‘straight guy’ stories

Jamie finally has to confront his true feelings.

An encounter with star baseball player Anthony.

Sexy twink fulfills fantasies of two straight jock friends.

Straight guy can't seem to forget girlfriend's brother.

A dominant twink takes his straight jock even deeper.

Jay, Jamie and Ellie enjoy their break from school.

The school holidays end, and the Science Fair happens.

Hurricane gets closer; Jeremy gives Logan a pounding.

A young man meets a married silver-fox daddy.

Two hot straight jocks take their gay twink bff - again!

Jay tries to be Eric's friend, and Louis has regrets.

Twisted Tales: Jack submits deeper to dominant couple.

Martin allows Carl's Seduction to go further.

Kinky wife wants to see her husband suck on a cock.

Unexpected seduction during quarantine desperation.

Girlfriend uses her boyfriend for gay erotica shoot.

First MMF Threesome with their sexy neighbor Daddy.

The conversion completes.

Straight guy Lee feels sparks with straight guy George.

Chris stays over, slides in & takes me to POUND TOWN.

Spring break drugs lead to first time gay sex.

Twink's exam stress relieved by jocks.

Sexy jock Chase is back to exchange edging for rent.

18 Year Old HS Seniors hook up in the locker-room get caught.

Christian falls deeper to Daddy's dominance.

Steven starts having strange dreams whilst away with work.

Waking up at the Coleman house continues the adventure.

Lindsey reveals her secret. Nick has a strange dream.

The sexy neighbor girls have a surprise.

Carl and Martins relationship keeps heating up.

The guys take Ecstasy and a wild night unfolds.

Jessie needs a reminder about what happened last night...

Tyler gets in on the action, things definitely getting weird.

My domme ex girlfriend finishes what she started.

Seduced at my apartment gym.

Teacher gets seduced by student with wife's permission.

Christian joins a new gym and gets unwanted attention.

Two straight guys get surprisingly horny in the Jacuzzi.

Harvey finds out who MrGTop is!

Helping out the frat president with a costume emergency.

Harvey sucks his first ever cock!

Harvey continues make money online whilst exploring his arse.

A special edible awakens the slut inside my husband.

Tyler finally catches his hot straight roommate in the act.

Jaime has a drink with his scene partner and takes him home.

College date gives surprise rimjob.

Straight guy gets seduced into Anal...and loves it.

The guys perform the scene. "Brent" enjoys it way too much.

Braden's back at the Coleman household for 4th of July party.

Straight boys summer starts off unexpectedly.

Three best friends vacation in Sin City and sin becomes them.

The aftermath of Mark and James' night together...

John gets turned out by new, older neighbour.

Monica and Sarah continue their fun.

A neighborhood jog leads to first time magic.

The roommates continue their unexpected quarantine fun.

Martins new young employee takes a liking to him.

Why is Brad feeling THAT? Jayden just grins and grins...

I agree to be one of her test subjects.

Preston goes deeper with his new Daddy.

Chad's brother tries to ruin everything.

Boys get way too drunk on spring break couple's vacation.

Jason and Jacob assume their roles as the night continues.

He knew how to make me feel more comfortable.

Gay guy unexpectedly taken by two straight best friend jocks.

Friend's professional father helps with pulled muscles.

A married straight man lets his curiosity take over.

Straight guy is seduced by gay neighbor.

Dominant twink completes his conquest over a straight jock.

An older man conquers a straight guy.

Girlfriend's dad and boyfriend share the back seat.

Mark's housemate has her boyfriend over...

I take Daddy and Eric's morning wood instruction.

Helping his best friend takes an unexpected turn.

Fantasy Football Punishment Takes a Turn.

Two, straight best friends make some discoveries.

Guy working at home gets an eyeful.

A straight guy meets a charming older guy at a bus stop.

A straight couple fall for huge cock and big tits.

Rugby fan gets more than post-game autographs.

David has always had a crush on his best friend's father.

A guy finally meets the one who turns him out.

Two straight guys trapped in the snow do what they must.

Tyler's hot straight guy roommate has a massive secret.

A cure for small dick woes, may cause strange side effects.

When his date passes out on him, he finds Les is more.

University students find each other at last.

Two roommates begin a romantic entanglement.

Twisted Tales: Theo meets his new roommate.

Straight guy finds himself in an unusual situation.

Austin reveals what he had to do to join the fraternity.

Meeting Damon's Husband leads to new adventures.

Seduced by his sister's sexy, horny boyfriend.

Straight male has help while dreaming

Straight guy gets fucked for the first time.

Horny straight guys hook up hotel sex.

Noah returns home to his straight guy crush.

Derek and Chris. This was no dream.

Austin reveals some of his insecurities in a surprising way.

Video night shows him what he never suspected.