Try the free LITEROTICA WEBCAMS!

‘first time gay’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
first time gay 

Category

Sort by:
ViewsRatingFavoriteNewest
All Time

The Soccer Locker Room Pt. 09

Jake and his straight teammate chat in the showers post-game.

by jtwy in Gay Male 03/13/2021
H
4.53
23.9k
20
4
29

The CL Tease Ch. 01

Straight, online tease gets get turned out by his 'victims'.

by jrzdogg in Gay Male 05/04/2017
4.49
23.9k
22
1
30

Locker Room Talk

A sexless man has a reawakening in middle age.

by OffNSFW in Gay Male 06/16/2023
H
4.52
23.8k
12
6
33
0

Straight College Roomies

Cody meets his new college roommate Tanner.

by tylerjaygym in Gay Male 01/21/2024
H
4.58
23.7k
52
10
100
0

Sean and Roger

A night on the town leaves 2 unlikely lovers together alone.

by ShadeyB in Transgender & Crossdressers 08/04/2011
4.17
23.7k
1
2
1
0

Do You Want to Hold My Cock? Pt. 02

Straight guy ends up liking having his ass eaten.

by tazzman777 in Gay Male 07/08/2023
4.43
23.6k
25
3
42

Lost & Found Ch. 01

Ayden's accident unravels his world.

by SinfulCharms in Gay Male 06/26/2010
H
4.63
23.5k
13
14
16
0

My New Gym Buddy Pt. 02

I do a little more exploring of this newfound curiosity...

by TheQrious1 in Gay Male 03/26/2021
4.03
23.2k
26
6
41

Aunt Spices Things Up

Aunt introduces me to her lifestyle.

by jx88 in Gay Male 07/07/2020
4.34
22.8k
29
4
34
0

Suite Seduction Pt. 01

Shy guy sets out to solve an XXL college dorm mystery.

by kreme_filled in Gay Male 08/05/2020
H
4.72
22.7k
55
6
95
0

In Bed with Housemate's Gay Cousin

Awakening to a very sticky and tricky dilemma.

by RandyPanTheGoatBoy in Gay Male 09/28/2023
H
4.55
22.6k
24
12
53
0

Escape Room for Jocks Pt. 03

The jocks play another game and meet eachother.

by MrSunshineBoy in Gay Male 09/08/2020
4.42
22.6k
25
2
38

First Time at 7/11

He gets his first time in a cooler.

by SJ6969 in Gay Male 07/17/2013
3.46
22.3k
2
1
4
0

Working Out Issues Ch. 03

Mel gets more comfortable with his body.

by blake1 in Transgender & Crossdressers 02/25/2019
H
4.59
22.3k
24
10
27

Back to Back Pt. 01

Friends find each other again after 12 years.

by TurbulenceAhead in Gay Male 04/24/2022
H
4.75
22.1k
56
23
112

Magical Desire

A powerful warlock finds his soulmate.

by SkylerLuv in Gay Male 02/14/2019
H
4.8
22.1k
15
4
39
0

Mark and Melanie: The Meeting

We meet Mark and Melanie, maybe our next sexual companions.

by rainman0720 in Group Sex 03/05/2017
H
4.58
22k
24
4
36

Working Out Issues Ch. 06

Mel makes a friend at the gym, and finds a way to help Adam.

by blake1 in Transgender & Crossdressers 03/31/2019
H
4.77
21.7k
30
13
33

Brotherly Love

Mo is taken to a sex worker by his older brother.

by tvdude17 in Incest/Taboo 09/14/2018
4.32
21.7k
23
0
32
0

The Beach House

I hang out with my Aunt's new Boyfriend.

by HenrySeldon in Gay Male 01/14/2024
H
4.61
21.6k
31
4
63

Bears, Beets, Butt Stuff

[Office fanfic] Jim and Pam stay at Dwight's agritourist B&B.

by Ransome in Celebrities & Fan Fiction 01/08/2017
4.06
21.3k
8
2
13
0

Loving Him Ch. 01

A story of the beginning, bitter and sweet.

by gildedbutterflies in Gay Male 07/12/2013
4.49
21.1k
19
6
30

First Date Pt. 01

An Incubus sex demon is looking for his new mate.

by ClarenceKonrad in Gay Male 07/31/2018
4.36
20.7k
29
6
47
0

The Unique Mouse Ch. 02

Nerd's unusual body makes Chad go crazy about him...

