‘gay first time’ stories

My first time losing my anal virginity to a 9 in cock.

A married guy has his first experience.

A straight man discovers he may be a submissive cocksucker.

Waking up at the Coleman house continues the adventure.

Straight man gets put down by a monster...and loves it.

Chapter by chapter of my experiences with older men.

A colleague finally gets to seduce you.

Girlfriend's cocky bro dominates me in every way.

A gay guy and a straight guy walk into a club.

Jon explores a side of him he didn't know he had.

Straight married man discovers a new side to his life.

Panty wearing man returns to lose his virginity.

19-year-old college student gets a massage.

Older brother becomes his first sex toy.

His turn getting water pumped in the hot tub.

College guy has his first gay experience.

Married man ventures onto building site.

Todd surely wasn't a boy anymore.

Two horny roommates help each other with a mutual problem.

Finding my boyfriend's dildo leads to even bigger secrets.

19-year-old guy shares a hotel room with a 60-year-old man.

Man has affair with wife's boyfriend.

The story of my first time with another guy.

An unsuspecting traveler gets a massage he won't forget.

A young man finally gives in to his bicuriousity.

Two straight football coaches fuck during rained out game.

A brother and sister begin a sexual summer adventure.

College guy first discovers the pleasures of gay sex.

Friends take NFL betting to new extremes.

Straight males have gay sex.

Muscle hunk gets violated by Mexican officers.

19-year-old has his first gay experience in a movie theater.

Young man discovers his cousin - and penis.

A memorable, fantasy-fulfilling 18th birthday.

She wants to see him with another man.

Staying with a straight friend in a studio apartment.

I wondered what it would feel like to be fucked in the ass.

Horse-hung roommate dominates me in private and public.

First time gay in a public college bathroom.

John gets a choice: get raped, or allow it.

Josh plays Cupid to two formerly straight guys.

Second honeymoon expands couple's horizons.

Straight man turns roommate gay.

Their seduction revealed his bisexual nature.

First and second experience with an older man.

A college nobody gets his ass fucked.

Dad wonders about his son's strange doctor's appointment.

Bi-guy surprises his straight buddy.

A roommate experience broadens his horizons.

Straight man discovers a lust for cock.

College guy's fantasy becomes reality.

How a trusted friend takes advantage.

The first full time.

A married man learns about glory holes.

Son loses his virginity.

Alex slides further into submission.

A young man is opened up by two older men...

Two straight male roommates go camping and explore bi-sex.

What can happen when browsing in a bookshop.

An ex-girlfriend tricks man into threesome with another guy.

First time in prison for spoiled jock.

How receptive athletes are seduced at team physicals.

Straight boy can't stop thinking about cock, gets surprise.

Mature male finds gay lifestyle.

What it took to open up the world of bi-sex to him.

Nervous Newbie tries BJ and anal.

Joe's cock was in-demand; soon he could buy wire cutters.

A video viewing leads friends on a bi adventure.

Student gets his first taste of cock.

Man at gym finds something fun in the lockers.

His introduction to gay sex.

Injured guy gets a little help from another man.

A crossdresser's coming of age.

Naughty 18-year-old boys get caught by headmaster.

Zack is traded to the minors and his wife doesn't like it.

Naked modeling session shifts power dynamics in our dormroom.

Richard finally realizes he needs to be cuckold.

Dave and Steve explore each other further.

Curious male finds his release through gay anal.

Two men explore their bisexuality.

Park Ranger initiates seeking first timer.

He loved women, but desired men too.

Waking up to a whole new beginning.

Meredith guides you along your first homosexual experience.

Paul learns my identity and uses that to his advantage.

An older man's first bisexual experience is an interracial one.

Ken's breakup leads to learning about sex from two older men.

Two firemen discover a new & exciting bond.

A drunk college student stumbles into a whole new world.

Friendship between two guys turns sexual.

Curious guy gets his first taste of man at conference.

Old friends experiment in the school showers.

Anal Sex With a Black Tranny in L.A.

Curiosity gets the better of a married couple.

Dominant Boss initiates new employee.

There was more on offer than just dinner on a plate.

Straight guy loses wager to gay friend.

Jordan finds a way to communicate with his deaf friend Kevin

While waiting for the roommate to take interest.

A visit to a porno theatre gets hot.