Slave Ch. 06

Have you ever been spanked?

H
4.57
58.9k
21
4
24

My Shy Teen Slave Ch. 01

Clark has always had a thing for the shy girls.

4.18
152.1k
145
7
224

Hi, I'm Sam

A dream comes true for a shy Scottish man.

4.44
22.8k
18
14
26
0

The Devil in Her Pt. 02

The dark prince begins the seduction of his angel.

4.33
8k
2
2
7

The Taming of Mr. Parson

Can it work between a 34 year old man and an 18 year old girl?

H
4.73
63.7k
50
6
88
0

Right Down the Hall Pt. 01

James and Rosy get blackmailed by Anja.

3.28
24.8k
6
3
12
0

Carolyn - My First

18 year old shy guy and shy older lady.

H
4.51
64.3k
21
3
25
0

Shy Girl

Man meets a shy girl at a house party.

4.42
99.1k
48
3
65
0

Shy Wife - Tricked Into Beach Exposure

Shy Wife - tricked into beach exposure.

3.94
134.2k
37
16
72
0

Kat's Cruise Ch. 04

Kat and Daisy get to know one another.

H
4.51
24.7k
6
0
10

Working Hard

A new employee conquers an inexperienced intern.

0
43.3k
10
7
13
0

Picture Perfect

Who was taking these photographs?

3.72
52.4k
40
0
69
0

His Little World

His booty call, her whole world.

4.12
13.7k
3
1
5
0

A Little Attention Goes a Long Way

A shy chubby girl gives in to a stranger's advances.

3.82
63.7k
35
30
47
0

Room Mates Pt. 03

Jake gets blindfolded and Sammie gets her first taste.

H
4.77
43.7k
29
4
34

A Handyman's Memoir Ch. 34

A Southern Belle in a Southern Town.

H
4.72
47.4k
9
3
12

Lottie, the Shy, Chubby Bridesmaid

I gatecrash a wedding and connect with a bridesmaid. Or two.

H
4.53
76k
75
17
94
0

Blue Dress

One night from the perspective of both sides.

3.73
9.7k
5
2
6
0

Jess

Some things are worth waiting for.

H
4.74
103k
89
21
123
0

By Air Mail Ch.01

Nobody ever said that a lookout's life wasn't lonely.

4.4
19.9k
12
1
21

Bodypainting

Janette and a shy Sean paints a beautiful model, Sophie.

3.9
18.9k
6
1
8
0

Petra

Being so alone hurts.

4.46
11.8k
3
14
4

A Bronx Boy Fills His Dream Girl

Rags to riches Vincent "fills" his dream girl.

4.44
89.2k
59
12
79
0

Windy and Warm

A busker meets a homeless woman.

H
4.64
48k
56
14
79
0

Field Trips with Daddy: The Library

I stumble upon an exhibitionist slut for us to share...

4.21
42.4k
11
4
20
0

Across The Hall

Nadia's neighbor takes advantage of her.

4.18
111.3k
35
10
48
0

Krista and Lia

Krista enters new territory with help from her friend Lia.

4.25
46.5k
15
2
22
0

The Girl Who Wasn't There Ch. 03

Ginny meets a cute and amazing girl from Scotland.

H
4.84
18.5k
32
9
36

Chris Plays Strip Poker Pt. 01

Stacie tells about Chris' Adventures in Strip Poker.

H
4.51
71.2k
38
2
56

The Naked Monster

A nevernude girlfriend makes his fantasy come true.

4.44
47.5k
17
0
30
0

Vicky Ch. 01

A shy girl sets out to stop reading and start living.

4.01
48.8k
26
7
38

Military Strength

Couple's fantasy is fulfilled while servicing the troops.

4.14
56.9k
21
0
32
0

Hard-Balling Soft-Ballers

Shy wife is talked into making a video.

4.44
90.7k
71
0
105
0

Beware the Quiet One

Two ugly ducklings are better than one!

H
4.69
82.2k
27
18
39
0

Emily and Hayden Ch. 04

A young submissive girl and a Dom.

4.47
24.7k
12
13
15

June

George comes to the rescue.

H
4.61
28.6k
28
15
38
0

Katie's Week of Repercussions Pt. 01

Katie goes to great lengths to keep her secret from Nick

4.48
153.4k
210
14
323

Life Changing Friends

A couple's routine life turned by one fun dinner party.

4.47
57.3k
17
10
22
0

Breaking Cathy

Making a bad college girl obedient.

3.76
54.8k
7
1
14
0

The Railway Trip

Wife swap on a night train for skiing in the far north.

3.81
36.4k
10
9
14
0

The O-Mobile

Looking for self-pleasure? Hop on in and go for a spin.

3.8
46.1k
11
3
21
0

Callie's Intimate Learning Pt. 01

Callie is a young girl who has never had a boyfriend.

