‘shy’ stories

Shy honors student lusts after the twins next door.

Clay bonds with his shy daughter by showing her how to fuck.

Two single mothers try out new living arrangements.

Mike inherits an old house with fuckable monster girls!

Dana hid herself away.

Brother and sister start their journey of discovery.

Can Andrew survive the pacific northwest?

She went just to watch but ended up well fucked.

Nerd gets powers to cause pleasure and starts his harem.

A very shy wife makes husband's fantasy come true.

Shy, innocent teen is corrupted by her family and friends.

Diana wakes up between Brendan and Ian.

Bored, he takes advantage of his shy drunk cousin.

A hypnotized college girl finds something more.

They include another man with unintended consequences.

Dana hid herself away. James found her.

Sue visits my shed for a second time.

Cute Korean girl turns out to be something of a tease.

A girl learns about her two twin-sister friends secret.

Katie goes to great lengths to keep her secret from Nick

Conservative school teacher gradually loses her inhibitions.

A shy girl stays in a motel with her closest friend.

College guy & his mother reenact an incest scene.

From my shed to my bedroom, another first.

Shy mom and son find love after dad passes away.

Several men take advantage of a shy Asian wife.

She visits my shed to retrieve her panties.

Some fun nakey and sexy times in a clothing store.

Her roommate admits she has to masturbate five times a day.

Full Figured college girl meets tall, dark, and HOT.

I'm feeling shy at a party. And then I meet David.

Shy Mia wants to be taught by an older man.

How a young shy housewife found a new profession.

Clark has always had a thing for the shy girls.

Best friends find they both want something more.

Shy Carol's first erotic album gift for husband Greg.

He nudges his conservative wife to become naughtier.

A shy wife is convinced to bare it all on a nude beach.

A Young Man Discovers Unlikely Family Traditions.

Succumbing to experienced older man.

A boy moves in with hot aunt and her three daughters.

Shy college girl finds a sleeping older man.

Landon meets a small, skittish girl.

A big brother takes his teasy sister.

Samantha discovers that she's an exhibitionist.

A shy wife continues her adventures with other men.

Workmen watch as a young modest wife gets a tan all over.

His first girl takes his virginity.

Mark sets his sights on his roommate's shy girlfriend.

Sexy student teases teacher to his breaking point.

Edain is forced by a stranger in her stable.

Young, shy, innocent, Vietnamese wife tries new things.

Jake really likes his roommate's shy girlfriend.

My wife having sex with other men for the first time.

Brother and sister continue affair and bring in a friend.

Shy Carol's second erotic album for husband Greg.

Coed works her way through school hosting lingerie parties.

A short trip changes a once shy wife into an exhibitionist.

A quiet wife is urged to have sex with an older man.

Reserved Indian's first experience with his mother.

Widowed father of three meets the young school nurse.

Tired and horny nurse has fun with pretty latin salesgirl.

Tom and Grace conspire to have John accept their fucking.

Forgetful brother + horny sister = sibling fun.

Young man fulfills old fantasy with family MILF friend.

Aunt regrets stealing his virginity. She makes it right.

Two coed dorm mates swap bodies. Sort of.

Shy wife is seduced into a sexy, impromptu photoshoot.

Brad helps a friend loosen up in the bedroom.

College brother & sister home alone during lockdown.

Lesbian high school coach seduces a shy teen.

Some things are worth waiting for.

Sparks between me and the cute but shy T-girl next door.

Ch 2: A Step-Mom's Enticing Offer.

How I listened, watched, and had sex with Dee in college.

Husband lets stranger use his wife as his own sex toy.

It all starts with a little glimpse into my sister's journal.

Wife is persuaded to relive old times with former boyfriend.

Strict Indian mum continues to masturbate ill son.

A young art teacher is taken out of her sexual comfort zone.

Virgin fiancée gets strip searched in a small town jail.

His sister sets him up with a cheerleader.

Amanda wanted a challenge, Ronny might just be too much.

Our babysitter takes it further than I expected.

Shy and innocent wife trained to crave cock.

Husband watches as wife is forced to get an immigration exam.

Incredible how shy teen becomes a slut.

They talk that evening and have a more intimate encounter.

I discover my power: Donna, Hanna, Samantha.

Most people have a bucket list; I have a fuck It list.

Faith proves to her brother that love is truly blind.

He exposes shy wife to his subordinate from work.

Shy young secretary comes out of her shell.

A Japanese exchange student craves the company of a MILF.

Husband's friend proves a point.

Poker games gone wrong as my shy gf is the prize.

Reserved indian continues with his mother.

Shy wife becomes the prize in a strip poker game.

The quiet ones often have the dirtiest fantasies.

I discover that I am an illegal alien.