by Edey in Gay Male 04/14/2022
H
4.8
20.7k
43
25
59

Summer Switch Ch. 04

BFFs to lovers - 1st gay sex experience of 2 "straight" men.

by qchickie in Gay Male 04/04/2021
4.46
20.6k
14
6
32

Keeping an Open Mind

Seema convinces me to try some new things.

by Templar_Writer in Fetish 10/15/2019
4.29
20.4k
11
6
21
0

Starting Over

Staying at my buddy's place brings some surprises.

by QuickYellowFox in Gay Male 12/02/2023
H
4.52
20.4k
28
1
57

First Night Seduction Ch. 02

Theo takes his time with Adrien.

by S_Isemen in Gay Male 07/08/2019
4.32
20.2k
12
7
19

Trust Ch. 02

A gay man falls in love with a straight one.

by Elenia26 in Gay Male 08/13/2013
H
4.69
20k
15
0
20

What Happens in Vegas

A story of a first time blow job in Vegas.

by randomlyrandom in Gay Male 08/29/2020
4.04
20k
11
4
15
0

Underneath Ch. 02

He ordered his male coworker to wear lingerie and more...

by Edey in Gay Male 04/30/2022
H
4.83
19.9k
24
23
49

Desperate Nights

Housemates can't sleep - follow up on "Desperate Times..."

by aRedheadWrites in Gay Male 08/21/2020
4.45
19.8k
18
10
28
0

Underneath a Warm Afternoon Sun

Time away with my best friend.

by asterism in Gay Male 03/10/2021
H
4.67
19.8k
18
5
43
0

The Principal's Turn - Sam's Fall

With Maggie's turn complete, Taisha puts Sam in his place.

by rimaday in Transgender & Crossdressers 07/18/2021
H
4.72
19.8k
24
4
38

Weekend in New Hampshire Pt. 02

Day 2 of the friends' adventure in the country.

by grant50 in Transgender & Crossdressers 10/26/2019
H
4.73
19.5k
23
5
27

Enthusiastic Voyeur

Wife's gay sex fantasy, old urges, a chance gay encounter.

by ILikeIt in Gay Male 10/07/2023
H
4.6
19.2k
35
13
61
0

Loving Him Ch. 02

Lexan and Max's relationship takes a drastic turn.

by gildedbutterflies in Gay Male 07/12/2013
H
4.6
19.1k
17
5
18

First Do No Harm

A beautiful young patient changes me from straight to gay.

by eviltwin52 in Gay Male 03/02/2023
H
4.68
18.9k
30
13
59

Into the Woods

Caught naked in the woods.

by davidinlace in Gay Male 06/10/2023
H
4.59
18.8k
24
10
45

Post-coital Panic

Kit gets more than he bargained for on a bachelor's trip.

by hardwoodstudios in Gay Male 04/01/2024
H
4.86
18.5k
40
17
71
0

Of Lust & Stallions

Two stallions get frisky...

by AmethystMare in Gay Male 07/05/2018
4.09
18.3k
7
0
14
0

Escape Room for Jocks Pt. 04

The race is on between the 4 jocks.

by MrSunshineBoy in Gay Male 09/18/2020
H
4.57
18.2k
23
2
30

The Birth of a Size Queen

I wanted it, and I got it.

by pdiddyd55 in Gay Male 02/26/2024
H
4.73
18k
43
4
72

First Night Seduction Ch. 03

The seduction continues.

by S_Isemen in Gay Male 07/13/2019
H
4.71
17.9k
12
5
15

Alpha Bear on Campus Ch. 03

John and President May form a father/son bond.

by johngus22 in Gay Male 11/27/2020
H
4.66
17.6k
22
6
25

A Drunken Encounter

After a bad breakup, a co-worker eases my tension.

by HenrySeldon in Gay Male 01/27/2024
4.01
17.2k
8
1
20

Escape Room for Jocks Pt. 06

The jocks their weaknesses are again tested.

by MrSunshineBoy in Gay Male 10/25/2020
H
4.6
17k
24
2
32

Escape Room for Jocks Pt. 05

The race continues.

by MrSunshineBoy in Gay Male 09/27/2020
4.46
16.9k
23
4
32

Trust Ch. 03

A gay man falls in love with a straight one.

by Elenia26 in Gay Male 08/14/2013
H
4.59
16.7k
22
0
24

Unexpected Swimming Lesson

My mistress wanted me to publish me most recurring fantasy.

