Try the free LITEROTICA WEBCAMS!

‘first time gay’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
first time gay 

Category

Sort by:
ViewsRatingFavoriteNewest
All Time

An Old Friend

I meet a friend in a bar, and one thing leads to another...

by whoneedsguys in Gay Male 09/28/2016
H
4.55
43.5k
35
14
56
0

Obsessing Over You, Beautiful!

He has a girlfriend. But he lusts for his gay roommate.

by Edey in Gay Male 04/01/2022
H
4.76
43.2k
83
38
157
0

Burning Honey Ch. 01

Aspen meets a golden man.

by elleem in Gay Male 08/03/2014
H
4.68
42.8k
91
20
116

Surfers Experiment in Speedos

These Aussie surfers experiment in speedos.

by speedodave in Gay Male 07/10/2016
4.49
42.7k
21
2
35
0

The List

Straight father gets a massage he will never forget.

by Illogical in Gay Male 01/12/2024
H
4.78
42.7k
93
22
158
0

First Time in an ABS

Young guy stops by ABS to see what it's all about.

by jrzdogg in Gay Male 10/15/2015
4.26
41.9k
20
2
29
0

Frank's Hot First Time Sex

First Time unexpected gay.

by wisefucker in Gay Male 12/15/2015
3.59
41.9k
7
2
10
0

Cody Becomes Chloe Pt. 01

A teen goes on Craigslist and meets Will.

by Southernstud97 in Transgender & Crossdressers 03/19/2015
3.54
41.7k
16
9
21
0

The Psych Survey

College Kid's Asshole Father Turned by a Psych Nerd.

by rimaday in Gay Male 05/10/2018
H
4.67
41.6k
52
8
86
0

James Pt. 01

Story of a straight guy's first time.

by Irish_Ted in Gay Male 01/26/2017
4.19
41.5k
15
2
27

We Finally Get Together

He gets together with his favorite email couple.

by doer19 in Group Sex 07/09/2007
4.23
41.3k
3
2
5
0

First Time with Ian Ch. 01

A first time with Ian in a shower room.

by mpow in Gay Male 06/17/2013
4.39
40.8k
7
6
12
0

Highway Encounters Ch. 01

A man's boring trip takes a turn for the interesting.

by blatant_bi_guy in Gay Male 04/27/2013
4.49
40.6k
19
10
24

Breaking My Cherry

Man to man seduction.

by bilove69 in Gay Male 08/14/2016
4.41
40.6k
18
2
24
0

Turning Boys into Men Ch. 02

Two young men explore further with mature woman.

by markindy in Incest/Taboo 05/20/2017
H
4.54
40.3k
46
0
57

For the Love of Cock

My path to becoming a cocksucker.

by 69stroker69 in Gay Male 12/04/2019
4.48
39.9k
21
17
31
0

More Than I Bargained For

Rob's fantasies come true while browsing old records.

by JigglyWiggly in Gay Male 05/12/2013
H
4.55
39.8k
29
10
33
0

A Gay Change of Mind

I find myself increasingly attracted to Gavin.

by Templar_Writer in Gay Male 12/15/2016
4.45
39.7k
16
15
24

Mike, Helen, and Hannah

Ben is bribed with sexual favors to have oral sex with Mike.

by yesterdays in Gay Male 10/10/2016
H
4.53
39.7k
27
8
45
0

A Cock in the Hand Ch. 03

Can Wayne save his ass from his blackmailers?

by rimaday in NonConsent/Reluctance 05/01/2022
H
4.81
39.7k
54
15
72

Gay for Candy

Afraid he's been turned gay, Ash must confess to his girl.

by BuckyDuckman in Novels and Novellas 06/01/2018
H
4.81
39.7k
100
22
162
0

Underneath

He noticed his annoying coworker secretly wears a thong!

by Edey in Gay Male 04/19/2022
H
4.77
38.8k
85
28
155

Easing My Stress

A massage to combat stress turns into better relief.

by Reusha in Gay Male 05/01/2015
4
38.6k
8
3
10

Wrestler's Shower

A sexually repressed wrestler has his first gay encounter

by Maximus_Crassus in Gay Male 07/28/2016
4.27
38.4k
23
0
32
0

Trip Money Ch. 02

Going for the big trip money

by sr71plt in Gay Male 10/27/2006
H
4.59
38.3k
8
0
13

Sissy in Vegas

What happens in vegas turns a sissy out of a femboy.

