Try the free LITEROTICA WEBCAMS!

‘gay first time’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
gay first time 

Category

Sort by:
ViewsRatingFavoriteNewest
7 Days30 DaysAll Time

Flower Shop

Dominant Boss initiates new employee.

by newbitime in Gay Male 06/13/2009
H
4.61
116k
99
12
118
0

My Neighbor the Cop

Neighbor turns a married man bi.

by tonyl65 in Gay Male 06/09/2012
H
4.61
432.3k
522
45
656

Genuine First Timer

Jim places an ad online to worship a stranger's cock.

by 1077ad in Gay Male 01/18/2011
H
4.61
72.5k
28
10
41
0

Don't Ask Don't Tell

He would do anything to get out of being drafted.

by kicky1000 in Gay Male 11/15/2006
H
4.61
90.2k
78
9
81
0

Black Daddy at the Y Pt. 04

Preacher Takes a Boy.

by RandyScottsdale in Gay Male 12/02/2021
H
4.61
21k
16
2
21

Dominated By Wrestling Rival Pt. 02

Losing wrestler pays the price.

by somebody123 in Gay Male 02/26/2021
H
4.61
62k
105
16
142

Neighbor Ch. 04

I take Daddy and Eric's morning wood instruction.

by SluttyBisexualGuy in Gay Male 04/02/2021
H
4.61
82.3k
143
38
205

The Price of Her Peach

He can fuck her ass, but first...

by KenJames in Gay Male 08/26/2021
H
4.61
36.4k
45
3
73
0

Greg Ch. 02

Greg explains.

by ryanuk1971 in Gay Male 01/24/2011
H
4.6
25.3k
0
2
0

Assuming the Position Ch. 01

Bi-curious man finds a top man.

by bi golly in Gay Male 04/22/2011
H
4.6
168.6k
79
29
95
0

Bobby in the Bar Ch. 02

Never go up to a man's room.

by aibean in Gay Male 01/18/2012
H
4.6
102.4k
66
7
68

Cross Country

PE lesson turns into lessons of an altogether different type.

by UK_Dreamer in Gay Male 05/25/2012
H
4.6
84.8k
44
9
54
0

Road Trip

We Share Our Hottest & Wildest Adventures On A Long Drive.

by Rob_McCall4 in Gay Male 07/27/2023
H
4.6
18.7k
15
3
40
0

Girl for Charlie

Unexpected gay visitor gives him a chance to dress up.

by Jamie_in_dresses in Transgender & Crossdressers 12/28/2012
H
4.6
88.4k
81
16
103

Straight No More

Drunk straight guy goes to gay bar by accident and is turned.

by silkstockingslover in Gay Male 03/21/2013
H
4.6
595.9k
602
66
827

Mountain Men Ch. 02: Schooled

His first anal with a wild mountain man.

by KenJames in Gay Male 02/01/2020
H
4.6
28.7k
18
5
31

Nova's Journey

An orphan learns the consequences of her rescue.

by OnlyATest in Lesbian Sex 05/19/2014
H
4.6
60.6k
66
14
81

My Straight Roommate

Joe's roommate Russ is a walking wet dream, and he knows it.

by kerrymcboyd in Gay Male 08/12/2017
H
4.6
180.2k
195
20
289

Swim Team Ch. 11 - Baptism

Bret joins Michael at church, ending up at the Dad's loft.

by FINLEYDIXON in Gay Male 01/16/2022
H
4.6
6.1k
6
3
16

Awakening

A straight man discovers he may be a submissive cocksucker.

by up4anything0849 in Gay Male 07/01/2019
H
4.6
139.1k
138
47
176

The Nightclub

Fucked for the first time by a stranger on the dancefloor.

by Forbiddenpleasures in Gay Male 12/31/2021
H
4.6
58.1k
113
10
173
0

The General's Kid

Training a teenage recruit.

by KenJames in Gay Male 02/09/2022
H
4.6
24.5k
24
4
45
0

A Cruising Life Ch. 02

Finally sucking my first cock.

by tommydntx in Gay Male 05/03/2020
H
4.6
23.6k
24
4
26

Slutty Sleepover

Two, straight best friends make some discoveries.

by SluttyBisexualGuy in Gay Male 10/27/2017
H
4.6
879.5k
1.2k
85
1.6k

Bookstore Lessons

Young man comes to see pictures, but gets the real thing.

