Try the free LITEROTICA WEBCAMS!

‘first time gay’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
first time gay 

Category

Sort by:
ViewsRatingFavoriteNewest
All Time

Gay for Candy

Afraid he's been turned gay, Ash must confess to his girl.

by BuckyDuckman in Novels and Novellas 06/01/2018
H
4.81
39.7k
100
22
162
0

Accidental Dick Pic from Dad Pt. 02

It’s now my turn to see what my dad tastes like.

by androgynousLavender in Gay Male 08/13/2022
H
4.74
65.1k
99
6
137

Boredom Can Be Dangerous Ch. 02

Young husband has sex with Father-in-Law.

by markindy in Gay Male 10/10/2010
H
4.5
125k
96
6
115

The List

Straight father gets a massage he will never forget.

by Illogical in Gay Male 01/12/2024
H
4.78
42.8k
93
22
158
0

John's First Time

His wife does the teaching. He does the sucking and more.

by seeape in Gay Male 09/14/2008
H
4.6
241.6k
93
23
113
0

New Gym Friend

Straight man is seduced after a workout.

by newbitime in Gay Male 09/25/2014
4.33
145.5k
93
14
124

Boredom Can Be Dangerous Ch. 01

Man encounters Son-in-Law at adult bookstore.

by markindy in Gay Male 10/09/2010
4.47
120.8k
93
6
134

Curious with the Gay Kid

18-year-old gets big surprise during first gay experience.

by taleteller in Gay Male 10/22/2005
4.31
254.7k
93
18
102

2 Cocksluts Share a Big Cock

I share Daddy's big cock with my new blowjob buddy.

by goldigga in Gay Male 04/03/2014
4.47
98.1k
92
5
105
0

Burning Honey Ch. 01

Aspen meets a golden man.

by elleem in Gay Male 08/03/2014
H
4.68
42.8k
91
20
116

Boys will Be Boys

A group of straight friends enjoy their boy bodies.

by tvdude17 in Gay Male 06/28/2022
H
4.68
45.8k
87
7
152
0

Picture Perfect

Picture of couple and gay friend unleashes bi lust.

by Jamie_in_dresses in Gay Male 02/26/2016
H
4.61
54.1k
86
17
113
0

Underneath

He noticed his annoying coworker secretly wears a thong!

by Edey in Gay Male 04/19/2022
H
4.77
38.8k
86
28
155

Gym Sauna Therapy Leads To More

First timer has unexpected encounter with older gym owner.

by superpumper in Gay Male 04/26/2017
H
4.56
83.6k
85
4
115
0

Sissy in Vegas

What happens in vegas turns a sissy out of a femboy.

by wolf_hunt in Gay Male 01/21/2023
H
4.71
37.7k
85
22
142
0

Well... He Did Say Please

He just went down to get a joint.

by pdiddyd55 in Gay Male 11/08/2018
H
4.63
57.7k
84
7
128

Voyeur No Longer

I saw him fuck a guy, invited him home for my wife to see us.

by ILikeIt in Gay Male 12/01/2023
H
4.85
31.4k
84
11
133
0

Obsessing Over You, Beautiful!

He has a girlfriend. But he lusts for his gay roommate.

by Edey in Gay Male 04/01/2022
H
4.76
43.2k
83
38
157
0

Party with Wife and Her Lover

Conned into gay encounter.

by colleenslittletoy in Gay Male 09/03/2011
4.2
136.6k
83
13
101
0

Becoming a Gay Fuck Toy

The Secret is out, now I was fucked.

by Want2BUsed in Gay Male 07/25/2014
4.43
99.4k
82
5
98
0

The Unique Mouse Ch. 01

Nerd’s unusual body captivates Chad’s attention in showers.

by Edey in Gay Male 04/08/2022
H
4.66
35.2k
81
33
146

Girl for Charlie

Unexpected gay visitor gives him a chance to dress up.

by Jamie_in_dresses in Transgender & Crossdressers 12/28/2012
H
4.6
88.5k
81
16
103

Soccer Bitch Boys

Small town soccer players submit to the enemy team.

by leo_thedirewolf in Gay Male 09/06/2021
H
4.6
50.5k
81
8
145

My Silence Will Cost You Ch. 01

Sean moves into dorm with hot football jock, shit.

by LoganPrejean337 in Gay Male 03/05/2023
H
4.76
31.4k
80
13
164

A Favour Ch. 02

Josh wakes the following morning to a slightly changed world.