by wolf_hunt in Gay Male 01/21/2023
H
4.71
37.7k
85
22
142
0

A Favour Ch. 02

Josh wakes the following morning to a slightly changed world.

by BluePill in Gay Male 07/09/2019
H
4.86
37.7k
80
5
109

Two Straight Guys

Straight guy Lee feels sparks with straight guy George.

by TwistedManc in Gay Male 02/17/2024
H
4.81
37.6k
104
31
184

Alpha Bear on Campus Ch. 01

My seduction by my university's president begins...

by johngus22 in Gay Male 11/19/2020
4.31
37.5k
61
6
113

EDM After-Party

A red dress causes excitement for us both.

by RoyMarksman13 in Gay Male 02/12/2019
H
4.56
36.8k
48
2
77
0

First Time Guy...

A great cure for loneliness.

by alexcarr in Gay Male 04/29/2012
4.17
36.6k
2
2
8
0

Club Games

Who will they choose.

by mikeinto in Group Sex 06/27/2012
4.11
36.6k
8
1
15
0

24hr Gym After Dark

Timothy encounters 2 strangers at the gym.

by ComingOutStrong in Gay Male 02/16/2022
H
4.66
36.3k
45
11
77
0

Lost in a Blizzard Ch. 01

A guy gets lost in a blizzard in Sweden and is rescued.

by TheCandyManCan13 in Gay Male 04/07/2018
H
4.63
36.2k
64
11
85
0

Best Customer Service at an ABS

Married Man in Desperate Need.

by 1mbibry in Gay Male 12/20/2021
H
4.59
36k
42
9
62
0

Seduced on Liberty

My early Navy days and my first gay encounter.

by rob1949 in Gay Male 06/13/2016
4.25
35.6k
24
9
29

The Stanger in the Steam Room

A college freshman discovers his bisexuality.

by QuietNightFantasy in Gay Male 03/03/2022
H
4.61
35.6k
27
9
59
0

Retirement Home Romp Ch. 01

Sam visits his grandfather at his retirement home.

by QuietNightFantasy in Incest/Taboo 03/06/2022
H
4.5
35.4k
29
1
54
0

First Time with a Man

My first encounter in a sexual relationship with a man.

by jwalkernc in Gay Male 07/15/2013
4.08
35.2k
8
3
13
0

The Lake House

New neighbor needs a lawn service.

by pdiddyd55 in Gay Male 10/15/2023
H
4.74
35.2k
49
7
108

The Unique Mouse Ch. 01

Nerd’s unusual body captivates Chad’s attention in showers.

by Edey in Gay Male 04/08/2022
H
4.66
35.1k
81
33
146

A Synonym for Acquiesce

No one told him 'no'.

by my_rage_is_bliss in Gay Male 08/11/2005
4.17
35.1k
10
3
13
0

To Protect and Serve

Breaking up leads to cop car sex.

by majicman21 in Gay Male 04/02/2016
4.38
34.3k
29
6
37
0

Meating Terry

My first experience with a submissive sissy boy.

by andyorlando in Transgender & Crossdressers 10/05/2016
4.14
34.2k
16
5
20
0

Birthday Sur-pride!

An innocent birthday gift turns into a new F/F experience

by LushinLace in Audio 06/24/2021
H
4.77
34k
24
10
55
0

A Cock in the Hand Ch. 04

Straight Married Man's Manipulation to Cock Whore Continues.

by rimaday in Gay Male 08/05/2022
H
4.83
33.6k
51
13
67

My Big Cock Journey Ch. 02

Being fucked for a first time... by two big cocks.

by ajstar in Gay Male 11/23/2021
H
4.69
33.4k
29
4
53

Girlfriend's Away Pt. 04

How far can Sara make the boys go?

by Hebrides in Group Sex 03/22/2021
4.18
33.4k
19
4
37

Surrogate Experiences

Laura talks Tommy into trying it with a man.

by Omenainen in Gay Male 07/11/2020
H
4.69
33.2k
19
9
49
0

My Bi-Side Pt. 01

Finally exploring my Bi-Side.

