‘first anal’ stories

Active tags
anal (22)hairy man (15)armpit licking (14)huge cock (13)older man (12)rimming (11)double penetration (10)frottage (10)oral (9)hairy pussy (9)analingus (9)first time (8)size differences (8)threesome (8)gay anal (8)rough anal (7)anal virgin (7)small penis (7)creampie (7)big cock (7)18-year-old (6)outdoor sex (6)mmf (6)bdsm (6)older/younger (5)anal sex (5)twink (5)love (5)anal first time (5)uncut cock (5)mature (4)cunnilingus (4)motel sex (4)forced (4)gay first time (4)humiliation (4)hirsute man (4)voyeurism (4)rough (4)dirty talk (4)milf (4)gay age difference (4)rough sex (4)size difference (4)first time gay (4)mutual masturbation (3)first oral (3)deepthroat (3)hairy legs (3)younger man (3)bisexual (3)wife (3)blowjob (3)hairy armpits (3)ffm (3)huge breasts (3)virgin ass (3)submissive (3)tied up (3)first time anal (3)public sex (3)gay twink (3)gay incest (3)bear and twink (3)cock sucking (3)cheating (3)older man younger man (3)reach around (3)forced anal (3)two men one woman (3)first blowjob (3)long cock (2)first threesome (2)bisexual husband (2)gift (2)holiday (2)submission (2)romance novella (2)australia (2)male domination (2)gay older man (2)smooth twink (2)oral sex (2)lingerie (2)older woman (2)orgasm (2)dp (2)hairy chest (2)orgy (2)age difference (2)voyeur (2)gangbang (2)female masturbation (2)spanking (2)reluctance (2)gilf (2)stranger (2)beach (2)strap-on (2)pussy licking (2)sucking (2)indian (2)fucking (2)lesbians (2)hardcore (2)toys (2)cum filled ass (2)small cock (2)virgin (2)bondage (2)seduction (2)mistaken identity (2)bear (2)school dress (2)group (2)gay younger man (2)tranny (2)group sex (2)wife swapping (2)cousin (2)teasing (2)1970s (2)hair fetish (2)well hung (2)well hung daddy (2)confessions (2)natural woman (2)strip poker (2)deep throat (2)shaving (2)bikini (2)mentor/protege (2)armpit hair (2)white sheets (2)cheating wife (2)hairy woman (2)younger woman (2)second person pov (2)dominant man (2)painal (2)blow job (2)rubbing cocks (2)penis envy (2)gay voyeur (2)bareback (2)married (2)internet sex (1)roger quickly (1)island (1)face sitting (1)mild domination (1)heat (1)taboo (1)bonding (1)nurse (1)damonx (1)cowgirl anal (1)fingering herself (1)loving oral (1)father and daughter first time (1)revenge (1)black and white (1)physical exam (1)college sex (1)car (1)faint (1)teacher/student (1)sharing (1)travel (1)perfect body (1)friend's wife (1)balls deep (1)daddy/twink (1)orphan (1)boss (1)massage (1)pay (1)breast sucking (1)fantasy (1)gay (1)special bond (1)man to man sex (1)bisexual father (1)watching parents (1)handcuffs (1)voyeur neighbors (1)smooth body (1)forced sex (1)bare back fucking (1)daughter seduces mother (1)big breasts (1)tit wank (1)first person (1)theater fondling (1)old man/young lad (1)come in mouth (1)banana boobs (1)well endowed (1)growers (1)impregnate (1)big cock worship (1)gay anal sex (1)shaved pussy (1)gay oral (1)armpit (1)high heels (1)gay grandson (1)busty teen (1)canadian setting (1)drunk (1)hirsute girl (1)overpowered (1)cottage encounter (1)young woman (1)seduced by older (1)wife becomes a whore. (1)anal wife (1)jacuzzi (1)forced cocksucking (1)chubby guy (1)football (1)ball gag (1)beauty and the beast (1)female erotic audio (1)non-consensual (1)uncle seducing (1)fffmm (1)butt plug (1)continuation (1)straight anal (1)puppy love (1)vagina (1)mistress (1)
first anal

Back Rub

A husband's back rub turns into something unexpected.

Anal 11/30/2017

Breaking Clichés Ch. 08

A trip to a snowy mountain, part 1.

Erotic Couplings 10/29/2017

Married Guy Fucks Me... Hard

The Married Guy had his first gay anal experience.

Gay Male 10/26/2017

Jack's Dad

Jack seduces his dad.

Incest/Taboo 09/07/2017

Just for You Ch. 02

Ed takes a more active role.

Gay Male 07/12/2017

People Can Only Label Themselves

College roommate discovers I've never tried anal sex.

Gay Male 05/12/2017

Sarah the Hairy Princess

Fond memories of the sheltered girl next door.

Fetish 05/08/2017

Threat of Foreclosure Ch. 05

New playmates arrive and Tanya gets initiated.

