Try the free LITEROTICA WEBCAMS!

‘first time gay’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
first time gay 

Category

Sort by:
ViewsRatingFavoriteNewest
All Time

My Photo Shoot

My first time with another man is during a modeling shoot.

by matt_1972 in Gay Male 05/05/2011
4.33
124k
30
4
43
0

No Longer a Show Ch. 02

Straight cam dude meets IRL for first gay anal sex.

by CinaedeFuri in Gay Male 01/23/2021
4.33
12.8k
21
3
24

First Time

My first time with another guy.

by brummy in Gay Male 05/07/2013
4.33
78.3k
12
6
19
0

New Gym Friend

Straight man is seduced after a workout.

by newbitime in Gay Male 09/25/2014
4.33
145.5k
93
14
124

Identity Crisis 01: In The Closet

Peter, Eddie, Venom and Spider-Man in a farce of alter egos.

by AWhoopsieDaisy in Celebrities & Fan Fiction 05/08/2022
4.33
3.7k
8
3
11

Best Friends' Friday Night

Two best friends share a magical night.

by Mindsworkspace23 in Gay Male 12/13/2018
4.33
44.6k
20
1
35
0

The Experiment

Kevin's wife discovers his gay porn and upends his life.

by MindTrip412 in Gay Male 02/06/2020
4.33
60.9k
105
28
163
0

Our First Meeting

A first-person imaging of what a first time might be like.

by txwill85 in Gay Male 02/06/2016
4.33
13.2k
8
1
10

New Territory

A young man's first experience with his fellow gender.

by Mr_Bodacious in Gay Male 02/16/2017
4.33
64k
5
7
14
0

Stress Relief

Inexperienced married guy tries gay sex while traveling.

by markindy in Gay Male 07/11/2010
4.32
115.8k
33
13
49
0

College Life

Jake and I become more than friends.

by historycup in Gay Male 07/07/2014
4.32
71.7k
25
11
39

Telling Secrets

One young man's boss offers an unexpected proposition!

by OwenBurke in Gay Male 09/30/2013
4.32
69.7k
16
3
22
0

Sixty Nine - And Counting!

Colin is my first. He will not be my last!

by Corjix in Gay Male 05/09/2021
4.32
7.9k
2
1
7
0

My New Gym Buddy

Turns out I'm a little more curious than I thought...

by TheQrious1 in Gay Male 03/23/2021
4.32
63.1k
132
24
202

A True Bisexual First

Twenty-year-old is seduced by an older gentleman.

by MacD in Gay Male 08/11/2005
4.32
194.2k
30
10
36
0

Mattress Delivery

Straight horny 18-year-old's gay first time with black delivery man.

by skyscraper11 in Gay Male 01/22/2012
4.32
121.3k
57
11
72
0

Sarah's Poker Surprise

Surprise bi first time.

by HotYoungCouple in Gay Male 07/26/2012
4.32
141.7k
39
8
53

Brotherly Love

Mo is taken to a sex worker by his older brother.

by tvdude17 in Incest/Taboo 09/14/2018
4.32
21.7k
23
0
32
0

First Night Seduction Ch. 02

Theo takes his time with Adrien.

by S_Isemen in Gay Male 07/08/2019
4.32
20.2k
12
7
19

Alpha Bear on Campus Ch. 01

My seduction by my university's president begins...

by johngus22 in Gay Male 11/19/2020
4.31
37.5k
61
6
113

Curious with the Gay Kid

18-year-old gets big surprise during first gay experience.

by taleteller in Gay Male 10/22/2005
4.31
254.7k
93
18
102

Failed Threesome

Bi-curious guy gets his man-card permanently revoked by bull.

by RSchwuler in Gay Male 02/22/2017
4.31
166.8k
216
30
334
0

Cable Hook-Up

A married man's first time with another man.

by LaTourEiffel in Gay Male 11/07/2012
E
4.31
118.6k
43
12
50
0

Time to Share

Two men share a beauty.

by pratychook in Group Sex 06/10/2005
4.31
59.9k
7
0
12
0

I Used to be Straight

Divorced guy has shower sex with muscular cousin.