by kneelsoften in Gay Male 01/26/2008
H
4.6
141.3k
67
28
77
0

My Weekend with Jake

A personal ad that worked.

by j3zza in Gay Male 02/11/2009
H
4.6
72.1k
14
14
28
0

Showers

Don gets some help in the shower.

by bi golly in Gay Male 01/01/2008
H
4.6
159.7k
66
13
78
0

Friday Night in the Sauna

A bisexual MMF threesome in the gym's sauna.

by BlackHat39 in Group Sex 10/28/2007
H
4.6
210.2k
91
20
127
0

Forced Ch. 02

The errors of his ways.

by nickymartin in Gay Male 09/17/2007
H
4.6
258.7k
106
12
119

An Old Friend Ch. 03

Final chapter: two old friends explore the bi-side.

by jjdtx in Gay Male 08/31/2006
H
4.6
47k
16
4
18

Bobby

Young Midwesterner explores a big-city porno theater.

by Dormrat in Gay Male 02/24/2006
H
4.6
166.8k
69
0
87

The Other Side of the Island

Tourist neutralizes his guilt on a Caribbean island.

by sr71plt in Gay Male 08/11/2006
0
70.2k
22
8
31
0

Dominated in Jamaica Ch. 01

A chance meeting witha couple led to self discovery.

by HerLittlePiggy in Gay Male 01/08/2008
H
4.59
174.7k
97
0
122

Straight No More: Getting Ahead

Straight man's interview includes taking cock in both holes.

by silkstockingslover in Gay Male 07/09/2014
H
4.59
267.1k
251
34
323

Surprise Sexual Awakening

A sleepy, horny straight guy is easily seduced.

by JJ79cbab in Gay Male 10/26/2014
H
4.59
166.4k
150
26
179
0

Unexpected Awakening

Married guy finds his bi side when wife's back is turned.

by Jamie_in_dresses in Gay Male 02/04/2015
H
4.59
104.3k
68
19
82
0

Taken in His Own House

John is set upon by a pair of burglars.

by RaulBloodworth in Gay Male 02/11/2016
H
4.59
91.5k
145
22
178
0

Zara's Closet

Vacationing brothers find pleasure in sharing a bed.

by Jamie_in_dresses in Gay Male 06/12/2018
H
4.59
84.3k
70
2
122
0

Saying Hello to Bi

A knock on the door leads to an intense afternoon experience.

by RascalRick in Gay Male 01/07/2022
H
4.59
56.1k
28
11
55

Coming Out Strong

Bad break-up to first gay hook-up.

by tayphala in Gay Male 03/29/2017
H
4.59
52.3k
24
12
37
0

College Visit Goes Wrong Pt. 01

College senior humiliated by big-dicked teen.

by somebody123 in Gay Male 09/10/2022
H
4.59
67.6k
122
16
222

The Training Session

Two guys help each other out at a training session.

by hot2spear in Gay Male 06/09/2021
H
4.59
31.4k
24
10
51

First Cum Swallow

Swallowed my first load.

by garyr43 in Gay Male 06/14/2018
H
4.59
238.6k
61
108
81
0

My Wife's Hot Cousin Ch. 09

Straight married men spend a couple of days naked in nature!

by funandbold in Gay Male 04/14/2018
H
4.59
29.6k
21
4
31

Working Out Issues Ch. 03

Mel gets more comfortable with his body.

by blake1 in Transgender & Crossdressers 02/25/2019
H
4.59
22.3k
24
10
27

The Game of Hockey - 750

Young hockey player reconnects with twink he met growing up.

by JamiePlynth in Gay Male 02/12/2024
H
4.59
5.5k
6
3
10
0

When the Ball Drops...