by Submissiveness in Gay Male 06/07/2017
4.02
16.6k
2
1
4
0

A Cock in the Hand Ch. 08

Straight man turned gay cock-whore accepts his new role.

by rimaday in Gay Male 09/03/2023
H
4.74
16.6k
18
5
30

Shady Pines Ch. 01: Prologue

Sean takes the plunge with Sam.

by AgirlcalledBob in Gay Male 10/09/2018
H
4.53
16.5k
15
0
34

No Longer a Show Ch. 01

Straight live cam guy tries first gay blowjob to make cash.

by CinaedeFuri in Gay Male 01/22/2021
3.92
16.1k
21
3
35

Ch. 05 Unexpected Weekend

Fucked like a girl.

by Jamie_1 in Transgender & Crossdressers 05/20/2023
H
4.77
15.8k
16
6
25
0

Just for You

An Oral Fantasy.

by sj_53 in Gay Male 12/11/2016
H
4.58
15.7k
4
1
4

A Favour Ch. 04

Josh returns after a trip away.

by BluePill in Gay Male 01/28/2020
H
4.67
15.5k
26
10
42

The Deviant Girls Go Wild Pt. 03

The girls give the two remaining boys an lesson in slutdom.

by Obobby in Group Sex 02/02/2020
4.45
14.9k
11
1
18

Escape Room for Jocks Pt. 09

One new game, two more team mates, one winner.

by MrSunshineBoy in Gay Male 03/01/2021
H
4.51
14.7k
18
5
25

Poppy

Young questioning man falls for older fem.

by ophanim in Gay Male 11/18/2019
H
4.63
14.6k
15
2
26
0

Back to the Bay

Adrian finds love in a small town after living in London.

by sjreardon in Gay Male 05/13/2021
H
4.77
14.5k
32
11
58
0

What Did I Lose Ch. 01

A young college student wants to lose his V card... but not.

by Virginny in Gay Male 05/28/2021
4.07
14.1k
18
4
29
0

Ready for My Close-Up

Jake and Ethan's movie scene rehearsal goes off-script.

by QuickYellowFox in Gay Male 03/01/2024
H
4.85
14k
31
6
57
0

Jess' Fantasy Ch. 02

Billy comes over to another house party at Jess' and Dylan's.

by Bluebird8991 in Gay Male 05/08/2021
H
4.64
13.8k
38
2
58

Wild Camping

Ramon and Dan were gay virgins until they camped out.

by Dannyboy23 in First Time 05/04/2023
4.3
13.7k
5
1
9
0

The New Guy Ch. 02

Part two of a guy earning some experience.

by Verified in Gay Male 04/13/2012
4.4
13.6k
8
3
9

Summer Switch Ch. 05b

BFFs (1F 2M) give Cole (M) his first gay sexual experience.

by qchickie in Group Sex 06/21/2021
H
4.69
13.6k
5
1
11

Recollections of My First Ch. 02

After wiping off my face, the night continues...

by T00M in Gay Male 08/21/2022
H
4.84
13.6k
27
8
39

In Consequence of Danny

Memories of that first time with Danny.

by alexcarr in Gay Male 06/17/2013
3.67
13.5k
0
4
1
0

Nevermore Ch. 01

A Buck's Party at a Virtual Reality club.

by BluePill in Gay Male 06/10/2020
H
4.69
13.3k
25
3
56

Our First Meeting

A first-person imaging of what a first time might be like.

by txwill85 in Gay Male 02/06/2016
4.33
13.2k
8
1
10

Oslo

An unusual adventure when I was a young man.

by NorwegianLars in Gay Male 07/16/2021
4.1
12.9k
4
1
9

A Hot White Mess Pt. 02

Alex seeks relief at the beach but then Steve appears.

by Gorev_Reighl in Gay Male 08/30/2016
4.13
12.9k
9
4
11

Back to Back Pt. 09

Thanksgiving break Part Two.

by TurbulenceAhead in Gay Male 04/12/2023
4.47
12.8k
28
133
38

No Longer a Show Ch. 02

Straight cam dude meets IRL for first gay anal sex.

by CinaedeFuri in Gay Male 01/23/2021
4.33
12.8k
21
3
24

Summer Switch Ch. 05c

BFFs (1F, 3 "straight" M) explore first gay sex experiences.

by qchickie in Group Sex 07/01/2021
H
4.81
12.7k
7
2
22

Long Weekends Pt. 02

The weekend fun continues for the cousins and a friend.