3.96
18.8k
10
3
12

The Monotony of Lust Ch. 02

Two best friends continue on their sexual journey

3.72
16.2k
5
3
6

The Monotony of Lust Ch. 01

Two best friends flirt but hesitate to go further.

4.15
26.2k
10
1
20

Told You, You Wanted It

A big brother takes his teasy sister.

4.16
167.2k
123
21
166
0

Playing with Fire

A couple to be married but the intended wife has a relation

3.41
22.6k
9
13
15
0

The Works

A modest newlywed opens up on her last day of vacation.

4.3
108.1k
50
7
79
0

Trembling On the Edge of the Cliff

A woman is emotionally and physically entangled with a music teacher.

3.65
8.4k
0
3
4
0

The Naked Filmmaker Pt. 04

Sam is interviewed for a female magazine.

4.25
31.9k
10
3
15

Doing Eva Ch. 08

I take Eva for the weekend and she enjoys new meat.

H
4.56
26.5k
9
0
15

Unlocking Tally Ch. 01

A young nerdy woman comes out of her shell, thanks to a toy.

H
4.61
46.8k
39
2
63

Anniversary Gift

During the 30th wedding celebration night she get new view.

3.23
61.3k
16
23
26
0

The Devil May Care

A family heirloom provides the key to sexual liberation.

H
4.65
30.8k
25
3
32
0

Moonshadows Ch. 04

They take advantage of their new levels of intimacy.

H
4.68
24.7k
26
8
33

Amy and Ron Ch. 01

Story of a conservative girl, the beginning.

3.91
63.7k
43
21
64

Chance Encounter Changes Everything

Pete quickly overcomes his issues with being shy.

4.19
21.8k
9
2
11
0

First Time Chatlog

The chatlog between the inexperienced and the excited.

H
4.66
18.2k
6
3
9
0

Close Neighbors Ch. 03

More fun with Lisa and Becky.

H
4.59
30.8k
13
1
16

Off-screen

A chance encounter opens up old flood gates.

3.88
11.8k
1
0
5
0

Aurora Finds Her Mate

BBW Aurora has just met the perfect man...or something.

H
4.55
29.1k
59
13
68
0

The River

Crossing the lines of friendship, she takes what she wants.

4.26
25.4k
13
2
16
0

F3 Booty Hideaway

Coming home leads to revelations.

3.85
15.4k
1
10
2
0

Soccer-Mom: First Swap Party

She went just to watch but ended up well fucked.

4.44
465.6k
329
19
490

A Little Halloween Magic

Will Rose and Michael recognize love when they find it?

4.49
35.3k
23
8
32
0

Samantha's Awakening

Samantha discovers that she's an exhibitionist.

H
4.73
116k
121
17
165
0

Timid Wife

Husband compels timid wife to be fucked by a stranger.

4.06
127.9k
45
13
67
0

Haunting Exhibition

Casual intimacy isn't what it seems.

4.33
25.5k
6
7
9
0

New Muslim Escort's First Date

Life-changing exploration of sexual passion for both.

4.46
39.6k
17
2
32
0

Grammy's Boy Ch. 02

Grandmother helps young man expand his horizions.

H
4.6
127.6k
52
16
65

Stories about Satyrs

She has heard stories about satyrs. Today she makes her own.

4.39
16.6k
11
1
17
0

Wife, Shy to Hottie

Wife converted from being shy to bold and hot.

3.53
71.7k
12
8
23
0

Innocence in the Office Ch. 01

It's wrong to fuck the intern...isn't it?

3.93
77.9k
21
6
26
0

The Dare

Taylor's first day of sophomore year.

4.21
80.1k
50
28
76

Allie Rides Again

A beautifully adorned body deserves an appreciative man.

4.33
21.3k
8
4
16

Fresh Escort Does Bachelor Party

Incredible how shy teen becomes a slut.

4.43
159.8k
82
1
130
0

Dominated By Best Friend's Uncle

Succumbing to experienced older man.

4.46
163k
135
16
175
0

Touched for the First Time

A young woman masturbates until orgasming.

0
85.4k
21
7
29
0

Dark Chocolate: A Mature Story

Dark chocolate is the sweetest treat.

4.39
127.4k
72
15
87

It Is Always the Quiet One

Good girl becomes an exhibitionist while on vacation.

3.85
72.8k
12
3
27

Finding Comfort Ch. 01

Can two survivors find solace in each other's embrace?

H
4.55
24.7k
20
6
33
0

(big B1) Know The Person Inside

Two lonely insecure people get together.

4.42
22.1k
12
0
14
0

You're Mine and You Know It Ch. 02

Jennifer gets what she wants… or is it.

4.46
88.1k
48
15
56

The One for Me Ch. 01-03

Meeting the one that is for you.

H
4.66
24.7k
9
8
15

The Sixth Floor Ch. 02

A second rendezvous at the university library.

4.41
18.7k
7
1
10
1...56789...11
Active tags
Active tags
shy
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