by BluePill in Gay Male 07/09/2019
H
4.86
37.7k
80
5
109

My Personal Trainer

A desire to experiment with gay sex is fulfilled by a BBC.

by dre_jones in Gay Male 07/18/2020
H
4.77
53.8k
80
10
127
0

Short-Term in Chicago Ch. 02

Straight guy learns more from gay neighbor.

by markindy in Gay Male 01/13/2012
H
4.72
81k
79
18
97

Sharing a Hotel with my Teammate

straight, college jock reveals he can suck his own dick.

by androgynousLavender in Gay Male 09/07/2022
H
4.67
46.9k
77
17
148
0

Twink & Straight Stepdad Mess Around

Innocent shower peeping escalates into much more.

by androgynousLavender in Gay Male 01/01/2022
H
4.65
53.5k
76
4
146
0

One More Time Ch. 01

Cameras, soccer balls, the darkroom, and a new best friend.

by JKendallDane in Gay Male 08/09/2013
H
4.51
60.2k
76
17
95

Horny Dylan and his Dad Ch. 01

Dylan and his experiences growing up around older men.

by tysler in Incest/Taboo 09/11/2017
4.19
67.7k
75
3
121

The Daughter's Boyfriend Pt. 02

A father's decent to gay submission continues.

by rimaday in Gay Male 08/23/2018
H
4.73
68.1k
75
10
105

My Best Friend

A typical day between two friends turns into something more.

by matt_1972 in Gay Male 07/19/2012
4.41
167.4k
74
11
102
0

The Hunt Pt. 01

Halloween party, dressed as a woman, the perfect disguise?

by TastyFan in Transgender & Crossdressers 07/13/2014
H
4.51
95k
74
13
98

Turning Boys into Men Ch. 01

Two young men learn much from a mature woman.

by markindy in Incest/Taboo 05/19/2017
4.4
63.8k
74
5
115

Her after party

My wife watches as I explore my bisexual side for her.

by Allhers in Group Sex 09/19/2022
H
4.67
44.5k
73
14
133
0

Road Trip Turnout Ch. 02

Straight man's conversion continues as he fully submits.

by rimaday in Gay Male 01/12/2018
H
4.8
69.3k
72
8
104

Conquered

To seduce sexy straight CEO, twink decides to hire gunman.

by trappedinthecl0set in Gay Male 08/02/2022
H
4.73
24.5k
70
29
130
0

The Chance of a Lifetime

Straight guy gets fucked for the first time.

by xxvicexx in Gay Male 06/25/2008
H
4.51
229.1k
69
38
89
0

Demands on Him Ch. 02

The boss strikes again at the office Christmas party.

by latenightkiss in Gay Male 01/16/2015
H
4.55
86.1k
69
9
88

Mr. and Mrs. Bohaven Ch. 02

They continue their sexual bucket list in Palm Springs.

by SluttyBisexualGuy in Group Sex 06/27/2020
H
4.79
59.2k
67
11
117

My Ex Gets Her Revenge Ch. 01

My ex girlfriend gets revenge.

by nautolan17 in Gay Male 02/22/2020
4.38
57.8k
67
6
108
0

I Fell In with The Masseur

Man finds out he's gay & finds happiness.

by eroticpen69 in Gay Male 03/16/2006
H
4.62
158.1k
65
23
82
0

Coworker Seduces Me

Coworker seduces straight guy.

by niftywriter in Gay Male 01/25/2023
H
4.64
80.4k
65
21
118
0

First Time In Front of My Wife

I was encouraged to suck a man by my wife.

by glmike523 in Gay Male 12/14/2011
4.38
201.1k
64
18
86
0

Lost in a Blizzard Ch. 01

A guy gets lost in a blizzard in Sweden and is rescued.

by TheCandyManCan13 in Gay Male 04/07/2018
H
4.63
36.2k
64
11
85
0

The Birthday Party

A 30 year old loses his virginity to three men.

by KaseyLegs in Transgender & Crossdressers 06/07/2016
H
4.5
69k
63
8
79
0

A Bend in the Road

A middle-aged straight man finds love with a young gay man.

by Oldguy45 in Gay Male 11/24/2009
H
4.54
148k
63
19
93

Straight Top to Gay Bottom Toy Ch. 04

Candy's turnout continues as Tina takes control.