by NiceGuyInVa in Gay Male 10/30/2005
4.3
210.6k
57
6
81

Wild Camping

Ramon and Dan were gay virgins until they camped out.

by Dannyboy23 in First Time 05/04/2023
4.3
13.7k
5
1
9
0

Steaming Love Pt. 03

Part three of the series, Steaming Love.

by Nick_Roy in Gay Male 12/18/2022
4.3
1.7k
2
0
5

Broken In

He gets a first taste of man love.

by standingstones in Gay Male 07/16/2013
4.3
103.7k
49
0
58
0

Straight Boy to Bi Bottom Ch. 01

My first cock.

by young7inchfun in Gay Male 01/12/2017
4.3
85.3k
32
8
39
0

The Paper (Man) Delivers

Etiquette between tops, bottoms and the meeting of men!

by VickyMalacca in Gay Male 11/30/2022
4.3
4.3k
2
1
5
0

My Trusted Friend Ch. 01

My best friend helps me live my secret fantasy.

by WillyDFW in Gay Male 07/23/2018
4.3
68.3k
43
9
68

Blanket Bitch

Straight friends first gay time happens under a blanket

by AustinTatious7787 in Gay Male 07/30/2008
4.3
216.4k
107
2
133
0

Long Weekends Pt. 02

The weekend fun continues for the cousins and a friend.

by notacrobat in Gay Male 04/26/2020
4.3
12.7k
12
2
25

Keeping an Open Mind

Seema convinces me to try some new things.

by Templar_Writer in Fetish 10/15/2019
4.29
20.4k
11
6
21
0

Christmas Wish Mishap: Twin Bullies

A Christmas wish come true, or is it...

by Fibaro in Transgender & Crossdressers 12/25/2020
4.29
27.2k
29
15
48
0

Started at the Theater

First time with a man, started at the Adult Movie House.

by isoro1 in Gay Male 03/23/2020
4.29
26k
14
4
20
0

Crossing the Line

A young man's first gay experience.

by joeys-game in Gay Male 06/29/2006
4.29
98.9k
13
12
18
0

Robert's First Time Cock Ch. 01

He made me cum over his chest.

by norm55 in Gay Male 06/05/2007
4.29
78.6k
10
3
11

Remembering the First

Two young men discover sex with each other.

by lhayes in Gay Male 07/21/2011
4.29
53.9k
6
6
9

Rodney's Travels - Manaus Brazil

An unexpected adventure in Brazil...

by ragal2 in Gay Male 12/23/2022
4.29
8.8k
1
0
7

My First Time

He always thought of himself as straight.

by gray3035 in Gay Male 09/12/2005
4.29
91.2k
19
7
26
0

The Education of Lisa Ch. 09

Will's gay-time story.

by Christian Black in Gay Male 08/27/2005
4.29
27.6k
2
0
2

Special Delivery

The pizza delivery guy was a hot black man.

by felok22 in Gay Male 08/11/2010
4.29
57.4k
13
6
16
0

My First Gay Blowjob Ch. 01

Straight for 22 years, until I see his cock.

by JSamuels58 in First Time 10/10/2020
4.28
50.6k
47
10
76

Wrestler's Shower

A sexually repressed wrestler has his first gay encounter

by Maximus_Crassus in Gay Male 07/28/2016
4.27
38.4k
23
0
32
0

BFF Ch. 04

My BFF finally gives me to a real man.

by BiBoiBitch in Gay Male 03/30/2021
4.27
27.7k
35
6
50

The Mr. Larry Chronicles: Neil Pt. 01

Mr. Larry teaches Neil about his needs.

by Tentacles_Fun_Grrl in Anal 10/31/2022
4.27
9.8k
6
2
6

Cherry Popped

Stationed in a war zone, a soldier has to escape.

by tvdude17 in Gay Male 11/26/2021
4.26
27.5k
17
5
40
0

First Time in an ABS

Young guy stops by ABS to see what it's all about.

by jrzdogg in Gay Male 10/15/2015
4.26
41.9k
20
2
29
0

Crime Doesn't Pay

A man catches a thief in his hotel and teaches a life lesson.

