‘gay first time’ stories

A young straight guy is forced to obey him.

Girlfriend's dad and boyfriend share the back seat.

18-year-old boy is taken by older neighbor.

Girlfriend uses her boyfriend for gay erotica shoot.

Wife teaches Hubby new tricks.

Two straight guys get surprisingly horny in the Jacuzzi.

Kinky wife wants to see her husband suck on a cock.

Two guys discover their orientation isn't what they thought.

Two, straight best friends make some discoveries.

Straight guy watches porn tapes that are not what they seem.

Girl uses boyfriend to negotiate for gym membership.

Friend's professional father helps with pulled muscles.

Straight married man is seduced by his best friend.

War changes Will's life--can Lucas help him live again?

Friend catches him wearing his girlfriend's lingerie bottoms.

A happily married couple both submit to her Dom ex-lover.

The guys take Ecstasy and a wild night unfolds.

He got caught... she got even.

Straight married man can't resist black teen's huge cock.

Drunk straight guy goes to gay bar by accident and is turned.

Seeing a big black cock in sauna turns straight married man.

I thought I was in love... then I met her little brother.

Neighbor turns a married man bi.

Straight roommates get horny after St. Paddy Day barhopping.

Father and son bond while mom's away!

Braden's back at the Coleman household for 4th of July party.

Straight father submits himself and family to black teen.

Seduced at my apartment gym.

Straight guy discovers a sex app that changes his life.

Straight married man submits to a young stranger at airport.

A straight drunk guy submits to his roommate...twice!

A straight man is drawn into the world of black submission.

Finding my boyfriend's dildo leads to even bigger secrets.

An older man takes a willing first timer all the way.

A widowed army major falls for his former brother in law.

One man witnesses the fall of men & women to a BBC teen…

A straight college guy becomes a submissive cocksucker.

Straight man discovers anal pleasure with two men and a bet.

Two straight guys trapped in the snow do what they must.

Spring break drugs lead to first time gay sex.

Walt is intrigued by the black man helping out at church.

A straight white football player submits to black roommate.

Wild date ends at a glory hole.

A neighborhood jog leads to first time magic.

Couple live out bisexual fantasies with dominant BLACK teens.

Cocky rival dominates me on a backpacking trip.

A wife is convinced to try swinging to save her marriage.

Stoned and getting fucked for the first time.

Alone in a tent, a close friend takes him completely.

A first time with a black shemale goddess.

Mom's tits leads to me becoming a cocksucker and bottom.

His first gay experienced is forced.

Conclusion: It's not 2 men & labels. It's 2 hearts & love.

High school twink gets dominated by ripped farm-hand.

Spoiled narcissist hates his macho football jock roommate.

College roommates become fuck buddies after first mansex.

Josh plays Cupid to two formerly straight guys.

Amazing what joy a little misunderstanding can bring.

Husband discovers the thrill of an Alpha Male.

Straight teacher is turned by two ex-students.

Straight guy loses a bet at a gay bar.

Waking up at the Coleman house continues the adventure.

A black stud learns white boys are great bottoms.

Jordan finds a way to communicate with his deaf friend Kevin

Two straight friends get dared to try something new.

Straight guy decides being a bottom is where it's at.

Straight man's interview includes taking cock in both holes.

Jaded and defensive Win finds love with a control freak.

Straight shy guy walks into an adult theatre in late 1980's.

Gay stud's hobby is turning straight guys.

Married white man submits to big black dom boss.

White boy meets black man.

Straight man is forced to crossdress and suck cock.

Mountain man takes city boy.

A young man is opened up by two older men...

Straight guy experiences a little madness of his own.

Dad and Mom seduce their 18-year-old son into having bisex.

A night drinking with a friend turns into something else.

Straight married man sucks his first cock & becomes addicted.

Girlfriend's cocky bro dominates me in every way.

Husband is surprised when he & wife share a man.

Sister achieves goal of getting hung brother to fuck ass.

Seduced by an older man.

Scotty submits to an older man he meets at the movies.

My girlfriend made me suck cock for the first time.

Colleague takes advantage of intimate procedure.

LA cop finds love where he least expects it.

Dad wonders about his son's strange doctor's appointment.

Straight guy attends his gay friend's bachelor party.

A joke between roommates goes a bit too far.

Daniel gets abducted.

Joe's roommate Russ is a walking wet dream, and he knows it.

Sorting dorm's mail leads to biggest and best man on campus.

College roommates discover the ultimate in male bonding.

Two straight football coaches fuck during rained out game.

Horse-hung roommate dominates me in private and public.

Brother turns little brother into a man.

Straight married man is turned by younger black colleague.

Tommy plays dress-up and gets caught by his neighbor.

He's blackmailed into sucking his first cock.