by rimaday in Lesbian Sex 04/13/2018
H
4.74
50.4k
63
7
80

New Awakening Pt. 02- A Taste for Cock

Straight boss pays for spying on his secretary with his ass.

by rimaday in Gay Male 10/15/2017
H
4.77
53k
62
13
83

Big Bot, Sex Hot, Breeder Gets Laid

Sex-starved guy gives in to gay colleague's desire.

by danielblue in Gay Male 10/14/2005
4.45
164.2k
62
0
77
0

Island Love

Man seduces teen on the beach for his first.

by Jamie_in_dresses in Gay Male 02/11/2010
4.43
152.9k
62
13
76

My Cock in My Roommate

Roommate leaves the shower door open. And gets abused.

by R10010 in Gay Male 01/05/2019
4.16
96.3k
62
13
90
0

My Teen Stud Cousin

Sam’s Cousin Comes to Visit.

by dominanceaddict1 in Transgender & Crossdressers 07/08/2023
H
4.59
30.7k
62
16
99
0

Bum Chums Have Fun In The Sun

A virgin stud loses his cherry to 4 hot men on the beach.

by danielblue in Gay Male 06/17/2006
H
4.56
211.6k
61
0
85
0

A Cock in the Hand Ch. 02

Straight married man attemps redemption after forced blowjob.

by rimaday in Gay Male 02/17/2022
H
4.69
49.4k
61
14
88

Alpha Bear on Campus Ch. 01

My seduction by my university's president begins...

by johngus22 in Gay Male 11/19/2020
4.31
37.5k
61
6
113

Summertime House-sitter's Seduction

Older men teach 20-year-old the ropes of gay sex.

by hardgrader in Gay Male 11/01/2005
H
4.67
214.2k
61
31
73
0

To Live and Fuck in L.A. Ch. 01

A young actor catches a break in Hollywood.

by Fit_for_a_Fuck in Gay Male 07/05/2018
H
4.55
27.2k
60
8
82

Mr. Koch

A young man meets a married silver-fox daddy.

by TeshinJapan in Gay Male 01/18/2024
H
4.82
24.3k
59
13
100
0

New Years Resolution Ch. 01

A young, straight married man gives his first blowjob.

by MadCuck in Gay Male 02/06/2022
H
4.64
30k
59
12
117

International Relations

Straight man reluctantly introduced to gay sex.

by markindy in Gay Male 08/19/2009
4.45
123k
59
8
80
0

Locker Room Surprise

A man becomes fasinated by his friend's small cock

by Gunther in Gay Male 12/17/2002
H
4.58
245.3k
59
27
87
0

Donkeydick69

Femboy gets in over his head in a gangbang.

by wolf_hunt in Gay Male 02/03/2023
H
4.5
29.7k
58
10
87
0

Trip with Friends Ch. 01

A sexual awakening in San Francisco.

by TheCandyManCan13 in Gay Male 08/16/2016
H
4.74
46.9k
57
12
88
0

I Used to be Straight

Divorced guy has shower sex with muscular cousin.

by NiceGuyInVa in Gay Male 10/30/2005
4.3
210.6k
57
6
81

Mattress Delivery

Straight horny 18-year-old's gay first time with black delivery man.

by skyscraper11 in Gay Male 01/22/2012
4.32
121.3k
57
11
72
0

Back to Back Pt. 01

Friends find each other again after 12 years.

by TurbulenceAhead in Gay Male 04/24/2022
H
4.75
22.1k
56
23
112

Peter the Neighbour

A young man and his older neighbour.

by davidinlace in Gay Male 10/24/2021
H
4.5
67.8k
56
11
79

Jack's Dad

Jack seduces his dad.

by sj_53 in Incest/Taboo 09/07/2017
4.45
46k
56
9
70

The Web Cam Experiment

Two virgin boys experiment with sexuality.

by fantasiafiesta in Gay Male 09/23/2013
H
4.54
80.9k
56
11
76
0

Suite Seduction Pt. 01

Shy guy sets out to solve an XXL college dorm mystery.

by kreme_filled in Gay Male 08/05/2020
H
4.72
22.8k
55
6
95
0

Island Love Ch. 02

Teen is taught about his need for gay love by an older man.

by Jamie_in_dresses in Gay Male 01/29/2011
H
4.7
75.6k
55
11
66

Seduced by My Hot Step-Brother

My hot stepbrother seduces me and takes my ass.