Lesbian Sex 04/02/2017

Dominated by a TS mistress

My first time meeting with a dominant Tgirl.

Transsexuals & Crossdressers 03/25/2017

Sentenced to the Church Youth Group

Parents decide their slacker teen needs guidance.

Gay Male 12/27/2016

Turning 20: The Perfect Celebration

Dan's 20th birthday was taken to the next level by his pals.

Group Sex 12/21/2016

Loving my Cousin

Falling for my cousin was easy.

Incest/Taboo 11/13/2016

Jeff and Paige

Love between and older man and a young woman.

Anal 10/12/2016

Caffeine and Miss Forgetful

A modern love story.

Transsexuals & Crossdressers 09/18/2016

Riley's Exploits Pt. 10

The Conference Part Three.

Group Sex 09/06/2016

A Sexual Awakening

Stretching my asshole.

Anal 09/06/2016

Butterball

Old man read his friend's grandson like a book.

Gay Male 08/22/2016

Muskoka

Over a weekend, two teenagers use sex to discover each other.

Anal 07/31/2016

One Night Out

Pain and pleasure, fear and fantasy.

BDSM 05/25/2016

Don't Fuck With Father Cahill

Parishioner gets caught in a compromising position

NonConsent/Reluctance 05/04/2016

Alice Grey: An Awakening Ch. 02

Alice returns home to her furious boyfriend, Todd...

Anal 04/22/2016

Dr. Baxter's Bizarre Practice

Out in the sticks the medical options were few.

Fetish 03/15/2016

Cathy and Kim

Picking up two females, 1 female 1 both.

Transsexuals & Crossdressers 02/01/2016

Curious Chelsea and Bad Grandpa

Teen caught snooping in her grandparents' bedroom.

Incest/Taboo 10/29/2015

Resistance is Futile

Sleep won't come for the lad in bed with a snoring stranger.

Gay Male 10/28/2015

The Corningwood Family Chronicles Ch. 03: Blake and Clive

Claire has her first threesome with Blake and Clive.

Group Sex 10/23/2015

A Year Ago Ch. 15

Sara Dates George.

Transsexuals & Crossdressers 10/14/2015

Texting Gets... Real

A cyber Sub/Dom Relationship gets out of control.

BDSM 09/15/2015

A Dream is a Wish Your Heart Makes

She gets back in the game, and better than before.

Anal 08/05/2015

My BFF Buster

A Dog brings us together.

Anal 07/07/2015

How You Want It Mr. Cable?

A young man looks through the slats of the barn.

Gay Male 06/18/2015

Swati, New at Office Ch. 02

Swati explores live-in nude and anal.

Anal 06/05/2015

Out For A Walk Ch. 03

This time they stay in bed.

Incest/Taboo 06/03/2015

Becoming a Cock Slut

My initiation to anal sex.

Gay Male 05/19/2015

Different With Men

Adam gets seduced by his employer.

Gay Male 03/22/2015

Admiring the Gardener

The mother of Mike's friend dressed casually in the yard.

Anal 03/07/2015

Endless Desire

Two married men make their fantasies a reality.

Gay Male 01/27/2015

Comings and Goings

She tells you her fantasies as she touches herself.

Humor & Satire 12/26/2014

Saving the Sexy Parts: Anal

Nina experiences anal sex for the first time.

Text With Audio 12/24/2014

Big Things Cum in Small Packages Ch. 02

Genevieve gets fucked in the ass for the first time ever.

Anal 12/20/2014

Pam's Here All Week

Plump teen has a fan in an older man.

Mature 12/11/2014

Community Involvement Ch. 12

An unexpected call from Michelle demands attention.

Erotic Couplings 11/23/2014

Peach Fuzz: Henry Goes To Church

After a rousing service the old man is aroused.

Mature 11/13/2014

A Special Gift for Christmas - A Holiday Story

Wife and Husband Give Special Christmas / Anniversary Gif.

Anal 11/11/2014

Hanson House Ch. 09

Grace's tits get more but the staff take Elissa's arse.

Anal 11/05/2014

Community Involvement Ch. 09

Daph asks me to take her rear.

Erotic Couplings 10/05/2014

A Teachable Moment

The professor educates his student.

Anal 10/01/2014

Yes, Again Ch. 04

She is put to a new use.

BDSM 09/27/2014

Chubby Gordon Needs a Friend

College student alone in a new city.

Gay Male 09/11/2014

Reconnecting Ch. 07

A woman unleashed and unquenchable continues to play.

Erotic Couplings 09/06/2014

While the Wife's Upstairs

The man of the house invited the paper boy in for a pop.

Gay Male 09/02/2014

Back For More

A young man liked what happened in his neighbor's apartment.

Gay Male 08/07/2014

A Thorn in the Rosebud

An older man takes my anal virginity.

Anal 07/17/2014

Dressed So

A beautiful lesbian finds love.