by Virgil_Assad in Transgender & Crossdressers 08/12/2013
4.26
72.5k
34
6
42
0

Ron

He gives in to his curiosity.

by ~Shadow~ in Gay Male 03/28/2006
4.26
95.2k
7
4
15
0

Seduced on Liberty

My early Navy days and my first gay encounter.

by rob1949 in Gay Male 06/13/2016
4.25
35.6k
24
9
29

My 30th Birthday

Crossing to the other side with a party guest.

by Jarios in Gay Male 09/19/2016
4.25
67.8k
12
9
20
0

The Road Sometimes Traveled

An unrequited cuckold takes the gay way out.

by rnumbers123 in Gay Male 06/06/2014
4.25
46.1k
36
8
43
0

First Time Ch. 01

Married bisexual man has his first same-sex encounter.

by bimale_35 in Gay Male 10/04/2007
4.24
128.3k
18
6
29

A Hot White Mess Pt. 03

Alex's curiosity leads him to spy on a campsite.

by Gorev_Reighl in Gay Male 09/09/2016
4.24
32.3k
7
6
14

Hell Night

18-year-old is taken in church.

by Tomass in Gay Male 11/27/2005
4.24
196.5k
127
18
156
0

Cassandra and Steve

His first MMF threeway has a surprise.

by Christian Black in Group Sex 01/29/2006
4.23
95.3k
14
2
24

We Finally Get Together

He gets together with his favorite email couple.

by doer19 in Group Sex 07/09/2007
4.23
41.3k
3
2
5
0

Charles

My first time with another guy.

by Afterhours22 in Gay Male 06/17/2012
4.23
49.4k
17
11
20

After The Move

New apartment leads to new experiences.

by Reshbod in Gay Male 10/06/2005
4.22
56.9k
13
7
18
0

The Eyes of Acceptance Ch. 01

Scared boy learns a painful truth about himself.

by KaseyLegs in Transgender & Crossdressers 01/02/2021
4.21
11.6k
18
8
24

Wanting Him Ch. 02

Ashton and Thomas resolve some differences.

by onemoreday in Gay Male 01/23/2015
4.2
26.7k
18
14
23

Party with Wife and Her Lover

Conned into gay encounter.

by colleenslittletoy in Gay Male 09/03/2011
4.2
136.6k
83
13
101
0

Finding Myself

Teen with a much older man.

by kccrossdresserleslie in Gay Male 07/08/2012
4.2
146.5k
12
9
21
0

Horny Dylan and his Dad Ch. 01

Dylan and his experiences growing up around older men.

by tysler in Incest/Taboo 09/11/2017
4.19
67.7k
75
3
121

I'm Not Gay - But

High school senior is seduced by family friend.

by iluvitall in Gay Male 12/15/2006
4.19
131.6k
26
7
34
0

James Pt. 01

Story of a straight guy's first time.

by Irish_Ted in Gay Male 01/26/2017
4.19
41.5k
15
2
27

A King's Conquest

A warrior king always gets what he wants.

by poisonivy274 in Gay Male 04/20/2006
4.19
80.1k
40
8
47

Girlfriend's Away Pt. 04

How far can Sara make the boys go?

by Hebrides in Group Sex 03/22/2021
4.18
33.4k
19
4
37

Wanting Him

A shy college freshman meets a confident, sexy man.

by onemoreday in Gay Male 01/06/2015
4.18
63.6k
53
9
69

The Myth about Big Black Cock

I discover the truth behind the myth of Big Black Cock.

by BBC_Envy in Gay Male 06/13/2015
4.18
68.1k
29
13
45
0

First Time Guy...