Jamie and Morris go missing on NYE

by Grayson87 in Gay Male 01/04/2024
H
4.59
4k
7
3
15
0

Old Jack

Seduced by an older man.

by exaucer in Gay Male 08/24/2012
H
4.59
283.2k
214
19
279

The New Slave Ch. 01

Daniel gets abducted.

by martin_x59 in Gay Male 08/09/2011
H
4.59
182.7k
200
21
263

First Gay Experience

Anal Sex With a Black Tranny in L.A.

by Friske_one1 in Transgender & Crossdressers 06/01/2011
H
4.59
117k
65
14
73
0

Cumming Out

David explores his sexuality with other men.

by Many Feathers in Gay Male 03/01/2009
H
4.59
93.7k
36
7
43
0

Best Friend, First Time

A gay first time.

by jwy12 in Gay Male 04/20/2009
H
4.59
227.4k
85
26
100
0

Barbarian Initiation

The great barbarian shows another side.

by sabb in Gay Male 03/14/2008
H
4.59
80.8k
26
1
35
0

Pretty Emo Boys Kissing Ch. 03

The title grows increasingly inaccurate.

by Nothinglikethesun in Gay Male 09/09/2009
H
4.59
62.5k
19
11
19

Discovering Boys Ch. 04

Jake wakes up the morning after, and finds Matt.

by imp22 in Gay Male 11/23/2023
H
4.58
6.2k
4
1
11

DJ Pt. 05

DJ/Jamie get ready to start college Doug tries to adopt DJ.

by o2byoung in Gay Male 10/30/2017
H
4.58
6k
3
1
3

Erik and Charles

Charles Xavier and Erik Lehnsherr, from X-Men: First Class.

by flying_monkey in Gay Male 07/11/2011
H
4.58
19.2k
15
7
16
0

His True Self

A lonely straight guy discovers what he really craves.

by readandreact in Gay Male 04/17/2014
H
4.58
105.4k
81
18
106
0

Getting Back on My Feet Ch. 01

A newly divorced man finds a new roommate.

by Shybicuriousguy in Gay Male 04/23/2022
H
4.58
39.9k
35
7
65

The All Blacks

Rugby fan gets more than post-game autographs.

by Forbiddenpleasures in Gay Male 01/26/2022
H
4.58
28.4k
66
5
106
0

Vacation Pt. 02

Story of Micheal's adventure from the waiter's point of view.

by hockeyfan2 in Gay Male 06/02/2021
H
4.58
11.5k
10
5
14

The Pirate and the General

My true accounting of how I became a pirate.

by OregonDavid in Gay Male 01/11/2010
H
4.58
24.2k
10
1
12
0

A Learning Experience

A guy thinks he is curious; finds out he is a whore.

by allsdude in Gay Male 04/10/2017
H
4.58
86.5k
80
17
111

The Fallen Ch. 04

Full Moon brings out inner desires.

by Acacia_wolf in Gay Male 03/25/2013
H
4.58
9.9k
9
4
9

Straight Turner: A Philosophy

Gay stud's hobby is turning straight guys.

by silkstockingslover in Gay Male 12/17/2014
H
4.58
204.5k
245
35
333
0

Surprise Encounter Ch. 02

The unexpected happens.

by Bottom_up in BDSM 10/05/2012
H
4.58
27.7k
8
5
10

Straight Through - Paul and Brandon

A straight guy wonders... but will he find out?

by MJRoberts in Gay Male 03/31/2014
H
4.58
75.2k
62
18
78
0

Picking the First Fruit

The first-plucked summer peach is the highest prize.

by sr71plt in Gay Male 08/21/2012
H
4.58
56.6k
22
7
27
0

Myth of Masculinity

Straight young married guy begins a journey of realization.

by JacobGoody in Gay Male 09/16/2016
H
4.58
73.3k
44
7
60
0

How I Became Gay

Super-curious man learns he's a gay bottom.

by GerardW in Gay Male 06/23/2008
H
4.58
169.2k
64
0
92
0

Halftime

A widower dabbles in gay sex.

by AnotherDay in Gay Male 03/30/2013
H
4.58
71.8k
45
12
51
0

My First Time

A young man finally gives in to his bicuriousity.

by MurderTrain in Gay Male 08/08/2014
H
4.58
132.8k
37
15
48
0

Uncovering Repressed Desires Ch. 01

Friend's cock lingers in his thoughts, comes out as husband.

by fitfidelityfifty64 in Gay Male 04/20/2021
H
4.57
24.3k
25
4
54

My Initiation

How I lost my gay virginity. The hard way.

by lockedupslut in Gay Male 09/09/2009
H
4.57
233.3k
101
18
142
0

Straight Teacher Turned

Straight teacher is turned by two ex-students.