Transsexuals & Crossdressers 07/17/2014

Tequila Sunrise

Snow storm creates a drunken encounter.

Erotic Couplings 07/16/2014

The Birthday Gift

A handyman's dream.

Anal 07/15/2014

Behind The Rectory

Young man gets caught by Father Scarff at a bad time

Gay Male 07/14/2014

Playing With Brittany Ch. 02

Brittany loses her anal virginity as the result of a dare.

Anal 07/14/2014

Grandpa's Chubby Granddaughter

As Patty matured his lust became overwhelming.

Incest/Taboo 06/08/2014

The Debt

There was only one way to pay him back.

NonConsent/Reluctance 01/15/2014

Almost Daddy

The new neighbor was perfect for my Mom, except...

Gay Male 12/19/2013

In or Out?

Standing at the door of a cheap motel room with a stranger.

Gay Male 12/17/2013

Reflections

Her quest to see orgasms.

Anal 12/12/2013

Grandma's Got a Boyfriend Ch. 04

In the end, Ted takes Jeremy at last.

Gay Male 12/07/2013

An Ordinary Man's Life Ch. 09

Donna offers Todd her anal cherry.

Romance 11/20/2013

8 Days: Day 2 - FTDS

All's Fair in Love and War - sequel to DamonX's 8 Days.

Anal 08/22/2013

Never Did This Before

Older gentleman moves into a Seniors' Community.

Gay Male 07/12/2013

First Time For Everything

Timmy's was with Chester with the Chevy Corvair.

Gay Male 07/08/2013

Curio Shoppe

The path to my first gay encounter was a bumpy one.

Fetish 07/04/2013

Young and Naive

A teen's first trip to an adult movie house.

Gay Male 07/03/2013

Fawn's Friend

Daughter brings her roommate home for the holidays.

Mature 07/03/2013

Annie in the Tropics

Holiday encounter with another couple.

Group Sex 05/21/2013

Secret Love

A story of two men whose relationship was special.

Gay Male 05/19/2013

Grandpa's Man Cave

Glenn's snooping unearths another side of his grandfather.

Gay Male 04/27/2013

Becky Was A Virgin

Her virginity wasn't what the neighbor wanted.

Anal 03/24/2013

Gone Fishing

A long-time ritual with my best friend and his Dad changes.

Gay Male 03/19/2013

Suja Aunty - First & Best

None better than a lovely aunt - a tale of love & lust.

First Time 03/18/2013

You Can Call Me Dad

A young man and his future stepfather get better acquainted.

Gay Male 02/26/2013

Camping in The Summer of 1984

Derek's dreaded week with the family gets strange.

Gay Male 01/30/2013

Experimental Anal

First-time anal among young lovers.

Anal 01/20/2013

After the Graduation Party

Austin gets a nocturnal visit from his Uncle Lloyd.

Gay Male 01/07/2013

Grandma and Jack: The Whole Story

Grandma blamed it all on old demon alcohol.

Incest/Taboo 12/09/2012

Runaway

Teen on the road needs a friend after heartbreak.

Gay Male 11/20/2012

Carson's Last Summer

Just-retired teacher has a fan in a college bound student.

Gay Male 11/19/2012

Backwoods Adventure

Cousins explore in the Adirondacks.

Gay Male 11/12/2012

Easy Pickings

Men found Andy ready and there for the taking.

Gay Male 11/11/2012

Huddled Together Ch. 08

You Should Never Go Home Again.

Sci-Fi & Fantasy 08/23/2012

Colony Art Theatre

Picked up by a fellow movie goer.

Gay Male 06/08/2012

Walt and Rhonda Ch. 11

Rhonda finally gives her ass to Walt.

Anal 04/15/2012

Snowball's Chance

Valentine's Day snowstorm brings us all together.

Anal 01/25/2012

Coach's Decision

High school soccer career ends on a high note.

Gay Male 01/14/2012

Five Nights Ch. 04

Sue gets her night.

Group Sex 07/30/2011

Bad Penny Ch. 04

A swinging relationship spiralling out of control.

Group Sex 07/25/2011

Lucky Girl Ch. 02

Becca has to finish a science project.

Erotic Couplings 06/29/2011

My Science Teacher, Mr. Duke

An after graduation pep talk becomes more than inspiration.

Gay Male 06/11/2011

In The Barn

18-year-old guy watches the farmhand with another man.

Gay Male 06/07/2011

Exiled To Grandpa's Farm

Two weeks seems like forever when you're 18.

Gay Male 06/02/2011

Daddy In the Dark

The visitor wasn't the monster from under the bed.

Gay Male 05/25/2011

If I Knew Then... Ch. 09

Eighteen again, but not so innocent - loving every moment.

Erotic Couplings 05/22/2011

Dad's Looking for Love

Jilted hubby seeks companionship on the net.

Incest/Taboo 04/17/2011
12
Active tags
first anal
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ
Related Tags