by LiamCox in Gay Male 09/27/2023
H
4.66
26.8k
54
8
102
0

A Cock in the Hand Ch. 03

Can Wayne save his ass from his blackmailers?

by rimaday in NonConsent/Reluctance 05/01/2022
H
4.81
39.7k
54
15
73

I Knew He wanted My Cock

Guy convinces his roommate to take his cock.

by R10010 in Gay Male 03/07/2019
4.36
63.6k
53
12
73
0

His First Taste of a Man

She arranges a same-sex encounter for him.

by P_V in Gay Male 04/12/2004
H
4.56
174.2k
53
12
68
0

The Office Jock

Wearing a jock strap to the office.

by Radames in Gay Male 02/24/2007
H
4.58
83.8k
53
8
69
0

Recollections of My First Ch. 01

Painful straight breakup leads me to explore hidden desires.

by T00M in Gay Male 03/02/2022
H
4.67
25.1k
53
11
85

Wanting Him

A shy college freshman meets a confident, sexy man.

by onemoreday in Gay Male 01/06/2015
4.18
63.6k
53
9
69

How I Lost My Anal Virginity

My first time losing my anal virginity to a 9 in cock.

by silverbullet2211 in Gay Male 11/02/2016
H
4.51
139.7k
52
18
69
0

Straight Invaded Pt. 02

Home invaders continue his turnout.

by rimaday in NonConsent/Reluctance 09/19/2017
H
4.63
91.2k
52
2
81

My First Time with the Neighbor

A story of how Malcolm lost his virginity.

by lotoplaz in Gay Male 05/07/2020
4.47
58.5k
52
12
81
0

A Hot Visit with a Neighbor

Divorcé joins his neighbor for more than just pizza.

by sjl1701 in Gay Male 01/08/2006
H
4.5
148.2k
52
24
60
0

The Psych Survey

College Kid's Asshole Father Turned by a Psych Nerd.

by rimaday in Gay Male 05/10/2018
H
4.67
41.6k
52
8
86
0

A Night Out

Drunken fun between three new friends.

by whoneedsguys in Gay Male 09/25/2016
H
4.66
60k
52
4
80
0

Straight College Roomies

Cody meets his new college roommate Tanner.

by tylerjaygym in Gay Male 01/21/2024
H
4.57
23.8k
52
10
99
0

A Cock in the Hand Ch. 04

Straight Married Man's Manipulation to Cock Whore Continues.

by rimaday in Gay Male 08/05/2022
H
4.82
33.6k
51
13
67

Gab's Seduction

I become closer with a friend that needs my help.

by Brian70 in Gay Male 10/20/2017
H
4.64
52.4k
50
7
74
0

Vacation at the Beach

Guy takes an island beach vacation.

by niplock in Gay Male 09/06/2006
H
4.51
175.6k
50
16
67
0

Bound to Happen

Journey of discovery for his bisexual impulses.

by jakladd in Gay Male 10/23/2007
H
4.65
109.7k
50
8
88
0

Dominating the Lax Bros Pt. 02

Sexy Irish lacrosse stud submits to horse-hung freshmen.

by somebody123 in Gay Male 02/26/2022
H
4.77
29.9k
49
13
80

Broken In

He gets a first taste of man love.

by standingstones in Gay Male 07/16/2013
4.3
103.7k
49
0
58
0

The Lake House

New neighbor needs a lawn service.

by pdiddyd55 in Gay Male 10/15/2023
H
4.74
35.2k
49
7
108

My Cross Country Adventure

Kind elderly gentleman helps student in distress.

by timmywells in Gay Male 09/02/2005
H
4.69
123.7k
49
19
67
0

That Photo!

A straight man bends a little.

by Otazel in Gay Male 03/18/2006
H
4.63
132.7k
48
7
70
0

Chat Friend Finds Me

Two straight men explore gay sex together.

by markindy in Gay Male 10/24/2006
H
4.59
104.3k
48
12
78

My New Gym Buddy Pt. 03

I give all of myself to him for the first time.

by TheQrious1 in Gay Male 07/17/2021
H
4.61
32.2k
48
8
70

If You Drop Your Wallet In P'town

Young guy's first bisexual adventure.

by 69plus1 in Gay Male 12/23/2012
H
4.63
77k
48
19
61

EDM After-Party

A red dress causes excitement for us both.

by RoyMarksman13 in Gay Male 02/12/2019
H
4.56
36.9k
48
2
77
0
Active tags
Active tags
first time gay
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ
Related Tags
Show More