‘first time gay’ stories

Girlfriend's dad and boyfriend share the back seat.

Girlfriend uses her boyfriend for gay erotica shoot.

Two straight guys get surprisingly horny in the Jacuzzi.

Kinky wife wants to see her husband suck on a cock.

Two, straight best friends make some discoveries.

Friend's professional father helps with pulled muscles.

A dominant and controlling older top gets what he wants

Helping out the frat president with a costume emergency.

Helping his best friend takes an unexpected turn.

The guys take Ecstasy and a wild night unfolds.

High School best friend and bull husband take me new places.

Kinky girlfriend seduces boyfriend into becoming her slut.

Jason and Jacob assume their roles as the night continues.

My fantasy of being submissive to another man is fulfilled.

Unexpected seduction during quarantine desperation.

Straight roommates get horny after St. Paddy Day barhopping.

Girlfriend discovers the guys are still hypnotized.

Braden's back at the Coleman household for 4th of July party.

Seduced at my apartment gym.

First bisexual orgy with my insatiable wife.

Finding my boyfriend's dildo leads to even bigger secrets.

How my neighbor made me his cock sucking man bitch.

Two straight guys trapped in the snow do what they must.

Teenage boy is forced to suck cock for beer.

Spring break drugs lead to first time gay sex.

Wild date ends at a glory hole.

A neighborhood jog leads to first time magic.

Boys get way too drunk on spring break couple's vacation.

With the lockdown in full swing, two housemates make do.

Fantasy Football Punishment Takes a Turn.

Two straight men find more in a gay porno done for money.

Married Man agrees to suck cock for first time.

Two straight friends explore gay sex.

Three best friends vacation in Sin City and sin becomes them.

I agree to be one of her test subjects.

Couple initiates a young neighbor into their play.

Two troubled men find each other at an airport gate.

Straight guy decides being a bottom is where it's at.

An alpha bull turns a straight man into a submissive slut.

Falling helplessly in love with my straight best friend.

Girlfriend makes fantasy come true with her strap-on.

An imprisoned pirate is dangerous thing for a young guard.

Maddie's brother gets a lesson from her professor.

A favor for a mate turns into a whole new experience.

His first time giving a blowjob.

Bi-curious guy gets his man-card permanently revoked by bull.

Wes finds a surprisingly enjoyable solution to a problem.

Can a bi-guy seduce his gay roommate?

Preston goes deeper with his new Daddy.

Sex. Drugs. Burning Man.

A father's descent into gay submission begins.

Young married man forced to suck a stranger's cock.

"Straight" man goes to party, doesn't leave straight.

He wanted to see if I inherited his dick.

Rick loses his virginity to his new older lover.

A walk in the park turned my straight life upside down.

Charles has to finally face the truth, he wants his son.

His new penis did not want his wife. It wanted men.

Straight guy is seduced by gay neighbor.

A mistake turns into some unconventional father-son bonding.

He is bullied to show his hole. Or he loses his girlfriend.

She helps with his gay desire.

Married straight man turned by home invaders.

Husband Introduces Wife to a Special Lady.

Straight guy finds his bi side with his brother.

Straight guy is enjoyed by his five best friends.

Straight man pays the tow truck driver the hard way.

The new neighbor "turned" my straight life upside down.

Husband and wife experience something new.

Married coworker and I have first male sex experience.

Pirates, ropes, and desire!

An Ambitious Young Lady's Turn and Submission to her Idol.

Straight guy lost a bet, has to dress as a girl to a party.

Turns out I'm a little more curious than I thought...

18-year-old is taken in church.

Straight male friends continue to explore with wives' help.

Two straight friends make a bet.

Alpha bull finally takes all of me.

Straight roommate is curious, and I am ready to help.

Straight man turned gay sex servant.

Str8 boy gets best head of his life from virgin cocksucker.

Straight man introduced to erotic male massage.

Caught my boss jerking off and he makes me finish it.

My first sex with a guy, and how my wife made it happen.

A friend's Halloween party ends with a surprise.

On the advice of a friend, I go see Michael for a massage.

Straight man's gay encounter in a dept. store dressing room.

Straight man meets big dick up close and personal.

Frank uses a Gypsy potion to enslave Spence.

Dad and Uncle initiate son into beloved family tradition.

Straight friends first gay time happens under a blanket

First time gay sex for younger man.

A curious guy goes for a boat ride with two sexy older men.

Fat guy gets revenge on hunk by making him submit.

Kevin's wife discovers his gay porn and upends his life.

Dad hooks up with son's lover.

Young married man's turn to a gay sissy slut begins.

He joins a couple to satisfy wife's unusual desires.

A girlfriend widens her boyfriend's horizons and his hole.

Afraid he's been turned gay, Ash must confess to his girl.