by kaizen082 in Gay Male 09/21/2019
H
4.53
33.2k
13
7
24
0

Hotter than Fiction 1997

A young man's first bisexual encounter with a hot couple.

by DionysusK in Gay Male 06/17/2023
H
4.74
33k
18
9
53
0

A Hot White Mess Pt. 03

Alex's curiosity leads him to spy on a campsite.

by Gorev_Reighl in Gay Male 09/09/2016
4.24
32.3k
7
6
14

My New Gym Buddy Pt. 03

I give all of myself to him for the first time.

by TheQrious1 in Gay Male 07/17/2021
H
4.61
32.2k
48
8
70

A Hot White Mess Pt. 01

18 year old Alex has his first gay crush on Steve.

by Gorev_Reighl in Gay Male 08/25/2016
4.47
32.1k
25
7
38

Peter the Neighbour Ch. 02

Peter takes me to bed.

by davidinlace in Gay Male 10/31/2021
H
4.57
31.8k
23
4
33

Nutritional Supplement

A curious bodybuilder learns a new work out.

by shannonkelly in Gay Male 08/14/2016
4.35
31.8k
14
2
19
0

Mirror in Law

A mother in law comes up with a devious plan.

by Fibaro in Mind Control 12/11/2021
4.07
31.6k
21
6
45
0

The Snow Man Ch. 07

Alex makes a decision.

by Orgone5 in Gay Male 08/08/2005
H
4.52
31.6k
10
8
13

Three Day Pass # 02

His first gay experience continues.

by BennyBlank in Gay Male 06/19/2005
4.48
31.4k
3
0
4

Voyeur No Longer

I saw him fuck a guy, invited him home for my wife to see us.

by ILikeIt in Gay Male 12/01/2023
H
4.85
31.3k
83
11
132
0

My Silence Will Cost You Ch. 01

Sean moves into dorm with hot football jock, shit.

by LoganPrejean337 in Gay Male 03/05/2023
H
4.76
31.3k
80
13
164

My Teen Stud Cousin

Sam’s Cousin Comes to Visit.

by dominanceaddict1 in Transgender & Crossdressers 07/08/2023
H
4.59
30.7k
62
16
98
0

New Years Resolution Ch. 01

A young, straight married man gives his first blowjob.

by MadCuck in Gay Male 02/06/2022
H
4.64
30k
59
12
117

Camping Bromance Firsts Ch. 02

Two straight buddies experience more of eachother.

by Logjam107 in Gay Male 12/24/2020
H
4.57
29.9k
22
6
38

Long Weekends Pt. 01

Holidays are better with family especially for Landon.

by notacrobat in Gay Male 01/04/2020
H
4.7
29.9k
33
5
58

Dominating the Lax Bros Pt. 02

Sexy Irish lacrosse stud submits to horse-hung freshmen.

by somebody123 in Gay Male 02/26/2022
H
4.77
29.9k
49
13
80

Donkeydick69

Femboy gets in over his head in a gangbang.

by wolf_hunt in Gay Male 02/03/2023
H
4.5
29.7k
58
10
86
0

Jake's Awakening

Supressed feelings between friends leads to more.

by evok99 in Gay Male 06/19/2012
3.9
29.4k
13
10
18
0

Giving it up on Craigslist

Sex starved husband ends up pleasing man from Craigslist.

by ginaxx in Anal 04/25/2021
4.13
29.3k
12
3
20
0

College Days Ch. 01

A fictional story.

by bdavidson in Gay Male 03/10/2019
H
4.52
29.2k
25
8
35

24 HR Gym

An unexpected first time.

by Mjolnir22 in Gay Male 02/17/2023
H
4.54
28.8k
23
5
48
0

Unrequited Love Ch. 01

A young man describes his first time.

by bjmichaels in Gay Male 06/18/2012
3.77
28.7k
4
5
5
0

First Night Seduction Ch. 01

Gay men can enjoy seduction!

by S_Isemen in Gay Male 06/30/2019
3.86
28.7k
17
4
43

My First Time With Gordon

1st time bi experience.

by swmnb in Gay Male 06/27/2016
4.14
28.6k
12
5
17
0

Brian, My First Gay Experience Ch. 04

The final chapter!

by dodgeboy2 in Gay Male 08/31/2008
4.38
28.3k
2
3
4

Three

You have a surprising revelation for me.

