‘butt plug’ stories

Active tags
anal (314)bondage (131)spanking (124)dildo (102)bdsm (81)humiliation (69)oral (68)femdom (65)slave (62)anal sex (58)submissive (58)vibrator (56)masturbation (55)lesbian (54)toys (52)blowjob (51)female submissive (48)nipple clamps (48)submission (42)threesome (42)master (40)blow job (39)enema (38)double penetration (37)oral sex (35)punishment (34)strap on (33)panties (32)cum (32)domination (32)male dominant (32)public (31)cunnilingus (29)mistress (29)forced (26)exhibitionism (26)rimming (25)stockings (24)strap-on (24)piss (24)ass (24)wife (23)blindfold (23)collar (23)pegging (23)female masturbation (22)chastity (22)slut (22)exhibitionist (22)fingering (21)fisting (21)blackmail (21)group sex (20)high heels (20)first time (19)orgasm denial (19)male submissive (18)anal play (18)cum eating (18)paddle (18)mdom (17)voyeur (17)teasing (17)strapon (17)sex toys (17)lingerie (16)crossdressing (16)sissy (16)incest (16)creampie (16)forced feminization (15)fetish (15)cock (15)female dominant (15)riding crop (15)shower (14)whipping (14)college (14)maid (14)cfnm (14)corset (14)ball gag (14)control (13)ass play (13)orgasm (13)handcuffs (13)latex (13)public sex (13)big cock (13)redhead (12)big tits (12)asshole (12)cock ring (12)training (12)facial (12)shaved (12)pain (12)dominant (12)light bondage (12)bisexual (11)ffm (11)fsub (11)rough (11)older man (11)cock sucking (11)fellatio (11)d/s (11)couple (11)discipline (11)mature (10)female domination (10)cuckold (10)husband (10)squirting (10)reluctance (10)whore (10)office (10)naked (10)tied (10)heels (10)transexual (10)sub (10)female submission (10)cheating (10)caning (10)second person pov (10)ass licking (10)porn (10)body builder (9)sister (9)rope (9)plug (9)spank (9)cum swallowing (9)mmf (9)gang bang (9)swallow (9)plug ass (9)leather (9)virgin (9)romance (9)pet (9)deep throat (9)degradation (9)feminization (9)tail (8)flogging (8)cane (8)pussy eating (8)orgasm control (8)leash (8)gangbang (8)restraints (8)thong (8)flogger (8)fantasy (8)student (8)daddy (8)hand cuffs (8)pussy (8)anal virgin (8)dirty talk (8)blonde (8)humiliated (8)public humiliation (8)analingus (8)cum slut (8)nipple clamp (7)reluctant (7)domme (7)cbt (7)clamps (7)male domination (7)anal beads (7)cigar (7)male anal (7)older woman (7)nonconsent (7)forced orgasm (7)orgy (7)interracial (7)massage (7)christmas (7)teen (7)outdoors (7)public nudity (7)dominatrix (7)nipple play (7)milf (7)shaved pussy (7)cream pie (7)bound (7)bdsm novella (7)rough sex (7)phone sex (7)hot wife (7)cross dressing (7)gag (7)anal training (7)fem dom (7)transformation (7)brother (6)slave girl (6)paddling (6)consequences (6)smoking fetish (6)teacher (6)younger man (6)vibrators (6)cocksucking (6)boss (6)pregnant (6)stranger (6)huge cock (6)gay (6)mff (6)tied up (6)forced bi (6)group (6)voyeurism (6)anal first time (6)erotic hypnosis (6)gay anal (6)exhibition (6)daughter (6)shaving (6)edging (6)noncon (6)whip (6)ass to mouth (6)bukkake (6)hypnosis (6)switch (5)
butt plug

Jason's Secrets Exposed Ch. 08

Lillie gets involved in her family's depravities.

BDSM 07/21/2016

Butt, It's My Birthday!

With help, Phil talks Danielle into an anal birthday present.

Anal 07/19/2016

Kitten's Ride Home

Kitten surprises master on the way home from work.

BDSM 07/14/2016

Down the Rabbit Hole Ch. 06

Mr. C's plaything is ordered on kinky scavenger hunt.

Gay Male 07/13/2016

The Uncertain Gift

A gift is given but who is it for?

Erotic Couplings 07/07/2016

His Sweet Girl Ch. 07

Tender anal reunion for secretary and her boss.

Anal 07/06/2016

Jason's Secrets Exposed Ch. 06

Marilyn and Alexis delve deeper.

BDSM 07/06/2016

In Flight

Stacy, Stewardess Extraordinaire.

Group Sex 07/05/2016

Fact Checker Ch. 01: Sadie

His new employee changes everything.

BDSM 07/04/2016

My VideoChat Error Ch 06

Denise Prepares Shauna.

NonConsent/Reluctance 06/29/2016

Bacchanal Ch. 04

A business dinner reveals a welcome surprise.

Group Sex 06/22/2016

An Office Memo Ch. 02

A consultant is called in to give an in-depth appraisal.