by notacrobat in Gay Male 04/26/2020
4.3
12.7k
12
2
25

Escape Room for Jocks Pt. 10

The Jocks are getting intimate with two more teammates.

by MrSunshineBoy in Gay Male 08/12/2021
H
4.67
12.6k
19
8
29

My Life With Rose Ch. 04

A friend of Rose's stops by to take my picture.

by thespeck in Gay Male 10/29/2012
4.37
12.6k
4
2
4

Coby Pt. 01

An 18yr suburban teen has thoughts; experiments with thoughts.

by etiennesurlaplage in Gay Male 08/29/2023
H
4.72
12.3k
15
2
36
0

Leaving HS with a Bang

Best friends trade BJs in the HS theatre.

by Mjolnir22 in Gay Male 12/05/2023
H
4.5
12k
18
5
26
0

Back to Back Pt. 06

A camping trip and a realization.

by TurbulenceAhead in Gay Male 08/28/2022
H
4.87
12k
23
40
32

Summer Switch Ch. 05a

Four BFFs (3M, 1F) explore beyond their previous sexualities.

by qchickie in Group Sex 06/18/2021
H
4.81
11.9k
6
3
14

Blake's Coming Out Pt. 05

Blake submits to Linc, Vinh, Park, Jae, Jung and Lee at once.

by ComingOutStrong in Gay Male 07/16/2021
H
4.67
11.8k
11
0
18

The Eyes of Acceptance Ch. 01

Scared boy learns a painful truth about himself.

by KaseyLegs in Transgender & Crossdressers 01/02/2021
4.21
11.6k
18
8
24

Ch. 04 Unexpected Weekend

Seduced into the bedroom.

by Jamie_1 in Transgender & Crossdressers 05/19/2023
H
4.76
11.5k
13
4
14
0

Insatiable Rob & Eric Ch. 08

Rob and Eric help Jay with his needs.

by insatiablerob8 in Gay Male 04/03/2017
H
4.59
11.4k
6
1
7

The Seed was Planted...

My first step in my sexual realization.

by Daxdenny11 in Group Sex 07/16/2023
4.16
11.2k
11
3
30
0

The Blond Man's Gaze

The man in the bathroom won't stop staring. Neither can I.

by PercyPopham in Gay Male 08/18/2023
4.49
11.2k
17
9
36
0

First Night Seduction Pt. 02 Ch. 03

Who's really top?!

by S_Isemen in Gay Male 08/13/2019
H
4.9
11k
8
5
16

The Outback Ch. 03

Neel and Dean explore the shift in power dynamics.

by BluePill in Gay Male 12/06/2023
H
4.93
10.8k
21
6
27

Ch. 06 Unexpected Weekend

Giving myself to a man.

by Jamie_1 in Transgender & Crossdressers 05/21/2023
H
4.77
10.7k
8
7
13
0

Unexpected Item

(but not in the bagging area...)

by sjreardon in Gay Male 08/17/2023
H
4.8
10.7k
13
9
29
0

Blake's Coming Out Pt. 04

A game of truth or dare in the spa.

by ComingOutStrong in Gay Male 07/15/2021
H
4.59
10.6k
10
0
19

Curious for Something New...

Where do you go late in life to explore new boundaries?

by CuriousToSuck in Gay Male 06/19/2023
4.4
10k
9
11
19
0

Back to Back Pt. 03

Artie starts to accept and Miles continues to deny.

by TurbulenceAhead in Gay Male 05/29/2022
H
4.75
9.9k
13
19
20

A Fantasy Becomes Reality

A personal ad helps a young man’s fantasy become a reality.

by bisex508 in Gay Male 04/29/2023
H
4.51
9.8k
8
1
14

The Mr. Larry Chronicles: Neil Pt. 01

Mr. Larry teaches Neil about his needs.

by Tentacles_Fun_Grrl in Anal 10/31/2022
4.27
9.8k
6
2
6

First Night Seduction Ch. 04

Theo and Adrien enjoy even more of each other's company.

by S_Isemen in Gay Male 07/21/2019
H
4.78
9.7k
8
4
14

Magical Enchantment

A warlock finds his powerful soulmate.

by SkylerLuv in Gay Male 10/27/2022
H
4.9
9.7k
4
2
25
0

First Night Seduction Pt. 02 Ch. 01

Time moves on for Theo & Adrien - but the passion remains.

by S_Isemen in Gay Male 08/04/2019
H
4.79
9.5k
5
3
9
Active tags
Active tags
first time gay
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ
Related Tags
Show More