by Carack_in in Group Sex 04/21/2009
4.03
28.1k
2
0
6
0

My Journey: From Fingers to Cock

My journey from fingers, to dildos, and finally to cocks.

by abzz2017 in Gay Male 09/28/2020
H
4.66
28k
41
9
75
0

They Just Needed a Little Push

A Bisexual Match is Made.

by fittexanman in Group Sex 12/21/2023
H
4.77
28k
37
6
77
0

BFF Ch. 04

My BFF finally gives me to a real man.

by BiBoiBitch in Gay Male 03/30/2021
4.27
27.7k
35
6
50

Midtowne Spa - First Time Bathhouse

Finally going to a gay bathhouse.

by BiLoveCock in Gay Male 08/28/2021
4.11
27.6k
11
8
19

The Education of Lisa Ch. 09

Will's gay-time story.

by Christian Black in Gay Male 08/27/2005
4.29
27.6k
2
0
2

Cherry Popped

Stationed in a war zone, a soldier has to escape.

by tvdude17 in Gay Male 11/26/2021
4.26
27.5k
17
5
40
0

Christmas Wish Mishap: Twin Bullies

A Christmas wish come true, or is it...

by Fibaro in Transgender & Crossdressers 12/25/2020
4.29
27.2k
29
15
48
0

To Live and Fuck in L.A. Ch. 01

A young actor catches a break in Hollywood.

by Fit_for_a_Fuck in Gay Male 07/05/2018
H
4.55
27.2k
60
8
82

Seduced by My Hot Step-Brother

My hot stepbrother seduces me and takes my ass.

by LiamCox in Gay Male 09/27/2023
H
4.66
26.8k
54
8
102
0

Wanting Him Ch. 02

Ashton and Thomas resolve some differences.

by onemoreday in Gay Male 01/23/2015
4.2
26.7k
18
14
23

The Service Station

First time gay in filthy service station.

by DirtyFetishMan in Gay Male 02/01/2021
H
4.51
26.4k
38
3
58
0

Started at the Theater

First time with a man, started at the Adult Movie House.

by isoro1 in Gay Male 03/23/2020
4.29
26k
14
4
20
0

The Other Boy in Goodwell

High lonesome cowboy's first time w/ an experienced hipster.

by Theroughstockeventauthor in Gay Male 07/05/2015
4.44
25.7k
15
6
28

The Real Kasey Ch. 01

The story of Kasey Legs.

by KaseyLegs in Transgender & Crossdressers 10/07/2016
H
4.72
25.5k
23
8
42
0

The Lesson Ch. 02

Harry's lesson is taken to the next level.

by seb737 in Gay Male 04/27/2006
H
4.54
25.4k
1
2
3

Adventures With Close Friends

Adventures of four close friends.

by aphrodite116596 in Group Sex 09/06/2020
H
4.52
25.3k
20
1
34
0

Recollections of My First Ch. 01

Painful straight breakup leads me to explore hidden desires.

by T00M in Gay Male 03/02/2022
H
4.67
25.1k
53
11
85

First Time Gay Sexual Experience

A straight male walks into a gay video arcade.

by BBPierce in Gay Male 10/22/2022
H
4.58
25.1k
20
3
41
0

Go Fuck Yourself

Man had time machine and sucks his own dick.

by Eros_343 in Gay Male 05/25/2019
H
4.51
25k
38
10
48
0

3 Smoothies Please

Exploring couple finds shaved exhibitionist Ted.

by tallsmooth in First Time 10/17/2019
H
4.63
25k
25
10
29
0

The Soccer Locker Room Pt. 06

Jake satisfies his star player after the team's first win.

by jtwy in Gay Male 01/09/2021
H
4.66
24.4k
28
1
40

Conquered

To seduce sexy straight CEO, twink decides to hire gunman.

by trappedinthecl0set in Gay Male 08/02/2022
H
4.73
24.4k
70
29
129
0

Mr. Koch

A young man meets a married silver-fox daddy.

by TeshinJapan in Gay Male 01/18/2024
H
4.82
24.2k
59
13
99
0

The CL Tease Ch. 02

The tease gets more than he bargained for.

by jrzdogg in Gay Male 05/16/2017
H
4.53
24.1k
18
1
20
Active tags
Active tags
first time gay
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ
Related Tags
Show More