‘first time gay anal’ stories

New to Cock

Straight guy goes to a bi massage parlor.

Group Sex 05/27/2016

First Time Anal

Bathhouse Fun.

Gay Male 05/25/2016

Too Horny to Study

Carley desperately needs to get off so she can focus.

Group Sex 09/13/2012

Meatings Ch. 01

Black married guy takes bicurious white married guy.

Gay Male 03/17/2007

Fun in the Forest

His virgin ass was waiting for Frank.

Gay Male 06/19/2006

Bum Chums Have Fun In The Sun

A virgin stud loses his cherry to 4 hot men on the beach.

Gay Male 06/17/2006

Big Bot, Sex Hot, Breeder Gets Laid

Sex-starved guy gives in to gay colleague's desire.

Gay Male 10/14/2005

Married Men Slip Away for Gay Sex

They might be married, but they still like cock.

Gay Male 07/22/2005
Active tags
first time gay anal
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