BDSM 06/11/2016

Jason's Secrets Exposed Ch. 05

Jason's mother tries a cigar, as Marilyn tuns more domme.

BDSM 06/10/2016

Melissa's Ordinary Day Ch. 05

Melissa meets the one behind all that's happened to her.

Transsexuals & Crossdressers 06/03/2016

Miss Erotic Universe

I square off with another porn star for industry supremacy.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 05/29/2016

Wife's Friends Anal Ch. 03

Strapon eating cum exhibition.

Fetish 05/25/2016

Savannah's Day at Work Ch. 02

Savannah's day gets crazier.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 05/24/2016

Marrying Into a Horny Family Ch. 05

The Honeymoon.and Christina's gives up her anal virginity.

Loving Wives 05/22/2016

Melissa's Ordinary Day Ch. 04

Melissa's friend Jessica learns what is really going on.

Transsexuals & Crossdressers 05/20/2016

48 Hours on Blue Bayou Pt. 23: Julie

Please plug my butt.

NonConsent/Reluctance 05/20/2016

Savannah's Day at Work Ch. 01

Having an adventure in the office.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 05/20/2016

Melissa's Ordinary Day Ch. 03

Melissa finds out a little more about what's happening.

Transsexuals & Crossdressers 05/19/2016

Melissa's Ordinary Day Ch. 02

The rest of Melissa's day after she arrives home.

Transsexuals & Crossdressers 05/18/2016

Marital Lease

What do you do after two disastrous divorces?

Loving Wives 05/13/2016

A Dream Comes True

A submissive's dreams are realised.

BDSM 05/11/2016

Melissa's Ordinary Day

It's just another day for a pretty young woman. Or is it?

Transsexuals & Crossdressers 05/10/2016

The White Room (Madison James)

How does Madison stay so wet for you?

BDSM 05/03/2016

Wife's Friends Anal

Wife offers up my ass.

Fetish 04/29/2016

Weekend with Judy Pt. 02

Judy's husband lets her live out yet another fantasy.

BDSM 04/28/2016

Jason's Secrets Exposed Ch. 03

Cigar smoking Wife/Mistress starts to come out.

BDSM 04/22/2016

Jane's Leash Pt. 01

Jane wakes up to find her husband ready to dominate her.

BDSM 04/19/2016

Shoe Slut

A woman breaks her high heel on her way to an important date.

BDSM 04/17/2016

A Week in the Life of a Cumeater Ch. 06

Eating cum, butt plugs, licking assholes.

Fetish 04/10/2016

Tucker's Studio Ch. 18

Marsha has a nice afternoon.

Erotic Couplings 04/10/2016

48 Hours on Blue Bayou Pt. 21: Julie

Ring a Bell for the Bellwether.

NonConsent/Reluctance 04/05/2016

A Week in the Life of a Cumeater Ch. 03

Cum feeding blowjob.

Fetish 04/01/2016

A Week in the Life of a Cumeater Ch. 01

Eating cum for a week.

Fetish 03/30/2016

Kinky Flashing

Flashing naked and eating cum.

Fetish 03/27/2016

Nympho Club Ch. 01

Amanda Brown enters the world of lesbian prostitution.

Lesbian Sex 03/26/2016

Uniques Bachelor Party

Old friend gets unique bachelor party.

Group Sex 03/22/2016

The Liquids Rule Ch. 05

The vaginal cavity is next.

NonConsent/Reluctance 03/20/2016

The Toy Room

Elise finds an intriguing room at a house party.

Toys & Masturbation 03/20/2016

At the Professor's Mercy

She seeks the professor's guidance & dominance.

BDSM 03/11/2016

Cinderella's Submission Ch. 05

Cinderella goes & submits to Royalty.

Erotic Couplings 03/05/2016

Turning Tables

When his proposition threatens her career, she takes control.

Anal 03/02/2016

Siblings Room Switch

New job makes a sister highly motivated for sex.

Incest/Taboo 03/01/2016

The Manse Ch. 03

Mark's first full day at the manse and preparing for service.

Fetish 02/26/2016

I Regret Nothing Pt. 03

What will we do now my sister's husband is home.

Incest/Taboo 02/24/2016

Gangbang Under Supervision

Brooke gets gangbanged at a resort as Ryan runs the show.

Group Sex 02/09/2016

The Start

A domme/sub switch tale.

BDSM 02/05/2016

Company Whore Ch. 02

She accepts her role as company whore.

NonConsent/Reluctance 02/02/2016

The Basketball Team's Bitch Ch. 01

The team's bitch prepares for his gang-bang with the trainer.

Anal 01/29/2016

Testing Ourselves Pt. 02

Should I switch my phone off when I'm drunk?

BDSM 01/13/2016

Lucy Gets Training

Eager sub learns for her Boss.

BDSM 01/12/2016

Filming Porno for my Birthday

He's and arranges a gang bang for his wife for her birthday.

Group Sex 01/10/2016

The Ethical Slutmaker Ch. 10

Tammi and Dan's new babysitter is glad to be of service.

Anal 01/02/2016

Popping My Husband's Cherry

Wife discovers the joys of anal sex - her husband's anus...