by silkstockingslover in Gay Male 09/24/2014
H
4.57
224.7k
264
28
349
0

Caught Ch. 02

Two friends wonder about Saturday.

by mikec1010 in Gay Male 04/20/2006
H
4.57
69.8k
25
7
28

Bobby and the Jock

When Bobby met college jock Bo.

by robcub32 in Gay Male 04/19/2010
H
4.57
164k
142
25
172
0

The Cavern

A fantasy finally fulfilled.

by DomRick in Gay Male 03/24/2006
H
4.57
47.7k
10
7
13
0

Mac and Me Ch. 02

Joe returns the favor and more.

by literalvirgin in Gay Male 02/14/2017
H
4.57
32k
17
3
17

Yellow Ch. 03

Two men really find each other in this chapter.

by ElonaHunter in Gay Male 07/22/2006
H
4.57
28k
3
2
3

Tales of a Cock Slave #74

Fun with hot, hung, aggressive Afghan bodybuilders.

by dprb65 in Gay Male 01/20/2021
4.57
3.7k
000

Turning Queer in Ibiza Ch. 01

Mickey finds new experiences on vacation.

by atticus10 in Gay Male 11/07/2008
H
4.57
37.3k
18
2
20

Believe Me Nora Ch. 01

A bi-sexual couple explore pregnant sex options.

by jackredd in Fetish 08/17/2012
H
4.57
35.3k
9
0
14

Shutter Click

70s Punk picks up a Teacher.

by Tom Collins in Gay Male 01/07/2006
H
4.57
43.8k
13
12
15
0

Dive

Tom's world suddenly gets a whole lot bigger.

by BobbyLaker in Gay Male 11/28/2023
H
4.57
12.9k
7
2
17

Block Party

A very fun block party that ends with an older man.

by Triplebottom in Gay Male 10/01/2018
H
4.57
77.9k
110
14
149
0

Amber's New Job Ch. 04

It's not all work: falling in love and time for revenge.

by MaryAnderson in Interracial Love 11/06/2014
H
4.57
39.8k
21
4
33

Brothers in Arms

A different sort of love story during the American Civil War.

by robertreams in Gay Male 09/28/2012
H
4.57
46.1k
33
5
39

Gotta Love Commuting

College guy's fantasy becomes reality.

by HornyTeenBoy in Gay Male 10/20/2006
H
4.57
125.6k
31
12
41
0

Old School, New Lessons

Old fantasies die hard when you go back to school.

by LeathermanCraig in Gay Male 05/16/2009
H
4.57
42.4k
14
4
20
0

When My Teen Cousins Came

Teen twin cousins play with me and my trans wife.

by jasperray in Incest/Taboo 12/13/2020
H
4.57
63.3k
106
5
186
0

Andy

His inner desires are met.

by silverace1 in Gay Male 02/28/2006
H
4.57
50.4k
12
5
18
0

The Dinner Party

There was more on offer than just dinner on a plate.

by Timkitten in Group Sex 03/10/2006
H
4.56
116k
19
3
40
0

My Time With Char Pt. 04

My first boyfriend.

by SamanthaMeyers in Gay Male 09/24/2021
H
4.56
5.3k
1
1
1

First Lust: First Love

18-year-old twink loses his cherry & falls in love.

by danielblue in Gay Male 03/16/2010
H
4.56
142.8k
32
0
45
0

The Photo Shop Ch. 15

A painful day at the beauty parlor and a photoshoot.

by candyman666 in Erotic Couplings 03/18/2021
H
4.56
7.2k
3
0
5

Cairo Surrender Ch. 05-06

Michael opens to Abazar's seduction.

by KeithD in Gay Male 06/11/2019
H
4.56
11.8k
8
0
9

Growing Up Hung Pt. 02

Straight college guy's first time fucking his new cocksucker.

by funandbold in Gay Male 05/22/2018
H
4.56
82.4k
73
4
106

Another Prison Story

White boy meets black man.

by frezrevup in Gay Male 09/02/2011
H
4.56
366.4k
243
31
314
0

Nobody Has to Know

He sucks a dick to win back his girl as she plays along.

by Archer2050 in Group Sex 12/12/2008
H
4.56
228.8k
167
30
215
0
1...34567...16
Active tags
Active tags
gay first time
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ
Related Tags
Show More