A great cure for loneliness.

by alexcarr in Gay Male 04/29/2012
4.17
36.6k
2
2
8
0

My First Time Experience

My first time gay experience, and how I knew I was bisexual.

by CummyTightsCub in Gay Male 07/17/2011
4.17
132.4k
28
11
35
0

Sean and Roger

A night on the town leaves 2 unlikely lovers together alone.

by ShadeyB in Transgender & Crossdressers 08/04/2011
4.17
23.7k
1
2
1
0

Straight Guy with a Gay Friend

When simple curiosity and fantasy becomes real.

by KubrickFreak in Gay Male 10/11/2005
4.17
196.2k
33
5
57
0

A Synonym for Acquiesce

No one told him 'no'.

by my_rage_is_bliss in Gay Male 08/11/2005
4.17
35.1k
10
3
13
0

First Time With a Guy

Straight but curious guy has his first gay experience.

by o123oleary in Gay Male 08/25/2016
4.16
77.8k
22
10
33
0

Blind Man's Bluff

Straight Guy/Gay Sex.

by trevorm in Gay Male 10/06/2011
4.16
70.8k
14
2
22
0

The Seed was Planted...

My first step in my sexual realization.

by Daxdenny11 in Group Sex 07/16/2023
4.16
11.2k
11
3
30
0

Bi-Sexual Seminar

Two straight guys explore bi-sexual fun.

by hhart708 in Gay Male 05/23/2008
4.16
155.6k
35
9
49
0

My Cock in My Roommate

Roommate leaves the shower door open. And gets abused.

by R10010 in Gay Male 01/05/2019
4.16
96.3k
62
13
90
0

Tony's First Time

Tony hooks up with a guy from work.

by chocolatecookie3 in Gay Male 12/31/2012
4.15
83.4k
15
5
20
0

Meating Terry

My first experience with a submissive sissy boy.

by andyorlando in Transgender & Crossdressers 10/05/2016
4.14
34.2k
16
5
20
0

My First Time With Gordon

1st time bi experience.

by swmnb in Gay Male 06/27/2016
4.14
28.6k
12
5
17
0

Giving it up on Craigslist

Sex starved husband ends up pleasing man from Craigslist.

by ginaxx in Anal 04/25/2021
4.13
29.3k
12
3
20
0

A Hot White Mess Pt. 02

Alex seeks relief at the beach but then Steve appears.

by Gorev_Reighl in Gay Male 08/30/2016
4.13
12.9k
9
4
11

Out

First time male gay sex story.

by FoxyMoxy in Gay Male 03/08/2017
4.12
58.7k
10
20
16
0

The Competition Ch. 01

What is up with little sister?

by napscoordinator in Incest/Taboo 05/01/2019
4.12
43.9k
26
3
48
0

Club Games

Who will they choose.

by mikeinto in Group Sex 06/27/2012
4.11
36.6k
8
1
15
0

First Bisexual Experience

Friends discover new sexual dimensions.

by wisdom45 in Gay Male 09/06/2016
4.11
59.1k
13
10
18
0

Midtowne Spa - First Time Bathhouse

Finally going to a gay bathhouse.

by BiLoveCock in Gay Male 08/28/2021
4.11
27.6k
11
8
19

Banging Big Time Is No Theory Ch. 02

The boys explore what's always been there

by kingchaos69 in Celebrities & Fan Fiction 10/09/2013
4.1
57.4k
23
3
26

Coach CockStud

Married man dreams about sucking cock... and does

by brian420d in Gay Male 09/17/2010
4.1
103.7k
20
9
27
0

Oslo

An unusual adventure when I was a young man.

by NorwegianLars in Gay Male 07/16/2021
4.1
12.9k
4
1
9

The Party

Boldness can get you spanked and more.

by Bottom_up in BDSM 07/05/2012
4.09
65.7k
6
3
7
0

Steaming Love Pt. 02

Part two of the gay MM erotica romance series, Steaming Love.

by Nick_Roy in Gay Male 12/16/2022
4.09
3.4k
2
2
6

Of Lust & Stallions

Two stallions get frisky...

by AmethystMare in Gay Male 07/05/2018
4.09
18.3k
7
0
14
0

Me and MrE

My first experience with another guy.

by Aussie_Ton in Gay Male 07/31/2008
4.08
67.3k
5
0
7
0

The Twist

Story about two friends search for love after heartbreak.

by MajesticLVR87 in Gay Male 11/02/2023
4.08
7.1k
6
5
15
Active tags
Active tags
first time gay
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ
Related Tags
Show More