Anal 12/31/2015

Mia's Anal Cherry

Mia loses her last cherry to Alex

Anal 12/30/2015

Red Eye

She seduces him into the mile high club.

Erotic Couplings 12/24/2015

Nicole

One Wild Night of Debauchery, butt plugs and all.

Erotic Couplings 12/15/2015

A Teacher's Sin Uncovered Ch. 02

Where I'm in the Principal's Office, on My Knees.

NonConsent/Reluctance 12/11/2015

Office Slave, Obedient Gift

A submissive secretary is loaned for the night.

BDSM 12/08/2015

Property of the Master Ch. 02

Dressed up and learning to walk in heels.

Transsexuals & Crossdressers 11/28/2015

Passion with a Younger Man

Grace's mother visits and gets physical with stepson.

Mature 11/25/2015

Getting Even with Evie Ch. 02

She begins to see how she has been transformed.

Anal 11/19/2015

The Boys Next Door Ch. 05

Diana gets the first part of her graduation present.

Group Sex 11/12/2015

Victorious Victoria

Submissive male struggles to win a contest for his Mistress.

BDSM 11/10/2015

The Bondage Secret

Tina accepts the gift of dominance & submission.

BDSM 11/10/2015

Changes Ch. 09

Final chapter and the ultimate bondage and submission.

Transsexuals & Crossdressers 10/25/2015

Inductive Orgasms Ch. 04

Induction of Sophi.

Incest/Taboo 10/24/2015

Changes Ch. 08

Stephanie comes out to friends. Gets "pegged" by Sarah.

Transsexuals & Crossdressers 10/23/2015

Blackmailed into Humiliation

A young man finds himself humiliated by a group of girls.

Transsexuals & Crossdressers 10/03/2015

Changes Ch. 05

First time En femme in public with Sarah.

Transsexuals & Crossdressers 10/03/2015

Later Discovery Ch. 03

Mature lady moves even further into new erotic territory.

Fetish 10/03/2015

The Ethical Slutmaker Ch. 06

Alexis persuades mayoral candidate Rhonda to open up.

Mind Control 10/02/2015

Later Discovery

Mature lady rediscovers sexuality in girdles and corsets.

Fetish 09/28/2015

Jefferson's Therapy Ch. 02

Dr. Benoit makes Jefferson beg for a stocking gag.

Fetish 09/23/2015

A Tranny Whores Tale: Bambi Banga

Another adventure with a sultry transgendered whore.

Transsexuals & Crossdressers 09/02/2015

Table for Three

Cheating wife gets punished by husband.

NonConsent/Reluctance 09/01/2015

Day Shades in the Day

He jerks off while looking out over a busy parking lot.

Exhibitionist & Voyeur 08/31/2015

Latter Day Sinners

Two LDS Gays spread more than the word of God with a stud.

Gay Male 08/29/2015

Geeks Rule Ch. 01

A trip down memory lane.

Romance 08/25/2015

Dinner in Chicago Pt. 03

She continues to toy with him in a semi-public setting.

BDSM 08/21/2015

Superior Mistress Session 01

Diary of serving my Mistress as she chooses.

BDSM 08/20/2015

Dinner in Chicago Pt. 02

Femdom date continues public humiliation of male sub.

BDSM 08/20/2015

Ægir's Wife Ch. 01

A happy home-'coming'...or is it?

BDSM 08/18/2015

Dinner in Chicago Pt. 01

His femdom dinner date exploits her control to expose him.

BDSM 08/18/2015

Hadley's Other Cherry Ch. 03

Prom night finally arrives & Jack takes Hadley's anal cherry.

Anal 08/13/2015

What the Hell's Happening Ch. 12-13

Lights, camera... Ch. 12 &13.

Loving Wives 08/12/2015

The Ex's Fault - Redux Ch. 05

Darcy finishes the story.

Erotic Couplings 08/11/2015

First Little Piggy Pt. 02

Anybody for a truffle hunt?

Fetish 08/11/2015

A New Life

A glimpse into a woman's life as a captive slave.

NonConsent/Reluctance 07/26/2015

Hadley's Other Cherry Ch. 02

Hadley trains her virgin ass for Jack's big cock.

Anal 07/22/2015

First Little Piggy Pt. 01

Adult twist on a classic.

Fetish 07/19/2015

Hadley's Other Cherry Ch. 01

Jack introduces his tiny teen gymnast to anal pleasure.

Anal 07/19/2015

A Slut Got Fucked Pt. 03

Slut had a fucking good evening.

Group Sex 07/16/2015

A Slut Got Fucked Pt. 02

She gets fucked again in bright daylight.

Group Sex 07/15/2015

A Slut Got Fucked

Three men fuck a slut a whole night.

Group Sex 07/12/2015

Swing Chronicles Ch. 09: Josh and Sharon

A Blast of a Blizzard with Josh and Sharon.

Group Sex 07/10/2015

Surprise Visit Pt. 02

Part 2 of Allison's surprise visit with Marcus.

Erotic Couplings 07/10/2015
Active tags
butt plug
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ
Related Tags